Article View: aus.environment.conservation
Article #6093Re: Gardeners ordered to pull out vegetables and plant grass
From: Herdy
Date: Thu, 05 Oct 1995 00:00
Date: Thu, 05 Oct 1995 00:00
111 lines
6113 bytes
6113 bytes
The following guff appeared in an Australian newsgrp. Please keep US
relevant material in US newsgrps. We don't give a bugger.
Reynold M. de Guzman (deguzman@a.crl.com) wrote:
: When my parents were being sued for their vegetable garden, my mom,
: who is a normally peaceful person battled them in court with some God
: sent lawyers who promote environmentaly healty urban development.
: The Kleinbrook Community Association Inc. ordered her to remove the
: vines that shaded our backyard or be sued. We got sued, but they
: lost. Whoever heard of beans causing such problems.
: The following is the Closed Caption transcript from:
: Channel 13 Eyewitness news 6:00 PM Sep. 29, 1995
: Shara Fryer/Newscaster:
: THEY WERE JUST TRYING TO SAVE A COUPLE OF DOLLARS AND GET A LITTLE
: EXERCISE. BUT INSTEAD, THEY WERE SLAPPED WITH A LAWSUIT. THE FILIPINO
: COUPLE NEVER DARED TO THINK THEIR GREENBEAN GARDEN WOULD CAUSE A
: PROBLEM, BUT IT DID. AND THEY HAD TO GO BEFORE A JUDGE TO SETTLE A
: NEIGHBOR'S COMPLAINTS. VICENTE ARENAS HAS MORE.
: Vincente Arenas/Reporter:
: THE GREENBEAN DEBATE STARTS IN THIS QUIET NORTH HARRIS COUNTY
: NEIGHBORHOOD. TWO YEARS AGO REYNALDO AND SOLEDAD DEGUZMAN PLANTED A
: GARDEN, IN THEIR BACKYARD. DURING COOLER WEATHER, GREENBEAN VINES
: GROW TALL HERE, ALONGSIDE OTHER RARE ASIAN VEGETABLES. BUT A NEXTDOOR
: NEIGHBOR DIDN'T LIKE THE BIG PLANTS...AND STARTED COMPLAINING. VICENTE
: ARENAS/EYEWITNESS NEWS:
: The fuss over the vegetables got so bad, the Kleinbrook Association
: got together and came to the Harris County Courthouse and asked a
: judge to order the de Guzmans to get rid of their garden.
: Reynaldo S. de Guzman:
: These are just some of the examples...I have some herbs...
: Vincente Arenas:
: SO THE DEGUZMAN'S SHOWED UP WITH EVIDENCE IN HAND. GREENBEANS, BITTER
: MELONS, AND A WHOLE LOT MORE.
: Soledad de Guzman/Gardener:
: I didn't think this was a nuisance because actually this gives us a
: kind of exercise and we really enjoyed planting and picking the beans
: you know and I didn't think it was a distraction from the appearance
: of our house.
: Vincente Arenas:
: WHEN IT WAS OVER, THE JUDGE SAID THE DE GUZMAN'S COULD KEEP THEIR
: GARDEN FOR NOW, GREENBEANS AND ALL. IN THE COURTROOM, RUSSELL SIMON
: COMPLAINED THE DE GUZMAN'S VIOLATED KLEINBROOK'S DEED RESTRICTIONS
: WHEN IT CAME TO YARDS. SIMON CALLED THE GARDEN AN EYESORE. BUT
: OUTSIDE, HE WOULDN'T TALK TO US ON CAMERA. (Speaking with Russell
: Simon/Neighbor) I can't get just one statement from you just saying
: what the bottom line is.
: Russell Simon:
: ...not right now...
: Vincente Arenas:
: OFF CAMERA SIMON SAID THE FIGHT'S NOT OVER. HE'S GOING TO A HIGHER
: COURT. MEANTIME THE DEGUZMAN'S PLAN TO COUNTERSUE SIMON FOR THE
: MONEY'S HE COST THEM IN ATTORNEYS' FEES, AND TIME LOST AT WORK. ALL
: TIME LOST AND TROUBLE'S WORTH IT THEY SAY, THEY'VE GOT THEIR GARDEN
: BACK, GREENBEANS AND ALL. VICENTE ARENAS 13 EYEWITNESS NEWS.
: ==============================================================
: What I can't figure out is why are these guys are so mad about beans?
: Some of these community associations are acting unconstitutionally by
: telling us what to plant and what to pull out. It might also be a
: case of discrimination. We took pictures of houses in that same
: subdivision that have plants growing over their fences. The
: Kleinbrook Association did not send any of these people a court order
: to remove their plants. Whatever the case, I'm sick of being harassed
: by deed restrictions and people who can't mind their own business.
: What I hate more than bullies, are bullies that think they can
: intimidate a peaceful family and get away with it because they have
: friends who studies "law". I thank God for the lawyers who took this
: case and shoved their crummy deed restrictions down their throats.
: Hurray for the peaceful gardeners!!!
: To read more about this recent case, got to this WWW page.
: http://www.crl.com/~deguzman/gardenlawsuit/gardenlawsuit.html
: ----------------------------------
: Reynold M. de Guzman
: Email: deguzman@a.crl.com
: WWW: http://www.crl.com/~deguzman
: ----------------------------------
--
Cheers,
Herdy
:-)
================================
Jon Herd
NORTH LAMBTON NSW AUSTRALIA
e-mail:
c9402098@alinga.newcastle.edu.au
================================
"Live Long and Prosper"
--------------------------------
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<44vcuv$hi5@seagoon.newcastle.edu.au>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!unknown!not-for-mailReferences:
<44ioc1$9qb@nntp.crl.com>Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit X-Google-Thread: 10607c,92d5c7fbe4b52293 X-Google-Attributes: gid10607c,public X-Google-Thread: fdaee,92d5c7fbe4b52293 X-Google-Attributes: gidfdaee,public X-Google-Thread: 10fd9b,92d5c7fbe4b52293 X-Google-Attributes: gid10fd9b,public X-Google-Thread: fe925,92d5c7fbe4b52293 X-Google-Attributes: gidfe925,public X-Google-Thread: 109d7b,92d5c7fbe4b52293 X-Google-Attributes: gid109d7b,public X-Google-Thread: 115a1f,92d5c7fbe4b52293 X-Google-Attributes: gid115a1f,public X-Google-Thread: 10df74,92d5c7fbe4b52293 X-Google-Attributes: gid10df74,public X-Google-Thread: 105eab,92d5c7fbe4b52293 X-Google-Attributes: gid105eab,public From: c9402098@alinga.newcastle.edu.au (Herdy) Subject: Re: Gardeners ordered to pull out vegetables and plant grass Date: 1995/10/05 Message-ID: <44vcuv$hi5@seagoon.newcastle.edu.au> X-Deja-AN: 117037612 references: <44ioc1$9qb@nntp.crl.com> followup-to: aus.environment.conservation,ca.environment,fedreg.environ,fj.soc.environment,francom.environnement,git.environment,pa.environment,sci.environment,scot.environment,talk.environment,tw.environment,uiuc.environment,uiuc.misc.environment,uk.environment,za.environment organization: The University of Newcastle newsgroups: aus.environment.conservation,ca.environment,fedreg.environ,fj.soc.environment,francom.environnement,git.environment,pa.environment,sci.environment,scot.environment,talk.environment,tw.environment,uiuc.environment,uiuc.misc.environment,uk.environment,za.environment