🚀 go-pugleaf

RetroBBS NetNews Server

Inspired by RockSolid Light RIP Retro Guy

Article View: ca.environment
Article #5607

BOGUS timber industry commercials

#5607
From: kelly.cowan
Date: Thu, 11 Jul 1996 00:00
64 lines
3608 bytes
To all concerned:

For the past two days, I have witnessed The California Forest Products
Commission advertising their "stewardship" to the environment minutes before
the world news on CBS in two seperate commercials.
The first one showed a major forest fire, then a pleasant-looking woman came
on and said that fires are a major threat to our forests, and that is why
"they" support firefighters' efforts to battle blazes.  Then she went on to
plug for the salvage rider (not mentioning it by name). She said that The
FPC aids firefighters in reducing fires by removing dead timber.  She also
insinuated the timber industry only removes the bad trees that produce
"fuel."

Someone taking advantage of the "fire emergency" that has recently occured
due to fire suppression?

For those of you that are up on fire ecology and proper forest management,
you will be aware this is a line of crap designed to get the cut out and
deflect critisism from the public about the timber industry's support for
bad forestry- and good short-term business.  We know that this commercial
most likely is the result of the hiring of a PR firm, such as
Burston-Marstellar, who specializes in "cleaning up" the reputation of dirty
business interests.

On to the commercial I just saw.

ANOTHER handsome homely woman came on and claimed the timber industry cuts
away from streams (with a lovely visual of a wild stream) to reduce erosion,
keep the water clean, and provide safe cover for thirsty wildlife.

Nice message, but she failed to mention that cutting away from streams was a
law forced by environmentalists.  Companies such as this were the very
people opposed to protecting streamside timber from cutting, and while doing
so, claimed that the action did not threaten the water, wildlife, or cause
erosion!!!!

We have all seen the full page ads and commercials put out by the oil
industry.  Some claimed stewardship to the environment by saying they
developed cleaner gas--all the while they were lobbying behind the scenes to
delay the production of electric vehicles.
Others claimed stewardship by showing beautiful pictures of wild and scenic
areas their companies were forced to preserve because the law required them
to mitigate damage done by setting land aside elsewhere.  Problem is--most
of the areas they preserve are not so scenic and have little value to
wildlife.  Their commercials are as confusing as their message.  LIke "Do
people care about the environment? (Visual of an eagle) People do."

I suspect that the timber industry has a lot more money since salvage sales
are booming now, thanks to The President and 104th congress allowing the
"salvage" rider to make it into law.   Goodness, it must cost a bundle to
run all these commercials and take out full-page ads in major newspapers.  I
wonder why they are doing this??????  I want to know what you think.

Is it

1) Because these are public service announcements
2) Because it is election year and the rebublicans have taken a beating on
the environment.
3) Because the timber industry wants your guard down so they can slip more
"riders" past the public.
4) Because polluters "really care."

Kelly.cowan@ebbs.cts.com
Technical Details
Message-ID: <CAEN.580B@ebbs.cts.com>
Path: arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!unknown!not-for-mail

Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit
X-Google-Thread: 10df74,b04f067563113316,start
X-Google-Attributes: gid10df74,public
From: kelly.cowan@ebbs.cts.com
Subject: BOGUS timber industry commercials
Date: 1996/07/11
Message-ID: <CAEN.580B@ebbs.cts.com>
X-Deja-AN: 168247245
organization: The Environmental BBS, San Diego, CA
newsgroups: ca.environment