Article View: can.ai
Article #551Mentifex * D.G. Mitchell CS Lab UT
From: Arthur T. Murray
Date: Tue, 31 Dec 1996 00:00
Date: Tue, 31 Dec 1996 00:00
42 lines
2587 bytes
2587 bytes
(For additional background, please run a Web search on Mentifex.) /^^^^^^^^^^^\ Top-down Overview; Details on WWW /^^^^^^^^^^^\ /visual memory\ ________ semantic / auditory \ | /--------|-------\ / syntax \ memory |episodic memory| | | recog-|nition | \________/<-----------|-------------\ | | ___|___ | | |flush-vector | _______ | | | /image \ | ___V____V___ word-fetch | /stored \ | | | / percept \<--|-->/ conceptual \--------------|->/ phonemes\| | | \ engrams / | \ mini-grids / for thinking | \ of words/ | | \_______/ | \__________/ in language | \_______/ | D.G. Mitchell <mitchell@cs.toronto.edu> says rather powerfully: > Sure enough, the mentifex picture is a lot like pictures you can > see at the start of many old cognitive psychology books, for example. > This is generally followed by a few hundred pages of stuff which > shows this kind of picture to be hopelessly naive and quite useless > as a scientific theory of the brain. > David - The Mentifex mind-diagram is more detailed and more explicit than the old psychology books, and new linguistics journals have begun to publish figures which agree with the lay-out of this diagram. (See G.S. Dell, "Structure and Content in Language Production".) - The diagram is posted under the assumption that intellectually curious persons will pick some area (module) of the proposed mind- model and investigate its deeper description in the URL documents, maintaining a dual attitude of: absorb new ideas + stop on error. - At a glance, a neuroscientist should be able to decide upon the superficial plausibility of the top-down diagram and then, if still undecided, plunge deeper into the URL mind-model in a self-terminating process of stop-at-point-of-either-fatal-flaw-or-no-new-ideas. - The entire Mentifex meme campaign is thus like a computer program with an exit-on-error trap: Search and destroy this theory of mind (or silently adapt and use it in your secret hidden AI coup d'etat).
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<E3AIrt.A5w@freenet.victoria.bc.ca>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!unknown!not-for-mailShow Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit X-Google-Thread: 103d82,e3c6bba33615bf55,start X-Google-Attributes: gid103d82,public From: uj797@freenet.Victoria.BC.CA (Arthur T. Murray) Subject: Mentifex * D.G. Mitchell CS Lab UT Date: 1996/12/31 Message-ID: <E3AIrt.A5w@freenet.victoria.bc.ca> X-Deja-AN: 206985375 sender: news@freenet.victoria.bc.ca (News Manager) x-nntp-posting-host: vifa1 organization: Victoria Freenet Association newsgroups: can.ai