🚀 go-pugleaf

RetroBBS NetNews Server

Inspired by RockSolid Light RIP Retro Guy

Thread View: at.freizeit.sf.startrek
2 messages
2 total messages Started by . Wed, 10 Dec 2008 09:22
[Buecher] Star Trek Destiny Band 3: Lost Souls (Spoiler)
#128
Author: .
Date: Wed, 10 Dec 2008 09:22
242 lines
13997 bytes
Baerbel Haddrell
============

Dies ist meine Besprechung des dritten und letzten Bandes der Destiny 
Trilogie: Lost Souls von David Mack.



S P O I L E R

After having read the second book of the Destiny trilogy I was very much 
looking forward to the next and last book. I could see that a lot of my 
speculations were right but I had no idea when I started reading this 
book how much further the story would go and how much richer this 
trilogy would become. In spite of a few criticisms I had this is an 
amazing series that opens the door to a lot of potential.

I want to get into more detail after I had a closer look at what 
happened in �Lost Souls�. There are four main storylines in this book:


AVENTINE (Captain Ezri Dax)

Especially in this book I could see that Ezri Dax matured in ways I find 
amazing and I welcome this very much. Her confidence has grown even more 
and it is great to see how she is finding her full potential. I am very 
much looking forward to read more about this remarkable captain and her 
crew.

This book showed a lot of the battles she and her crew fought against 
the Borg, their bravery, their sacrifices, the highs but also the lows. 
I think it was a good idea to include the topic friendly fire in this 
book, too. I very much felt for Kedair and when I read that she went 
back to make up for her mistake was sure she would indeed sacrifice 
herself. I was pleasantly surprised that David Mack didn`t follow that 
path and used that clich�. I prefer it when people survive and have to 
face the consequences of their actions. Dax speech put me off first 
because she sounded overly cruel to me but then I thought about it and 
realized that Dax was right with everything she said and Kedair needed 
the push that speech gave her. The expression �cruel to be kind� came to 
my mind. I think this scene showed that Captain Dax is still a skilled 
counsellor.


TITAN (Captain William Riker)

Inyx approached Deanna the way Dr. Ree should have by calmly discussing 
her options with him. I am glad that David Mack chose the best possible 
outcome, by not only healing Deanna but also her baby. That Inyx also 
rejuvenated a lot of her inner organs is a nice bonus.

I don`t know if editors and authors consider this matter closed now but 
I have the gut feeling that this is very likely the case. I am very 
happy with this outcome but nevertheless, I can`t forget that at the 
very least under certain circumstances a CMO can order a woman to have 
an abortion. I know, it was not an illegal order but I still think, it 
should be illegal. I feel very strongly about this but I realized during 
discussions that I am obviously in a minority.

At the very least, I hope that future books will address Dr. Ree`s 
experiences and his efforts to learn from them. I think the handled 
Deanna`s case very badly but he is a good person and even in his clumsy, 
unthinking way he tried to do his best for his patient.

I wonder what other surprises Inyx left behind. I wonder, is Deanna`s 
baby really completely normal?

Seeing Deanna and Riker back together and happy was nice.



ENTERPRISE (Captain Jean-Luc Picard)

I found the character arc in this book very interesting and moving. He 
was able to be the voice of reason that Ezri Dax listened to but I could 
also see from early on that Picard was getting closer to reaching his 
breaking point. The scene when he looked at his burned out ready room 
(�Time is the fire in which we burn�), it touched me a lot.

I think the comparison some people made, that the Borg are Picard`s 
Kryptonite, fits very well. I could see that the threat of the Borg 
literally sucked the strength out of Picard. Each time Picard was 
worried that Dax plan to install Captain Hernandez as a new Borg Queen 
might make matters worse, I wondered how that would be possible. What 
had the Federation, what had all the other civilizations of that region 
to lose? Annihilation was just hours away.

I think Worf failed his captain here. His job is not just honouring his 
captain by supporting him but also to be a voice of reason, someone who 
challenges the captain when it is needed. He should have pointed out 
much stronger that he disagrees with him and that he supports Dax plan. 
And when Picard was ordering the construction of the thalaron weapon, a 
metagenic superweapon, Worf disagreed even more but, this time, did not 
speak up at all. Instead it was Geordi who refused to obey this not only 
highly dangerous but also illegal order. I loved that scene! It is 
probably the best Geordi scene I have ever read or seen. It showed 
Geordi`s deep respect, his friendship with his captain but also his 
determination to do what is right and to accept the consequences. It was 
extremely powerful and touching.

Everybody has his or her breaking point. Picard`s threshold is very 
high. He has shown in the past how strong, how experienced, how cunning 
he is. At the same time, Picard had to handle serious personal losses 
and especially one trauma also most Starfleet officers can barely 
imagine. He emerged healed each time but the mental scars will never 
disappear. All Picard can do is being aware of them and be on his guard. 
But this time, it became too much and I can`t blame him for being so 
vulnerable when he was about to lose everything and having failed to 
keep his guard against his weakness up.

It shows that Picard is a human being with strengths and weaknesses. He 
is not a Borg. He is also not an action hero with underdeveloped 
feelings. It is his humanity that makes Picard interesting, likeable and 
worthy of respect, his battle to also deal with weaknesses, to learn 
from them and to grow. That makes a good captain but this book also 
shows what a good captain also needs: support. It showed the strong bond 
Picard has with his wife and with officers like Geordi. Especially now 
that the Kryptonite no longer exists I think what happened will make him 
stronger, it will forge a stronger bond with his crew and I think his 
experiences will help to be a good father to his son when he is born. I 
also think that Worf learned important lessons that will enable him to 
be a better first officer in future and hopefully, one day, a captain of 
his own ship.

The use of the thalaron weapon wouldn`t have been an effective weapon 
against the Borg. I think no weapon would have worked, even if there 
would have been an even deadlier one. Yes, maybe (and that is a very big 
maybe) it could have been used once and it could have destroyed 
hundreds, maybe more, Borg ships. But it would not have saved humanity 
or anybody else. It would also be a suicide weapon. It would only make 
the Borg more determined to get rid of this threat but Picard would no 
longer be alive to see it.

The Borg as described in the trilogy reminded me of a disease, a cancer 
that continued to grow and turned something positive into something 
ugly, menacing and ultimately fatal. I like the idea that the Borg 
needed healing instead of futile attempts at extermination very much. 
The way the Caeliar embraced and healed the Borg was beautifully written 
and the ideal way to bring the Borg story arc to a conclusion.

The way I see it, the Caeliar were the last hope humanity and all the 
other civilizations on the same level had against the Borg. Picard had 
the choice to face the end without losing himself, the person he is or 
give up hope. Picard definitely failed this test but fortunately his 
fellow officers, his friends, were there beside him and help him.

It was nice to see how Picard and Beverly were now looking forward to 
the future and happy. Picard, Dax and Riker � what these three captains 
went through together forged an even stronger friendship. I think that 
was very visible in this book and I enjoyed reading about it.


COLUMBIA (Captain Erika Hernandez)

After we learned about the history of Captain Hernandez captivity David 
Mack was now looking at what happened to the other group of survivors 
who left the disaster zone in a different city.

I had a gut feeling from early on that the Borg and the Caeliar are 
related, a gut feeling that grew stronger the more I learned. 
Nevertheless, I know now that I nevertheless had no idea but on the 
other hand, everything made so much sense to me. Nothing felt 
constructed, nothing felt like technobabble.

I think the origin David Mack showed here is so powerful because it 
didn`t happen by design. It is the result of tragic circumstances with 
results nobody could have predicted. What it shows, though, is how 
powerful the urge to survive in humans and Caeliar are. This is 
something both species have in common. When driven to the edge, some 
individuals are able to do extraordinary things in order to survive. 
Sedin was not responsible for her actions. She acted on instinct, as the 
Caeliar in the first book did who was starving on the wreck of the 
Columbia.

The idea of including the former Borg into the Caeliar is a wonderful 
idea but I hope at the same time that the Caeliar didn`t forget their 
strong beliefs in personal choices and freedom. I hope they gave each 
individual a choice, also the choice to leave and maybe even to be able 
to return to loved ones they left behind when they were assimilated.

 From early on I wondered what would become of Hernandez. She is a very 
powerful individual so that she falls into the category of Wesley, 
Morgan Lefler and McHenry. That means these people either disappear or 
they die. I am glad that in this case she left instead of being killed. 
I hope we will meet the Caeliar including Hernandez again.


OTHERS

It was touching to read how President Bacco dealt with the crisis, how 
she kept looking for answers, how she finally accepted her fate and was 
determined to face it with dignity and when, like a miracle, the threat 
vanished literally within one minute before the Borg would have 
destroyed Earth. It showed the strength of this remarkable woman but 
also her sense of humour. I liked the idea of having a last meal before 
the end.

We learned that the Voyager was left behind in bad condition, that 
Chakotay was left in critical condition by the Borg attack and that many 
people died on board. I am looking forward to �Full Circle�, the book 
that will tell us what happened to these people. I was already left 
wondering about Seven � or Annika Hansen. It was interesting to read 
that only Bacco really had the courage and compassion to help her when 
she lost her Borg implants. The Caeliar obviously did not only dissolve 
the Borg parts, they also regenerated what the Borg had taken away. It 
will be interesting to see what knowledge Annika still has left and if 
she has really been turned into a child in a woman`s body. I hope not.

I wish I could be able to read the story about the SCE, who saved a 
world from the Borg. I also wish I could learn what else Calhoun and the 
Excalibur did during this war but I couldn`t find anything in this book. 
As much as I enjoyed this trilogy, I would have enjoyed it so much more 
to see Calhoun more involved. I know that the next New Frontier book 
�Treason� has nothing to do with Destiny but I am hoping very much that 
Peter David will deal with this topic in another book.

I remember discussions very well if there should be one day a time in 
present day Star Trek in which the Federation is destroyed and people 
are trying to rebuild what had been lost. As appealing that idea was to 
me on some level, I think having �Dark Star Trek� within the Mirror 
Universe stories is enough and another modern Battlestar Galactica was 
also not something I wanted to see regularly in Star Trek. I think the 
Destiny trilogy found the right middle way: The Federation still exists 
but a lot has been lost and needs to be rebuilt. President Bacco`s 
speech was very moving, very positive. I think that was necessary at 
that point in time. But I am confident that coming books will not show 
us an idealized humanity, not to mention other races, members of the 
Federation or not.

A crisis tends to bring out the best but also the worst in people. 
People tend to bond together in order to fight a common enemy. But that 
enemy is gone now and a lot of people are left who have lost loved ones, 
who have in many cases also lost their world, who are desperate, bitter 
and angry. They can`t even hit back at the enemy. Others will see new 
opportunities. I am sure, there will be power games and power shifts.

The Klingons are badly weakened but I don`t think the Romulans are and 
certainly not the Danteri and Thallion Empire.

I am sure, the present day Star Trek books will be very interesting.

Baerbel Haddrell
NEW & SEALED APPLE IPOD TOUCH 8GB 2ND GEN MB528LL/A
#134
Author: stermen
Date: Mon, 04 May 2009 20:07
264 lines
16162 bytes
NEW & SEALED APPLE IPOD TOUCH 8GB 2ND GEN MB528LL/A

FREE USPS PRIORITY MAIL! BONUS SOFTWARE! CASHBACK!

Click to go

http://rover.ebay.com/rover/1/711-53200-19255-0/1?type=4&campid=5336229480&toolid=10001&customid=&mpre=http%3A%2F%2Felectronics.shop.ebay.com%2Fitems%2FiPod-MP3-Players_%3FBrand%3DApple%252520iPod%26Product%252520Line%3DiPod%252520Touch%26Condition%3DNew%26_dmpt%3DOther_MP3_Players%26_fln%3D1%26_sacat%3D73839%26_ssov%3D1%26_trksid%3Dp3286.c0.m282%26_mPrRngCbx%3D1%26_udlo%3D179.91%26_udhi%3D267.99%26_qi%3DRTM547901



HELLO ALL AND WELCOME TO OUR BUY IT NOW FOR A BRAND NEW, 100% AUTHENTIC AND 
SEALED APPLE IPOD TOUCH! ,
8GB MODEL!! This is the latest and greatest from Apple and the 2ND 
Generation of this wonderful iPod!


As well, this is eligible for live.com's cashback. You can get this iPod for 
about $186!
Please email us if you need assistance on getting the cashback rebate.


Click to go

http://rover.ebay.com/rover/1/711-53200-19255-0/1?type=4&campid=5336229480&toolid=10001&customid=&mpre=http%3A%2F%2Felectronics.shop.ebay.com%2Fitems%2FiPod-MP3-Players_%3FBrand%3DApple%252520iPod%26Product%252520Line%3DiPod%252520Touch%26Condition%3DNew%26_dmpt%3DOther_MP3_Players%26_fln%3D1%26_sacat%3D73839%26_ssov%3D1%26_trksid%3Dp3286.c0.m282%26_mPrRngCbx%3D1%26_udlo%3D179.91%26_udhi%3D267.99%26_qi%3DRTM547901

"." <.@trekdata.demon.co.uk> ha scritto nel messaggio 
news:bTL%k.24433$Fx1.7401@newsfe30.ams2...
> Baerbel Haddrell
> ============
>
> Dies ist meine Besprechung des dritten und letzten Bandes der Destiny 
> Trilogie: Lost Souls von David Mack.
>
>
>
> S P O I L E R
>
> After having read the second book of the Destiny trilogy I was very much 
> looking forward to the next and last book. I could see that a lot of my 
> speculations were right but I had no idea when I started reading this book 
> how much further the story would go and how much richer this trilogy would 
> become. In spite of a few criticisms I had this is an amazing series that 
> opens the door to a lot of potential.
>
> I want to get into more detail after I had a closer look at what happened 
> in �Lost Souls�. There are four main storylines in this book:
>
>
> AVENTINE (Captain Ezri Dax)
>
> Especially in this book I could see that Ezri Dax matured in ways I find 
> amazing and I welcome this very much. Her confidence has grown even more 
> and it is great to see how she is finding her full potential. I am very 
> much looking forward to read more about this remarkable captain and her 
> crew.
>
> This book showed a lot of the battles she and her crew fought against the 
> Borg, their bravery, their sacrifices, the highs but also the lows. I 
> think it was a good idea to include the topic friendly fire in this book, 
> too. I very much felt for Kedair and when I read that she went back to 
> make up for her mistake was sure she would indeed sacrifice herself. I was 
> pleasantly surprised that David Mack didn`t follow that path and used that 
> clich�. I prefer it when people survive and have to face the consequences 
> of their actions. Dax speech put me off first because she sounded overly 
> cruel to me but then I thought about it and realized that Dax was right 
> with everything she said and Kedair needed the push that speech gave her. 
> The expression �cruel to be kind� came to my mind. I think this scene 
> showed that Captain Dax is still a skilled counsellor.
>
>
> TITAN (Captain William Riker)
>
> Inyx approached Deanna the way Dr. Ree should have by calmly discussing 
> her options with him. I am glad that David Mack chose the best possible 
> outcome, by not only healing Deanna but also her baby. That Inyx also 
> rejuvenated a lot of her inner organs is a nice bonus.
>
> I don`t know if editors and authors consider this matter closed now but I 
> have the gut feeling that this is very likely the case. I am very happy 
> with this outcome but nevertheless, I can`t forget that at the very least 
> under certain circumstances a CMO can order a woman to have an abortion. I 
> know, it was not an illegal order but I still think, it should be illegal. 
> I feel very strongly about this but I realized during discussions that I 
> am obviously in a minority.
>
> At the very least, I hope that future books will address Dr. Ree`s 
> experiences and his efforts to learn from them. I think the handled 
> Deanna`s case very badly but he is a good person and even in his clumsy, 
> unthinking way he tried to do his best for his patient.
>
> I wonder what other surprises Inyx left behind. I wonder, is Deanna`s baby 
> really completely normal?
>
> Seeing Deanna and Riker back together and happy was nice.
>
>
>
> ENTERPRISE (Captain Jean-Luc Picard)
>
> I found the character arc in this book very interesting and moving. He was 
> able to be the voice of reason that Ezri Dax listened to but I could also 
> see from early on that Picard was getting closer to reaching his breaking 
> point. The scene when he looked at his burned out ready room (�Time is the 
> fire in which we burn�), it touched me a lot.
>
> I think the comparison some people made, that the Borg are Picard`s 
> Kryptonite, fits very well. I could see that the threat of the Borg 
> literally sucked the strength out of Picard. Each time Picard was worried 
> that Dax plan to install Captain Hernandez as a new Borg Queen might make 
> matters worse, I wondered how that would be possible. What had the 
> Federation, what had all the other civilizations of that region to lose? 
> Annihilation was just hours away.
>
> I think Worf failed his captain here. His job is not just honouring his 
> captain by supporting him but also to be a voice of reason, someone who 
> challenges the captain when it is needed. He should have pointed out much 
> stronger that he disagrees with him and that he supports Dax plan. And 
> when Picard was ordering the construction of the thalaron weapon, a 
> metagenic superweapon, Worf disagreed even more but, this time, did not 
> speak up at all. Instead it was Geordi who refused to obey this not only 
> highly dangerous but also illegal order. I loved that scene! It is 
> probably the best Geordi scene I have ever read or seen. It showed 
> Geordi`s deep respect, his friendship with his captain but also his 
> determination to do what is right and to accept the consequences. It was 
> extremely powerful and touching.
>
> Everybody has his or her breaking point. Picard`s threshold is very high. 
> He has shown in the past how strong, how experienced, how cunning he is. 
> At the same time, Picard had to handle serious personal losses and 
> especially one trauma also most Starfleet officers can barely imagine. He 
> emerged healed each time but the mental scars will never disappear. All 
> Picard can do is being aware of them and be on his guard. But this time, 
> it became too much and I can`t blame him for being so vulnerable when he 
> was about to lose everything and having failed to keep his guard against 
> his weakness up.
>
> It shows that Picard is a human being with strengths and weaknesses. He is 
> not a Borg. He is also not an action hero with underdeveloped feelings. It 
> is his humanity that makes Picard interesting, likeable and worthy of 
> respect, his battle to also deal with weaknesses, to learn from them and 
> to grow. That makes a good captain but this book also shows what a good 
> captain also needs: support. It showed the strong bond Picard has with his 
> wife and with officers like Geordi. Especially now that the Kryptonite no 
> longer exists I think what happened will make him stronger, it will forge 
> a stronger bond with his crew and I think his experiences will help to be 
> a good father to his son when he is born. I also think that Worf learned 
> important lessons that will enable him to be a better first officer in 
> future and hopefully, one day, a captain of his own ship.
>
> The use of the thalaron weapon wouldn`t have been an effective weapon 
> against the Borg. I think no weapon would have worked, even if there would 
> have been an even deadlier one. Yes, maybe (and that is a very big maybe) 
> it could have been used once and it could have destroyed hundreds, maybe 
> more, Borg ships. But it would not have saved humanity or anybody else. It 
> would also be a suicide weapon. It would only make the Borg more 
> determined to get rid of this threat but Picard would no longer be alive 
> to see it.
>
> The Borg as described in the trilogy reminded me of a disease, a cancer 
> that continued to grow and turned something positive into something ugly, 
> menacing and ultimately fatal. I like the idea that the Borg needed 
> healing instead of futile attempts at extermination very much. The way the 
> Caeliar embraced and healed the Borg was beautifully written and the ideal 
> way to bring the Borg story arc to a conclusion.
>
> The way I see it, the Caeliar were the last hope humanity and all the 
> other civilizations on the same level had against the Borg. Picard had the 
> choice to face the end without losing himself, the person he is or give up 
> hope. Picard definitely failed this test but fortunately his fellow 
> officers, his friends, were there beside him and help him.
>
> It was nice to see how Picard and Beverly were now looking forward to the 
> future and happy. Picard, Dax and Riker � what these three captains went 
> through together forged an even stronger friendship. I think that was very 
> visible in this book and I enjoyed reading about it.
>
>
> COLUMBIA (Captain Erika Hernandez)
>
> After we learned about the history of Captain Hernandez captivity David 
> Mack was now looking at what happened to the other group of survivors who 
> left the disaster zone in a different city.
>
> I had a gut feeling from early on that the Borg and the Caeliar are 
> related, a gut feeling that grew stronger the more I learned. 
> Nevertheless, I know now that I nevertheless had no idea but on the other 
> hand, everything made so much sense to me. Nothing felt constructed, 
> nothing felt like technobabble.
>
> I think the origin David Mack showed here is so powerful because it didn`t 
> happen by design. It is the result of tragic circumstances with results 
> nobody could have predicted. What it shows, though, is how powerful the 
> urge to survive in humans and Caeliar are. This is something both species 
> have in common. When driven to the edge, some individuals are able to do 
> extraordinary things in order to survive. Sedin was not responsible for 
> her actions. She acted on instinct, as the Caeliar in the first book did 
> who was starving on the wreck of the Columbia.
>
> The idea of including the former Borg into the Caeliar is a wonderful idea 
> but I hope at the same time that the Caeliar didn`t forget their strong 
> beliefs in personal choices and freedom. I hope they gave each individual 
> a choice, also the choice to leave and maybe even to be able to return to 
> loved ones they left behind when they were assimilated.
>
> From early on I wondered what would become of Hernandez. She is a very 
> powerful individual so that she falls into the category of Wesley, Morgan 
> Lefler and McHenry. That means these people either disappear or they die. 
> I am glad that in this case she left instead of being killed. I hope we 
> will meet the Caeliar including Hernandez again.
>
>
> OTHERS
>
> It was touching to read how President Bacco dealt with the crisis, how she 
> kept looking for answers, how she finally accepted her fate and was 
> determined to face it with dignity and when, like a miracle, the threat 
> vanished literally within one minute before the Borg would have destroyed 
> Earth. It showed the strength of this remarkable woman but also her sense 
> of humour. I liked the idea of having a last meal before the end.
>
> We learned that the Voyager was left behind in bad condition, that 
> Chakotay was left in critical condition by the Borg attack and that many 
> people died on board. I am looking forward to �Full Circle�, the book that 
> will tell us what happened to these people. I was already left wondering 
> about Seven � or Annika Hansen. It was interesting to read that only Bacco 
> really had the courage and compassion to help her when she lost her Borg 
> implants. The Caeliar obviously did not only dissolve the Borg parts, they 
> also regenerated what the Borg had taken away. It will be interesting to 
> see what knowledge Annika still has left and if she has really been turned 
> into a child in a woman`s body. I hope not.
>
> I wish I could be able to read the story about the SCE, who saved a world 
> from the Borg. I also wish I could learn what else Calhoun and the 
> Excalibur did during this war but I couldn`t find anything in this book. 
> As much as I enjoyed this trilogy, I would have enjoyed it so much more to 
> see Calhoun more involved. I know that the next New Frontier book 
>  �Treason� has nothing to do with Destiny but I am hoping very much that 
> Peter David will deal with this topic in another book.
>
> I remember discussions very well if there should be one day a time in 
> present day Star Trek in which the Federation is destroyed and people are 
> trying to rebuild what had been lost. As appealing that idea was to me on 
> some level, I think having �Dark Star Trek� within the Mirror Universe 
> stories is enough and another modern Battlestar Galactica was also not 
> something I wanted to see regularly in Star Trek. I think the Destiny 
> trilogy found the right middle way: The Federation still exists but a lot 
> has been lost and needs to be rebuilt. President Bacco`s speech was very 
> moving, very positive. I think that was necessary at that point in time. 
> But I am confident that coming books will not show us an idealized 
> humanity, not to mention other races, members of the Federation or not.
>
> A crisis tends to bring out the best but also the worst in people. People 
> tend to bond together in order to fight a common enemy. But that enemy is 
> gone now and a lot of people are left who have lost loved ones, who have 
> in many cases also lost their world, who are desperate, bitter and angry. 
> They can`t even hit back at the enemy. Others will see new opportunities. 
> I am sure, there will be power games and power shifts.
>
> The Klingons are badly weakened but I don`t think the Romulans are and 
> certainly not the Danteri and Thallion Empire.
>
> I am sure, the present day Star Trek books will be very interesting.
>
> Baerbel Haddrell 
Thread Navigation

This is a paginated view of messages in the thread with full content displayed inline.

Messages are displayed in chronological order, with the original post highlighted in green.

Use pagination controls to navigate through all messages in large threads.

Back to All Threads