Article View: aus.org.efa
Article #1187Re: Computer Age Article: Censorship fight hots up
From: Mark Addinall
Date: Tue, 18 Jun 1996 00:00
Date: Tue, 18 Jun 1996 00:00
116 lines
6230 bytes
6230 bytes
jnunn@pobox.com wrote: : Page 1, Computer Age, Tuesday 18 June 1996 : ------------------------------------------ : CENSORSHIP FIGHT HOTS UP : By Mark Lawrence : On the crest of a wave of celebration among it United States : counterparts, Electronic Frontiers Australia has increased its campaign : against Internet censorship laws that are being considered by the New : South Wales Government. : Electronic Frontiers Australia says tit believes the proposed : legislation, mooted as a model for other states, was "badly drafted, : draconion, indiscriminate and incapable of achieving its aims". Never, Australian politicions could never draught a bad, draconian and indescriminate bit of legislation that was incapable of achieving its aims. If a duly elected government says the Internet is evil, then it must be so. A few thousand of you 'net-nuts' are going to be inconvinience, but heh, tough. Get another hobby, take up gardening. : Campaign manager Greg Taylor said last week's US Federal Court decision : to block the Communications Decency Act, signed into law only four : months ago by President Clinton, was extremely encouraging, although the : US situation was not directly relevant to Australia and had not been the : reason for the campaign launch here. : "He said the group's objections were based on a leaked draft but the : essence of what would be put to the standing committee of the : attorneys-general on 11-12 July by the NSW Attorney-General was worth of : protest. : "First, we believe the new legislation is unnecessary because there are : already laws in existence that cover the subject and which have already : been used to charge and prosecute people for supplying and receivin : objectionable material on the Internet", Taylor said. : "Second, they are talking about something that is not technically : feasible -- they want Internet Service Providers (ISP) to be made : responsible for the information that may be accessed by minors. It's : ridiculous. The ISP is, after all, just a conduit. : "The other major concern is that the draft suggests that ISP's should be : required to do random monitoring of user activity; it's the equivalent : of asking Telstra to random monitor telephone conversations, which is a : grave offence under the relevant legislation," Taylor said. : He said the authorities were attempting to treat the Internet in the : same manner as television, when it clearly was nothing like the same : medium. : The bad content on the Internet was largely invisible to the average : users, he said. Anyone wanting to find the so-called offensive material : had to really look hard. : "This material makes up a tiny percentage of the total and gets far too : much attention -- particularly from the media, I'm afraid." Taylor said : all these factors added up to an indication that the proposals had been : writted by people "who have absolutedly no knowledge or experience of : the Internet". Rubbish. The media always present the facts, and only the facts, and in a well balanced manner as well. The proposals were written up by a well meaning group of people with a wish to improve the greater good. They do not need to be net.wizards to make this descision for us. : The decision by the three-judge US Federal Court last week to block : legislation that was designed to shield children from sexually explicit : ideas and images on the Internet included the finding that Internet : users were entitled to the strongest constitutional protection. : Judge Stewart Dalzell called the Internet " a never-ending worldwide : conversation " and said it "deserves the broadest possible protection " : from Government controls over what is said and seen. The means the same : hands-off protection that the print media gets -- that is, more : protection than given to air or cable broadcasts. : Any attempt to regulate the content of Internet expression, Judge : Dalzell said, could destroy "the global village" while trying to protect : its children. But if just one child is saved... : The bill had been opposed in court by two coalitions: one led by the : American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and another led by the American : Library Association (ALA). : The coalitions include companies doing business on the Internet or : expecting to have such operations; firms such as the major on-line : services and Internet access providers and trade associations. : (* Under new Victorian online laws, our regular Sitiings column has been : changed on legal advice -- Page 4) : ------------------------------------------ : Note spelling errors are probably mine :-)) : James I've got all my bookmarks set to point to pornographic graphics including some pictures of a 10 year old girl and a large dog found in alt.sex.ped... Now all we need is a couple of concerned journo's, a pollie or two. We should be able to dig up a family that has been shcked by porn, and bing-bang-bing, ban the net. I predict an increase in the sale of gardening tools this year. You futures people, buy Victa short. Mark.
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<4q561p$ghl@grissom.powerup.com.au>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!unknown!not-for-mailReferences:
<19960618074416107845@dialup-a3-62.melbourne.netspace.net.au>Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit X-Google-Thread: fa7f6,ed5310d9f37c8123 X-Google-Attributes: gidfa7f6,public X-Google-Thread: f5d9f,ed5310d9f37c8123 X-Google-Attributes: gidf5d9f,public X-Google-Thread: 112213,ed5310d9f37c8123 X-Google-Attributes: gid112213,public X-Google-Thread: 10df0c,ed5310d9f37c8123 X-Google-Attributes: gid10df0c,public X-Google-Thread: 111f60,ed5310d9f37c8123 X-Google-Attributes: gid111f60,public X-Google-Thread: 104b62,ed5310d9f37c8123 X-Google-Attributes: gid104b62,public From: addinall@news.powerup.com.au (Mark Addinall) Subject: Re: Computer Age Article: Censorship fight hots up Date: 1996/06/18 Message-ID: <4q561p$ghl@grissom.powerup.com.au> X-Deja-AN: 160737797 references: <19960618074416107845@dialup-a3-62.melbourne.netspace.net.au> followup-to: aus.org.efa,aus.net.news,aus.politics,melb.general,aus.org.acs,aus.org.waia organization: PowerUp reply-to: addinall@mail.powerup.com.au newsgroups: aus.org.efa,aus.net.news,aus.politics,melb.general,aus.org.acs,aus.org.waia