Article View: ab.general
Article #27720Re: News Release: Delwin (relevance & *all laws*)
From: HiThere
Date: Thu, 09 Apr 1998 00:00
Date: Thu, 09 Apr 1998 00:00
29 lines
2555 bytes
2555 bytes
In article <gall-0904981208020001@usrts1m4.uwinnipeg.ca>, gall@uwinnipeg.ca (Norman Gall) wrote: >In article <6giu5c$f6v$1@usenet54.supernews.com>, HiThere@outtatown.com >(HiThere) wrote: >Or that person otherwise has a duty (role responsibility) to render help - >i.e., police officer. > Police officers choose the contract. >> I can't do that to someone without asserting that others have the right to do > >> that to me. Why would I want to do that? > >I think you are confusing perfect right and imperfect rights. One might >have the right to life, but it might be that no one individual has the >obligation to provide for it. Not every right generates a *specific* >individual obligation. > >And some obligations are not generated by someone's specific individual >right. It might come from a duty. > It just seems to me that *duty* is the subjective word we use to impose a positive obligation when--as you describe--there _is_ no objective basis in individual rights for the imposition. Ron
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<6gj6ff$3uu$1@usenet85.supernews.com>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!unknown!not-for-mailReferences:
<Pine.A41.3.95.980402125511.30972D-100000@fn2.freenet.edmonton.ab.ca> <gall-0204981606260001@usrts2m2.uwinnipeg.ca> <6g2kq8$p8u$1@usenet47.supernews.com> <gall-0304981020220001@usrts1m10.uwinnipeg.ca> <3528F6F2.8534CDCF@netcom.com> <gall-0604981141300001@usrts2m3.uwinnipeg.ca> <6gc9op$q7i$1@usenet53.supernews.com> <gall-0704980053300001@usrts1m7.uwinnipeg.ca> <6gdo4d$jq6$1@usenet88.supernews.com> <gall-0704981351160001@usrts1m7.uwinnipeg.ca> <6ge0e2$ldg$1@usenet53.supernews.com> <gall-0704981602460001@usrts1m9.uwinnipeg.ca> <6gemod$ie$1@usenet50.supernews.com> <6gfokd$b7$1@usenet87.supernews.com> <gall-0804981336070001@usrts2m3.uwinnipeg.ca> <6gh1cu$185$1@usenet58.supernews.com> <gall-0804981854480001@usrts1m3.uwinnipeg.ca> <6giu5c$f6v$1@usenet54.supernews.com> <gall-0904981208020001@usrts1m4.uwinnipeg.ca>Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit X-Google-Thread: fb374,bcf571f59d59f073 X-Google-Attributes: gidfb374,public X-Google-Thread: fb1ea,bcf571f59d59f073 X-Google-Attributes: gidfb1ea,public X-Google-Thread: 112f74,bcf571f59d59f073 X-Google-Attributes: gid112f74,public X-Google-Thread: fb626,bcf571f59d59f073 X-Google-Attributes: gidfb626,public From: HiThere@outtatown.com (HiThere) Subject: Re: News Release: Delwin (relevance & *all laws*) Date: 1998/04/09 Message-ID: <6gj6ff$3uu$1@usenet85.supernews.com> X-Deja-AN: 342502863 Sender: @209.5.143.85 References: <Pine.A41.3.95.980402125511.30972D-100000@fn2.freenet.edmonton.ab.ca> <gall-0204981606260001@usrts2m2.uwinnipeg.ca> <6g2kq8$p8u$1@usenet47.supernews.com> <gall-0304981020220001@usrts1m10.uwinnipeg.ca> <3528F6F2.8534CDCF@netcom.com> <gall-0604981141300001@usrts2m3.uwinnipeg.ca> <6gc9op$q7i$1@usenet53.supernews.com> <gall-0704980053300001@usrts1m7.uwinnipeg.ca> <6gdo4d$jq6$1@usenet88.supernews.com> <gall-0704981351160001@usrts1m7.uwinnipeg.ca> <6ge0e2$ldg$1@usenet53.supernews.com> <gall-0704981602460001@usrts1m9.uwinnipeg.ca> <6gemod$ie$1@usenet50.supernews.com> <6gfokd$b7$1@usenet87.supernews.com> <gall-0804981336070001@usrts2m3.uwinnipeg.ca> <6gh1cu$185$1@usenet58.supernews.com> <gall-0804981854480001@usrts1m3.uwinnipeg.ca> <6giu5c$f6v$1@usenet54.supernews.com> <gall-0904981208020001@usrts1m4.uwinnipeg.ca> Organization: All USENET -- http://www.Supernews.com Newsgroups: ab.general,can.legal,ab.politics,can.politics