SEND= Private

Thread View: bit.admin

2 messages

[T] Back to Threads [V] Tree View [G] Group Articles

2 total messages Started by Museum Informatics Project Thu, 01 Sep 1994 21:16

#1147

Author: Museum Informatics Project
Date: Thu, 01 Sep 1994 21:16

10 lines
1062 bytes

If a LISTSERV list is SEND= Private (i.e., only subscribers can post to it),
will postings and responses to the bit.listserv.xxx equivalent newsgroup
be posted to the newsgroup? to the LISTSERV? if the poster is not subscribed?

I.e., is there a configuration of LISTSERV and bit.listserv that doesn't
permit the bit.listserv.xxx to be subscribed, but does recognize individual
posters (who are subscribed) to post messages to LISTSERV via bit.listserv?

Hope that made sense....
Peter

Re: SEND= Private

#1145

Author: Jim McIntosh
Date: Thu, 01 Sep 1994 22:16

35 lines
2637 bytes

In article <345gc2$j92@agate.berkeley.edu>, mip-arch@garnet.berkeley.edu (Museum Informatics Project) says:
>If a LISTSERV list is SEND= Private (i.e., only subscribers can post to it),
>will postings and responses to the bit.listserv.xxx equivalent newsgroup
>be posted to the newsgroup? to the LISTSERV? if the poster is not subscribed?

If the newsgroup is unmoderated, posts will be accepted to the newsgroup
regardless of who posts them -- but only those posts posted by people who
are subscribed to the list will be accepted for distribution to the subscribers.
This can lead to the wierd situation where someone on the mailing list posts
a question and someone responds to the newsgroup -- but the person who
asked the question never sees the answer because the person who responded
is not subscribed to the list.

What many people do is set up the newsgroup as moderated, with the list
address as the moderator address. All posts to the newsgroup will be sent
to the list address. The list owner can then decide to have the list be Send=
Private or Send= Public (or switch between the two as needed). When the
list is set to Send= Private posts from non-subscribers will be returned to
the poster by the listserv with a message explaining why the post was not


>I.e., is there a configuration of LISTSERV and bit.listserv that doesn't
>permit the bit.listserv.xxx to be subscribed, but does recognize individual
>posters (who are subscribed) to post messages to LISTSERV via bit.listserv?

If you have the list set to Send=Private, then those who want to read the
posts in news can set themselves to NOMAIL. They will be able to read
and post in news, and since they are technically subscribers their posts
will be distributed.

Does this answer your question?

Jim McIntosh (jim@american.edu)
The American University
Washington DC 20016-8019 USA

Thread Navigation

This is a paginated view of messages in the thread with full content displayed inline.

Messages are displayed in chronological order, with the original post highlighted in green.

Use pagination controls to navigate through all messages in large threads.

Back to All Threads