Article View: ca.firearms
Article #526NRA-ILA FAX ALERT - Vol. 8, No. 15 4/13/01
From: Neil At Hollywood�.Hom
Date: Fri, 13 Apr 2001 22:18
Date: Fri, 13 Apr 2001 22:18
513 lines
25302 bytes
25302 bytes
This is a multi-part message in MIME format. ------=_NextPart_000_00D4_01C0C42C.C848E740 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable NRA-ILA FAX ALERT=20 Vol. 8, No. 15 4/13/01=20 PREPARE FOR RENEWED ATTACKS ON GUN SHOWS WHEN CONGRESS RETURNS Congress is still on recess for its Easter District Work Period (House = scheduled to return April 20, Senate scheduled to return April 22), so = now is a good time to set up face-to-face meetings with your federal = lawmakers at their district offices. The gun-ban extremists in D.C. have = already set their sights on gun shows, and U.S. Senator Jack Reed = (D-R.I.) is poised to introduce his version of the legislation = championed by former U.S. Senator Frank Lautenberg (D-N.J.) that sought = to end gun shows as we know them today. The Senate will soon take up the = issue of education reform, and we anticipate that Reed and fellow = gun-ban extremists such as U.S. Senators Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.) and = Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) will be working with the gun-ban lobby, HCI, to = attach Reed's assault on gun shows, as well as other anti-gun = amendments, to any education legislation brought up for consideration. = Try to schedule personal meetings with your Senators-or contact them by = letter or phone call-to express your opposition to any assaults on our = Right to Keep and Bear Arms. For those on the Internet, you can also use = the "Write Your Reps" tool at NRAILA.org.=20 Also remember to urge your U.S. Representative to oppose S. 27, the = McCain-Feingold campaign finance "reform" legislation that was passed by = the Senate. This bill would severely restrict our ability to provide = timely information-including information on lawmakers' positions on = firearm-related issues-to our membership and tens of millions of other = law-abiding gun owners.=20 Finally, be sure to contact the offices of both your Senators and your = Representative to see if they have any Town Hall Meetings scheduled over = the next week. If so, be sure to attend, and bring your family, friends, = and fellow gun owners, so that you can take advantage of any = opportunities to express your support for the Second Amendment. If you = learn of any of these meetings, be sure to share the information with = the NRA-ILA Grassroots Division, so we may alert others. To find out = your federal lawmaker's district office number, you can call the U.S. = House switchboard at (202) 225-3121, and the U.S. Senate switchboard at = (202) 224-3121. Just ask for your lawmaker's office, and someone there = will be able to tell you the closest district office to where you live. = Also for those on the Internet, if you go to=20 COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY SET TO HONOR CONTROVERSIAL RESEARCHER Next week, Columbia University will bestow its Bancroft Prize-an award = it touts as "one of the most prestigious awards in the field of = history"-upon Michael Bellesiles of Emory University, author of last = year's "Arming America: The Origins of a National Gun Culture." = Bellesiles's book, according to the author, is a culmination of research = that indicates that most Americans around the time of our country's = formation did not own firearms. This, of course, is contrary to reams of = scholarly research showing that America has always been a nation where = the possession of firearms by responsible, law-abiding citizens has been = widespread.=20 While this book was received with high praise from gun-ban extremists = and the anti-gun media (the New York Times actually gave the book praise = before it was ever released), an editorial by Kimberley Strassel from = the April 5 issue of The Wall Street Journal points out that = Bellesiles's research has been under fire by many respected scholars. = Thus far, however, Bellesiles has refused to produce anything of = substance that would counter the claims of his critics. Gerald = Rosenberg, a visiting professor of law at Northwestern, told Strassel, = "...[T]he evidence is so overwhelming that it is incumbent upon = Bellesiles as a serious scholar to respond. He either has to admit = error, or somehow show how his work is right."=20 UCLA law professor Eugene Volokh has pointed to examples of Bellesiles = either misquoting sources, or citing sources that do not contain the = information the Emory professor claims they contain. Bentley College = history professor Joyce Lee Malcolm, author of "To Keep and Bear Arms: = The Origins of an Anglo-American Right," referred to Bellesiles's use of = travel narratives, which he claims failed to mention the use of guns for = hunting. But Malcolm states that "Arming America" makes no mention of = the same narratives referring to guns outside of the context of hunting. = And Northwestern professor of law James Lindgren tackles what many = reviewers have considered to be the most compelling aspect of Bellesiles = research-his use of probate records, which are basically inventories of = someone's estate at his time of death. Bellesiles claimes his research = shows that only 14.7% of American men, and virtually no women, owned = firearms, and he goes on to claim that most guns were old or broken. But = Lindgren says he went over the same records that Bellesiles cited, and = found that 54% of American men, and 18% of the women, owned firearms, = with no indication that most were listed as old or broken. Lindgren = stated, "No one who has seen the evidence can figure out how he could = have made such errors, or why he has not retracted the obviously = mistaken data."=20 According to Strassel, Bellesiles told her that many of his critics are = "ideologically motivated," but she points out that Rosenberg and = Lindgren all told her that they favor gun control. Bellesiles has also = revealed that he did not keep a database (rather odd in the age of = computers), but kept all his data on paper notes, and he claims these = paper notes were recently destroyed in a flood. Randolph Roth, an = associate history professor at Ohio State who also supports gun control, = examined Lindgren's work on probate records and commented that "it looks = as though Mr. Bellesiles work won't be reproducible."=20 In an effort to present a different view to Bellesiles's, Ron Lewenberg, = President of the Columbia College Conservative Club, has been working = with university officials to try to schedule a panel of researchers and = scholars to discuss "Arming America" next Wednesday, April 18, the day = Bellesiles is scheduled to receive his recognition from the university. = At this time, it is unclear if the school will accommodate this request, = but if it does, tentatively scheduled to appear are Yale professor John = Lott, author of "More Guns, Less Crime: Understanding Crime and Gun = Control Laws," and Clayton Cramer, author of several historical books, = including "For the Defense of Themselves: The Original Intent and = Judicial Interpretation of the Right to Keep and Bear Arms." Bellesiles = declined an invitation to appear as well. We should have more = information on this tentative panel discussion next week, so if you are = interested in finding out more, please call the Grassroots Division at = (800) 392-8683.=20 A LOOK AT THE STATES CALIFORNIA=20 SB 52, a bill that seeks to require licensing of all handgun purchasers, = will be heard by the Senate Public Safety Committee on Tuesday, April = 17. Contact members of the committee and urge them to oppose SB 52. For = a list of committee members, call NRA-ILA Grassroots, or use the "Write = Your Reps" tool at NRAILA.org.=20 FLORIDA=20 SB 412, a bill that seeks to protect firearm manufacturers from = reckless, politically-motivated lawsuits aimed at bankrupting them, = passed the Florida Senate on a vote of 27-12. The bill was immediately = certified to the House and will be awaiting consideration when lawmakers = return from Easter recess next week.=20 LOUISIANA=20 SB 425, a bill that sought to make gun owners criminally liable if a = juvenile gained access to one of their handguns and caused it to = discharge, or used it to harm another-even if that juvenile accessed the = handgun by theft, trespass, or other unlawful means-was defeated by the = Louisiana Senate on a vote of 27-9. If passed into law, SB 425 could = have caused gun owners to lose their homeowners' insurance if accidents = involving juveniles occurred in their homes.=20 MINNESOTA=20 House File 1360, the NRA-backed Personal Protection Act that seeks to = allow all trained, law-abiding citizens to obtain permits to carry = concealed handguns for personal protection, passed the Minnesota House = by an overwhelming margin, on a 85-45 vote. Unfortunately, when it was = time to bring the bill to the Senate floor for a vote, a group of = anti-gun state senators voted to keep the bill from even being = considered. For the names and numbers of those senators who voted = against your right to personal protection, contact NRA-ILA Grassroots, = or use the "Write Your Reps" tool.=20 TENNESSEE=20 The House Judiciary Civil Practices Subcommittee still has not = considered HB 227, a bill that seeks to allow Right to Carry permit = holders to carry firearms for self-defense in grocery and convenience = stores that sell alcohol for off-site consumption. Contact Subcommittee = Chair Representative Kim McMillan (D) at (615) 741-2043, and ask that = she bring this important bill up for a vote when the subcommittee meets = this Tuesday, April 17. Also on Tuesday, the House State and Local = Government Committee will hear HB 221, a bill that seeks to authorize = municipalities to heavily regulate the use of firearms under certain = conditions, such as banning hunting and regulating shooting range = activity. Contact committee members and urge them to oppose HB 221. For = a list of committee members, please contact NRA-ILA Grassroots, or use = the "Write Your Reps" tool.=20 TEXAS=20 The House Criminal Jurisprudence Committee passed HB 367, a bill that = seeks to mandate a federal records check using the flawed NICS system = prior to the sale of any firearm at a gun show (other than a sale to a = CHL holder). Although the bill has not yet been scheduled for action by = the full House, NRA members should begin calling their State = Representatives at (512) 463-4630 and urge them to oppose HB 367. = href=3D"http://www.bushtaxrelief.com/townhall.asp">http://www.bushtaxreli= ef. com/townhall.asp, you can find information on some town hall = meetings.=20 -------------------------------------------------------------------------= ------- Having difficulty finding ILA-related info? Try our FAQ Sheet=20 NRAILA.org is maintained for the NRA by=20 Mainstream Electronic Information Services=20 Homepage established 1994 by the NRA Institute for Legislative Action=20 11250 Waples Mill Road, Fairfax, VA 22030=20 ------=_NextPart_000_00D4_01C0C42C.C848E740 Content-Type: text/html; charset="iso-8859-1" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable <!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.0 Transitional//EN"> <HTML><HEAD> <META http-equiv=3DContent-Type content=3D"text/html; = charset=3Diso-8859-1"> <META content=3D"MSHTML 5.50.4611.1300" name=3DGENERATOR> <STYLE></STYLE> </HEAD> <BODY bgColor=3D#ffffff> <DIV> <CENTER> <H2>NRA-ILA FAX ALERT </H2> <H3></CENTER>Vol. 8, No. 15 4/13/01 </H3> <CENTER><B>PREPARE FOR RENEWED ATTACKS<BR>ON GUN SHOWS WHEN CONGRESS=20 RETURNS</CENTER></B> <P>Congress is still on recess for its <B>Easter District Work = Period</B> (House=20 scheduled to return April 20, Senate scheduled to return April 22), so = now is a=20 good time to set up face-to-face meetings with your federal lawmakers at = their=20 district offices. The gun-ban extremists in D.C. have already set their = sights=20 on gun shows, and <B>U.S. Senator Jack Reed</B> (D-R.I.) is poised to = introduce=20 his version of the legislation championed by former <B>U.S. Senator = Frank=20 Lautenberg</B> (D-N.J.) that sought to end gun shows as we know them = today. The=20 Senate will soon take up the issue of <B>education reform</B>, and we = anticipate=20 that Reed and fellow gun-ban extremists such as <B>U.S. Senators Dianne=20 Feinstein</B> (D-Calif.) and <B>Chuck Schumer</B> (D-N.Y.) will be = working with=20 the gun-ban lobby, <B>HCI</B>, to attach Reed's assault on gun shows, as = well as=20 other anti-gun amendments, to any education legislation brought up for=20 consideration. <I><U>Try to schedule personal meetings with your = Senators—or=20 contact them by letter or phone call—to express your opposition to = any assaults=20 on our <B>Right to Keep and Bear Arms</B>. For those on the Internet, = you can=20 also use the "Write Your Reps" tool at NRAILA.org.</I></U>=20 <P>Also remember to urge your U.S. Representative to oppose <B>S. = 27</B>, the=20 <B>McCain-Feingold</B> campaign finance "reform" legislation that was = passed by=20 the Senate. This bill would severely restrict our ability to provide = timely=20 information—including information on lawmakers' positions on = firearm-related=20 issues—to our membership and tens of millions of other law-abiding = gun owners.=20 <P>Finally, be sure to contact the offices of both your Senators and = your=20 Representative to see if they have any <B>Town Hall Meetings</B> = scheduled over=20 the next week. If so, be sure to attend, and bring your family, friends, = and=20 fellow gun owners, so that you can take advantage of any opportunities = to=20 express your support for the <B>Second Amendment</B>. If you learn of = any of=20 these meetings, be sure to share the information with the NRA-ILA = Grassroots=20 Division, so we may alert others. <I><U>To find out your federal = lawmaker's=20 district office number, you can call the U.S. House switchboard at (202) = 225-3121, and the U.S. Senate switchboard at (202) 224-3121. Just ask = for your=20 lawmaker's office, and someone there will be able to tell you the = closest=20 district office to where you live. Also for those on the Internet, if = you go to=20 <A <P><B> <CENTER>COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY<BR>SET TO HONOR CONTROVERSIAL=20 RESEARCHER</B></CENTER> <P>Next week, <B>Columbia University</B> will bestow its <B>Bancroft=20 Prize</B>—an award it touts as "one of the most prestigious awards = in the field=20 of history"—upon <B>Michael Bellesiles</B> of <B>Emory = University</B>, author of=20 last year's "<B>Arming America: The Origins of a National Gun = Culture</B>."=20 Bellesiles's book, according to the author, is a culmination of research = that=20 indicates that most Americans around the time of our country's formation = did not=20 own firearms. This, of course, is contrary to reams of scholarly = research=20 showing that America has always been a nation where the possession of = firearms=20 by responsible, law-abiding citizens has been widespread.=20 <P>While this book was received with high praise from gun-ban extremists = and the=20 anti-gun media (the <I><B>New York Times</I></B> actually gave the book = praise=20 before it was ever released), an editorial by <B>Kimberley Strassel</B> = from the=20 <B>April 5</B> issue of <I><B>The Wall Street Journal</I></B> points out = that=20 Bellesiles's research has been under fire by many respected scholars. = Thus far,=20 however, Bellesiles has refused to produce anything of substance that = would=20 counter the claims of his critics. <B>Gerald Rosenberg</B>, a visiting = professor=20 of law at <B>Northwestern</B>, told Strassel, "...[T]he evidence is so=20 overwhelming that it is incumbent upon Bellesiles as a serious scholar = to=20 respond. He either has to admit error, or somehow show how his work is = right."=20 <P><B>UCLA</B> law professor <B>Eugene Volokh</B> has pointed to = examples of=20 Bellesiles either misquoting sources, or citing sources that do not = contain the=20 information the Emory professor claims they contain. <B>Bentley = College</B>=20 history professor <B>Joyce Lee Malcolm</B>, author of "<B>To Keep and = Bear Arms:=20 The Origins of an Anglo-American Right</B>," referred to Bellesiles's = use of=20 travel narratives, which he claims failed to mention the use of guns for = hunting. But Malcolm states that "Arming America" makes no mention of = the same=20 narratives referring to guns outside of the context of hunting. And = Northwestern=20 professor of law <B>James Lindgren</B> tackles what many reviewers have=20 considered to be the most compelling aspect of Bellesiles = research—his use of=20 probate records, which are basically inventories of someone's estate at = his time=20 of death. Bellesiles claimes his research shows that only 14.7% of = American men,=20 and virtually no women, owned firearms, and he goes on to claim that = most guns=20 were old or broken. But Lindgren says he went over the same records that = Bellesiles cited, and found that 54% of American men, and 18% of the = women,=20 owned firearms, with no indication that most were listed as old or = broken.=20 Lindgren stated, "No one who has seen the evidence can figure out how he = could=20 have made such errors, or why he has not retracted the obviously = mistaken data."=20 <P>According to Strassel, Bellesiles told her that many of his critics = are=20 "ideologically motivated," but she points out that Rosenberg and = Lindgren all=20 told her that they favor gun control. Bellesiles has also revealed that = he did=20 not keep a database (rather odd in the age of computers), but kept all = his data=20 on paper notes, and he claims these paper notes were recently destroyed = in a=20 flood. <B>Randolph Roth</B>, an associate history professor at <B>Ohio = State</B>=20 who also supports gun control, examined Lindgren's work on probate = records and=20 commented that "it looks as though Mr. Bellesiles work won't be = reproducible."=20 <P>In an effort to present a different view to Bellesiles's, <B>Ron=20 Lewenberg</B>, <B>President of the Columbia College Conservative = Club</B>, has=20 been working with university officials to try to schedule a panel of = researchers=20 and scholars to discuss "Arming America" next <B>Wednesday</B>, <B>April = 18</B>,=20 the day Bellesiles is scheduled to receive his recognition from the = university.=20 At this time, it is unclear if the school will accommodate this request, = but if=20 it does, tentatively scheduled to appear are <B>Yale</B> professor = <B>John=20 Lott</B>, author of "<B>More Guns, Less Crime: Understanding Crime and = Gun=20 Control Laws</B>," and <B>Clayton Cramer</B>, author of several = historical=20 books, including "<B>For the Defense of Themselves: The Original Intent = and=20 Judicial Interpretation of the Right to Keep and Bear Arms</B>." = Bellesiles=20 declined an invitation to appear as well. <I><U>We should have more = information=20 on this tentative panel discussion next week, so if you are interested = in=20 finding out more, please call the Grassroots Division at (800) = 392-8683.</I></U>=20 <P> <CENTER><B>A LOOK AT THE STATES</CENTER></B> <P><B>CALIFORNIA</B>=20 <P><B>SB 52</B>, a bill that seeks to require licensing of all handgun=20 purchasers, will be heard by the <B>Senate Public Safety Committee</B> = on=20 <B>Tuesday</B>, <B>April 17</B>. <I><U>Contact members of the committee = and urge=20 them to oppose SB 52. For a list of committee members, call NRA-ILA = Grassroots,=20 or use the "Write Your Reps" tool at NRAILA.org.</I></U>=20 <P><B>FLORIDA</B>=20 <P><B>SB 412</B>, a bill that seeks to protect firearm manufacturers = from=20 reckless, politically-motivated lawsuits aimed at bankrupting them, = passed the=20 <B>Florida Senate</B> on a vote of 27-12. The bill was immediately = certified to=20 the House and will be awaiting consideration when lawmakers return from = Easter=20 recess next week.=20 <P><B>LOUISIANA</B>=20 <P><B>SB 425</B>, a bill that sought to make gun owners criminally = liable if a=20 juvenile gained access to one of their handguns and caused it to = discharge, or=20 used it to harm another—even if that juvenile accessed the handgun = by theft,=20 trespass, or other unlawful means—was defeated by the <B>Louisiana = Senate</B> on=20 a vote of 27-9. If passed into law, SB 425 could have caused gun owners = to lose=20 their homeowners' insurance if accidents involving juveniles occurred in = their=20 homes.=20 <P><B>MINNESOTA</B>=20 <P><B>House File 1360</B>, the NRA-backed <B>Personal Protection Act</B> = that=20 seeks to allow all trained, law-abiding citizens to obtain permits to = carry=20 concealed handguns for personal protection, passed the <B>Minnesota = House</B> by=20 an overwhelming margin, on a 85-45 vote. Unfortunately, when it was time = to=20 bring the bill to the Senate floor for a vote, a group of anti-gun state = senators voted to keep the bill from even being considered. <I><U>For = the names=20 and numbers of those senators who voted against your right to personal=20 protection, contact NRA-ILA Grassroots, or use the "Write Your Reps"=20 tool.</I></U>=20 <P><B>TENNESSEE</B>=20 <P>The <B>House Judiciary Civil Practices Subcommittee</B> still has not = considered <B>HB 227</B>, a bill that seeks to allow <B>Right to = Carry</B>=20 permit holders to carry firearms for self-defense in grocery and = convenience=20 stores that sell alcohol for off-site consumption. <I><U>Contact = <B>Subcommittee=20 Chair Representative Kim McMillan</B> (D) at (615) 741-2043, and ask = that she=20 bring this important bill up for a vote when the subcommittee meets this = <B>Tuesday</B>, <B>April 17</B>.</I></U> Also on Tuesday, the <B>House = State and=20 Local Government Committee</B> will hear <B>HB 221</B>, a bill that = seeks to=20 authorize municipalities to heavily regulate the use of firearms under = certain=20 conditions, such as banning hunting and regulating shooting range = activity.=20 <I><U>Contact committee members and urge them to oppose HB 221. For a = list of=20 committee members, please contact NRA-ILA Grassroots, or use the "Write = Your=20 Reps" tool.</I></U>=20 <P><B>TEXAS</B>=20 <P>The <B>House Criminal Jurisprudence Committee</B> passed <B>HB = 367</B>, a=20 bill that seeks to mandate a federal records check using the flawed NICS = system=20 prior to the sale of any firearm at a gun show (other than a sale to a = CHL=20 holder). <I><U>Although the bill has not yet been scheduled for action = by the=20 full House, NRA members should begin calling their State Representatives = at=20 (512) 463-4630 and urge them to oppose HB 367.</I></U>=20 href=3D"http://www.bushtaxrelief.com/townhall.asp">http://www.bushtaxr= elief.=20 com/townhall.asp</A>, you can find information on some town hall=20 meetings.</I></U>=20 <HR noShade> <CENTER> <P><FONT size=3D-2>Having difficulty finding ILA-related info? Try our = <A=20 href=3D"http://www.nraila.org/show.cgi?page=3D/grassroots/19990813-Genera= lInfo-015.html">FAQ=20 Sheet</A>=20 <P>NRAILA.org is maintained for the NRA by <BR></FONT><A=20 href=3D"http://www.mainstream.net/"><FONT size=3D-2>Mainstream = Electronic=20 Information Services </FONT></A><FONT size=3D-2> <P><FONT size=3D-2>Homepage established 1994 by the NRA Institute for = Legislative=20 Action <BR>11250 Waples Mill Road, Fairfax, VA 22030 </FONT></P> <P> </P></CENTER></FONT></DIV></BODY></HTML> ------=_NextPart_000_00D4_01C0C42C.C848E740--
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<FWKB6.261$x4.25404@newsread2.prod.itd.earthlink.net>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!supernews.google.com!sn-xit-03!supernews.com!cyclone2.usenetserver.com!news-out.usenetserver.com!newsfeed2.earthlink.net!newsfeed.earthlink.net!newsmaster1.prod.itd.earthlink.net!newsread2.prod.itd.earthlink.net.POSTED!not-for-mailShow Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit X-Google-Thread: 10a039,8c0e65828550d0d2,start X-Google-Attributes: gid10a039,public X-Google-ArrivalTime: 2001-04-13 15:20:01 PST Path: arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!supernews.google.com!sn-xit-03!supernews.com!cyclone2.usenetserver.com!news-out.usenetserver.com!newsfeed2.earthlink.net!newsfeed.earthlink.net!newsmaster1.prod.itd.earthlink.net!newsread2.prod.itd.earthlink.net.POSTED!not-for-mail From: "Neil At Hollywood�.Hom" <replyfromyou@spam.email.com> Newsgroups: ca.firearms Subject: NRA-ILA FAX ALERT - Vol. 8, No. 15 4/13/01 Lines: 514 MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary="----=_NextPart_000_00D4_01C0C42C.C848E740" X-Priority: 3 X-MSMail-Priority: Normal X-Newsreader: Microsoft Outlook Express 5.50.4522.1200 X-MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V5.50.4522.1200 Message-ID: <FWKB6.261$x4.25404@newsread2.prod.itd.earthlink.net> Date: Fri, 13 Apr 2001 22:18:13 GMT NNTP-Posting-Host: 209.179.232.249 X-Complaints-To: abuse@earthlink.net X-Trace: newsread2.prod.itd.earthlink.net 987200293 209.179.232.249 (Fri, 13 Apr 2001 15:18:13 PDT) NNTP-Posting-Date: Fri, 13 Apr 2001 15:18:13 PDT Organization: EarthLink Inc. -- http://www.EarthLink.net X-Received-Date: Fri, 13 Apr 2001 15:16:56 PDT (newsmaster1.prod.itd.earthlink.net)