🚀 go-pugleaf

Here is the promised summary of all the advice I received about
my query concerning cheap and good PCB CAD software:

From:	IN%"mpaul@unlinfo.unl.edu" 29-NOV-1992 21:24:11.85
To:	IN%"2575brooksr@VMS.CSD.MU.EDU"
CC:	
Subj:	RE: PCB CAD prgs advice wanted
 
Return-path: <mpaul@unlinfo.unl.edu>
Received: from unl.edu (unlinfo.unl.edu) by vms.csd.mu.edu (PMDF #3524 ) id
 <01GRQL8TWMDS9ODF74@vms.csd.mu.edu>; Sun, 29 Nov 1992 21:24:03 CST
Received: by unl.edu (4.1/SMI-4.0) id AA05621; Sun, 29 Nov 92 21:21:34 CST
Date: 29 Nov 1992 21:21:34 -0600 (CST)
From: mpaul@unlinfo.unl.edu (marxhausen paul)
Subject: RE: PCB CAD prgs advice wanted
To: 2575brooksr@VMS.CSD.MU.EDU
Message-id: <9211300321.AA05621@unl.edu>
X-Envelope-to: 2575brooksr
Content-transfer-encoding: 7BIT
Newsgroups: sci.electronics
References: <00964578.3C28D760@vms.csd.mu.edu>
 
"Good" and "cheap", in PCB software, you can sure get from the PADS Software
shareware version, which is available on ftp archives all over the place
(SIMTEL, etc. - drop me  line if you want a list, I don't have it handy.)
What is PADS?  Well, they make a Logic program for making schematics, and
a PCB program for circuit boards, which can suck in the output from the 
schematic package nicely.  The main difference between the shareware version
and the $2000 commercial version is that the size of the schematic you can
draw is limited to 2 pages, and the PCB is limited in the number of pins,
traces, etc. to an extent that you can do roughly a 30 IC design.  Also,
they don't include their much-touted "SuperRouter" autorouter in the shareware,
but it DOES include a couple of less capable autorouters.
 
How good is PADS?  Well, we've used Aptos CRITERION schematic/PCB/autorouter
software, another multi-thousand buck package; I've also taken a peek at 
OrCAD.  PADs is very capable, a professional package with some very powerful
and flexible features.  Two drawbacks, which feed on each other:
 
1) PADS uses a quirky user interface that makes us of a whole series of 
10-item menus selected by function keys, and the mouse, and also a command
line at the bottom of the screen, and it's NOT intuitive.  If you don't know
what you're doing, you're sunk.
 
2) Your aren't going to get a fully comprehensive and exhaustive manual for it
   without buying the commercial package.
 
HOWEVER...the shareware release does include a couple of lengthy tutorial files;
in the very latest release (which may not be on the archives yet) these total
some 70 pages.  If you work through them completely and read EVERYTHING in
them, you can get up to speed with PADS and get a good understanding of how
they do things, and from there, you can figure out some stuff they don't 
document.  
 
A comment about autorouting: it ain't what it's cracked up to be.  We have an
autorouter with CRITERION, and some folks here have tried OrCADs autorouter,
and everybody always concludes that autorouting is VASTLY overrated.  YOu
simply are not going to be able to plunk down your chips, input a netlist,
and sit back and watch it all take care of itself - autorouters do some very
stupid routing and miss some really obvious connections.  There really is no
substitute for a good eye and careful thinking and layout.   We simply do not
bother using autorouting any more.  I've never heard anybody say they knew
of an autorouter that really did a good job.
 
ANyway, I think enough of PADS that I will be installing on our EE department
undergraduate computer lab machines for the use of our students: for every
feature where I scratch my head (or curse), I find one that I say, "Wow,
that's really slick!  Hey, come here and look at this!"
 
 
-- 
paul marxhausen .... ....... ............. ............ ............ .......... 
. .. . .  . . . university of nebraska - lincoln .  . . .. . .  .. . . . . . . .
 .     .    .  .   .     .   .  .    .   .  .   .    .   .  grace .   .    .  . 
.   .         .       .      .        .        .      .        .   happens .     
From:	IN%"Gregory.Vines@brunel.ac.uk"  "Gregory Vines" 30-NOV-1992 04:51:58.99
To:	IN%"2575brooksr@VMS.CSD.MU.EDU"
CC:	
Subj:	RE: PCB CAD prgs
 
Return-path: <Gregory.Vines@brunel.ac.uk>
Received: from sirius.brunel.ac.uk (134.83.128.62) by vms.csd.mu.edu (PMDF
 #3524 ) id <01GRR0VS11GG9ODH0X@vms.csd.mu.edu>; Mon, 30 Nov 1992 04:51:47 CST
Received: from tcws-01.brunel.ac.uk by sirius.brunel.ac.uk with SMTP (PP) id
 <13409-0@sirius.brunel.ac.uk>; Mon, 30 Nov 1992 10:48:53 +0000
Date: 30 Nov 1992 10:48:45 +0000 (GMT)
From: Gregory Vines <Gregory.Vines@brunel.ac.uk>
Subject: RE: PCB CAD prgs
In-reply-to: <00964579.53F93A00@vms.csd.mu.edu>
To: 2575brooksr@VMS.CSD.MU.EDU
Message-id: <1492.9211301048@tcws-01.brunel.ac.uk>
Organization: Brunel University, West London, UK
X-Envelope-to: 2575brooksr
Content-transfer-encoding: 7BIT
Newsgroups: comp.robotics
 
In article <00964579.53F93A00@vms.csd.mu.edu> you write:
>Hi!
>	I'd like to know what PCB cad (w/autorouting) prgs are available
>for free or at least cheaply.  Specifically I need to be able to handle
>a device with staggered PGA (one row on .1" centers, next row .05" down
>and indented .05", repeating).  I currently use BoardMaster on my Amiga,
>but it doesn't think much of this device :-(.   Something for MS-DOS
>or X would be acceptable.  Thanks!
>
I use XCAD on my Amiga for PCBs, having drawn up a library of symbols for
pads.
 
Advantages:	extremely flexible (you can always draw more symbols)
		cheap (depending on your definition of cheap)
 
Disadvantages:	hand routing only
		massive output (XCAD-2000 only gives output in HPGL, converting
		that into postscript gives a board drawn entirely with say 0.1mm
		lines...
 
I'd be interested to hear more about BoardMaster.
 
> ----------------------------
> Ryan K. Brooks                        "You're never dead till you're        
> 2575BrooksR@vms.csd.mu.edu                  out of quarters."     
> Marquette University EECE              
> NemeSys Corporation
> "Curtains for Windows" 
 
				Yours electronically,
								Greg
 
Clouds with silver linings tend to rain the hardest.
 
From:	IN%"eplunix!raoul@harvard.harvard.edu" 30-NOV-1992 10:23:19.02
To:	IN%"harvard!2575brooksr@vms.csd.mu.edu"
CC:	
Subj:	RE: PCB CAD prgs
 
Return-path: <eplunix!raoul@harvard.harvard.edu>
Received: from harvard.harvard.edu by vms.csd.mu.edu (PMDF #3524 ) id
 <01GRRCGOW0AO9ODIGY@vms.csd.mu.edu>; Mon, 30 Nov 1992 10:23:06 CST
Received: by harvard.harvard.edu (5.54/a0.25) (for 2575brooksr@vms.csd.mu.edu)
 id AA21231; Mon, 30 Nov 92 11:20:31 EST
Received: by eplunix.UUCP; Mon, 30 Nov 92 10:40:13 est
Date: 30 Nov 1992 10:40:13 -0500 (est)
From: eplunix!raoul@harvard.harvard.edu (Nico Garcia-Otero)
Subject: RE: PCB CAD prgs
To: harvard!2575brooksr@vms.csd.mu.edu
Message-id: <01GRRCGP0TWI9ODIGY@vms.csd.mu.edu>
X-Envelope-to: 2575brooksr
Content-transfer-encoding: 7BIT
 
Try the PADS freeware: It's ftp'able from the /mirrors/msdos/cad
directory on wuarchive.wustl.edu, as padslog.zip, padspcb.zip,
and padslib.zip. It's pretty nice and configurable, although the
manual set bites the big one.
 
			Nico Garcia
			CIRL/MEEI
			eddie.mit.edu!eplunix!raoul
					
Newsgroups: comp.robotics
Path: spool.mu.edu!yale.edu!qt.cs.utexas.edu!cs.utexas.edu!wupost!uunet!das.wang.com!wang!pvr
From: pvr@wang.com ()
Subject: Re: PCB CAD prgs
Organization: Wang Labs, Lowell MA, USA
Date: Tue, 1 Dec 1992 13:55:52 GMT
Message-ID: <ByL2p5.Bq1@wang.com>
References: <00964579.53F93A00@vms.csd.mu.edu>
Sender: news@wang.com
Nntp-Posting-Host: preilley.wiis.wang.com
Lines: 33
 
2575brooksr@vms.csd.mu.edu (Ryan K. Brooks) writes:
 
>Hi!
>	I'd like to know what PCB cad (w/autorouting) prgs are available
>for free or at least cheaply.  Specifically I need to be able to handle
>a device with staggered PGA (one row on .1" centers, next row .05" down
>and indented .05", repeating).  I currently use BoardMaster on my Amiga,
>but it doesn't think much of this device :-(.   Something for MS-DOS
>or X would be acceptable.  Thanks!
 
	The freeware release of PADS_PCD allows you to define
part decals.   It may even have such a decal already defined.
PADS has schematic capture, board layout, autorouting and
an extensive parts library included in the freeware release.
It can be gotten from simtel.
 
These files are available via anonymous FTP from WSMR-SIMTEL20.ARMY.MIL
(192.88.110.20) or mirror sites OAK.Oakland.Edu (141.210.10.117),
wuarchive.wustl.edu (128.252.135.4), ftp.uu.net (137.39.1.9),
nic.funet.fi (128.214.6.100), src.doc.ic.ac.uk (146.169.3.7) or
archie.au (139.130.4.6), by e-mail through the BITNET/EARN file
servers, or by uucp from UUNET's 1-900-GOT-SRCS.  See UUNET file
uunet!~/info/archive-help for details.
 
Directory PD1:<MSDOS.CAD>
 
PADSLIB.ZIP   B  488615  920212  PADS library for PADSPCB.ZIP and PADSLOG.ZIP
PADSLOG.ZIP   B 1081636  920212  PADS Logic schematic capture CAD program
PADSPCB.ZIP   B 1036461  920212  PADS PCB (printed circuit board) layout pgm
 
--
>>>>>>>>>>>> Peter Reilley ..... pvr@wiis.wang.com ..... KA1LAT <<<<<<<<<<<<<
                     Well, that about says it.
Path: spool.mu.edu!uwm.edu!ogicse!das-news.harvard.edu!cantaloupe.srv.cs.cmu.edu!crabapple.srv.cs.cmu.edu!andrew.cmu.edu!jmce+
From: jmce+@andrew.cmu.edu (James Ryan Miller)
Newsgroups: sci.electronics
Subject: PADS Shareware Installation
Message-ID: <of_csQK00iUy83m1h4@andrew.cmu.edu>
Date: 12 Dec 92 15:13:00 GMT
Article-I.D.: andrew.of_csQK00iUy83m1h4
Organization: Freshman, CIT general, Carnegie Mellon, Pittsburgh, PA
Lines: 51
 
 
    I've got a number of requests for the info on how to get PADS to
install, so here it is.  Any problems with this, just let me know.
 
                                        Ryan Miller
                                        jmce+@andrew.cmu.edu
 
------
PADS logic and PADS pcb manual installation
 
        Many people have had trouble running the install program for
these programs.  Then you must install the programs manually as follows:
 
1)      You need these files:           PADSPCB.ZIP
                                        PADSLOG.ZIP
                                        PADSLIB.ZIP
 
        make the directory:             /PADSDEMO
 
        unzip PADSLOG.ZIP into the \PADSDEMO directory, and copy the
file files.exe to logfiles.exe.  Then unzip the other two into
\PADSDEMO.
 
2)      Make the following directories: /PADSDEMO/LOGFIL
                                        /PADSDEMO/FILES
                                        /PADSDEMO/LIB
                                        /PADSDEMO/CAM
 
3)      Move the following files:
        \PADSDEMO\LIB.EXE       ->      \PADSDEMO\LIB\LIB.EXE
        \PADSDEMO\ULIB.EXE      ->      \PADSDEMO\LIB\ULIB.EXE
        \PADSDEMO\FILES.EXE     ->      \PADSDEMO\FILES\FILES.EXE
        \PADSDEMO\LOGFIL.EXE    ->      \PADSDEMO\LOGFIL\LOGFIL.EXE
 
4)      Execute the following files (they are self extracting):
                \PADSDEMO\PADS.EXE
                \PADSDEMO\DHLP.EXE
                \PADSDEMO\LOGIC.EXE
                \PADSDEMO\LIB\LIB.EXE
                \PADSDEMO\LIB\ULIB.EXE
                \PADSDEMO\FILES\FILES.EXE
                \PADSDEMO\LOGFIL\LOGFIL.EXE
 
5)      Okay, the program installation is done.  You must do hardware
setup still.  Goto the \PADSDEMO directory and run pinstall.
 
        That should be it.  I hope this helps.  Let me know if you have
any problems.
 
                                                Ryan Miller
                                                jmce+@andrew.cmu.edu
------
------ End Of Summary ------X

Note:  I've downloads PADS and tried it out... its quite nice, a little
hard to get used to.  I also found out that there has been a revision
to BoardMaster (for the Amiga) which adds some important features, so
I have sent for the upgrade.

Thats all!
 ----------------------------
 Ryan K. Brooks                        "You're never dead till you're        
 2575BrooksR@vms.csd.mu.edu                  out of quarters."     
 Marquette University EECE              
 NemeSys Corporation
 "Curtains for Windows"