🚀 go-pugleaf

In article 508@steel.interlog.com, herbs@connobj.com (Herb Sutter) writes:
>
>If friendship were heritable, then you could use mixins to solve the general 
>problem of granting friendship to only parts of a class.  I'm about to ask a 
>question without having done my homework, but: what were the main reasons 
>again for not making friendship heritable (even as an option)...?	

My copy of D&E is not handy, so I don't know whether the reasons are
discussed there. But here is how it seems to me:

1. I hope we all agree with the principle that friendship can only be
granted and cannot be seized.

2. A base-class function has no special access to a derived class.

3. A friend class can be viewed as part of the class of which it is a
friend. If friendship were inherited, a friend class would have
priviledges unavailable to member functions. (This is IMHO a weak
argument.)

4. A stronger argument: The owner (i.e. maintainer) of a class must own
the friend function. A derived class owner typically does not own the
base class. I would not want functions I don't own to have special access
to my class -- it would constrain in unknown ways the changes I could make
to my derived class implementation.

Optional inheritance of friendship: First, it isn't clear to me
you would want to say "every friend of every base class is my friend too."
If that capability is not desireable, you would want to specify somehow
which base-class friends were also derived-class friends. Of course you
do that now with a friend declaration for each function.

I think you could make a case that
	friend class B;
should mean that friends of B are also friends of this class. If you
can grant friendship to all of B's members, it doesn't seems dangerous
to grant automatically the same to B's friends.
---
Steve Clamage, stephen.clamage@eng.sun.com




---
[ comp.std.c++ is moderated.  Submission address: std-c++@ncar.ucar.edu.
  Contact address: std-c++-request@ncar.ucar.edu.  The moderation policy
  is summarized in http://dogbert.lbl.gov/~matt/std-c++/policy.html. ]