Article View: comp.sys.mac.apps
Article #9412Re: TypeReader, OCR, Scanner Bundle
From: Sven U. Grenander
Date: Fri, 11 Dec 1992 22:30
Date: Fri, 11 Dec 1992 22:30
105 lines
5291 bytes
5291 bytes
I'm leaving all of the original text in place to keep the context. I just got TypeReader for $99.xx + $8.xx for shipping as a limited (?) competative upgrade offer. For the price I just couldn't pass it up. It is version 1.0, and it still has some minor bugs, but all in all I'm really impressed ! I haven't used it with any scanners (only plan to use with fax files), but it does a respectable job on the TIFF + PICT files I get out of my InterFax. It "seems" a lot faster than earlier OCR s/w I experimented with a while back. In article <1992Dec11.183618.9800@netcom.com>, tcmay@netcom.com (Timothy C. May) wrote: > > Here are some comments on ExperVision's fairly new OCR program, > "TypeReader," and also some comments on a bundled deal whereby you > "Buy TypeReader, Get a Scanner for Free." > > TypeReader got a very positive review in the the Dec., '92 "MacUser," > and in the 10-19-92 issue of "MacWeek." "MacWorld" has not yet > reviewed it. Both reviews said it was more accurate than Caere's > "Omnipage Pro," and faster as well. (It came out of practically > nowhere, so how could it challenge Caere, Calera, and Xerox? The > answer seems to be that it was developed for a large Japanese Kanji > recognition product, which underwrote the development costs. Also, it > appeared for Windows a while back...from what I can see, with its fine > interface, it's one of the rare DOS-world products that has migrated > to the Mac with grace and style.) > > I was eager to try it, especially when my dealer, the famous > "ComputerWare" (of the Bay Area, with my dealer in Santa > Cruz/Capitola), told me about the "Buy TypeReader, get a scanner for > free." special bundled offer (which I had not seen advertised anywhere). > > Here's the deal (then I'll report on the results): > > * TypeReader + Abaton TranScribe 300 scanner = $650 > > TypeReader has a street price of around $500, with a $100 rebate from > ExperVision, for an effective stree price of $400. (It is also > available for $150 as a "competitive upgrade" if you already have an > OCR program...see ExperVision's ads for details.) > > So this made the Abaton scanner a real deal, at $250. Even though it's > only black and white (NO 8-bit grey-scale), it's perfectly fine for > OCR, and works well with TypeReader. > > For comparison, I also looked at the H-P ScanJet IIp for $650 (after $50 > rebate from H-P), the Microtek Scanmaker II (a 24-bit color scanner) > for $900, and even the H-P ScanJet IIc (color, true 400 dpi) for $1300 > (after $100 rebate). Though I don't critically need color, I thought > the price on the ScanMaker II was low enough to be tempting. > > After nearly 5 hours of scanning, OCRing with both OmniPage Direct > ($275, street price, or $225 if purchased with the H-P IIp) and with > TypeReader, I concluded I wanted TypeReader. > > Advantages of TypeReader: > > * more accurate than OmniPage Direct (Note: OmniPage Direct is Caere's > low-end, but is nearly the same recognition engine as OmniPage Pro, so > say the reviewers. I didn't evaluate Pro, because it was $700 just by > itself, and TypeReader seemed to outmatch it anyway, at least in the > reviews.) > > * more features than OmniPage Direct...dictionaries, nice on-screen > corrections (with a bit image displayed simultaneously...a very useful > feature!), deferred processing (e.g., scan in 20 pages and then let > the Mac crunch later), and a nicer interface than OmniPage Direct > (though Direct has the convenient feature of placing the recognized > text directly into the word processor or whatever that you're in when > you open it). > > > The H-P ScanJet IIp is undeniably a very fine scanner, with both 8-bit > grey-scale and H-P's "AccuPage" autobrightness system, which handles > colored or stained paper much better. The H-P + OmniPage Direct > solution would have cost me $650 + $225 = $875. Upgrading to > TypeReader would have added $150, for a total of $1025. > > So I went with the TypeReader + Abaton TranScribe = $650 deal. > > I'm happy so far. I've been scanning articles, reports, letters, and > pages out of books. TypeReader is a joy to use. > > I hope these comments help someone out there. > > > --Tim May > > > > > > > -- > .......................................................................... > Timothy C. May | Crypto Anarchy: encryption, digital money, > tcmay@netcom.com | anonymous networks, digital pseudonyms, zero > 408-688-5409 | knowledge, reputations, information markets, > W.A.S.T.E.: Aptos, CA | black markets, collapse of governments. > Higher Power: 2^756839 | PGP Public Key: by arrangement.
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<sgrenander-111292142403@mac4.jpl.nasa.gov>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!sparky!uunet!think.com!ames!elroy.jpl.nasa.gov!mac4.jpl.nasa.gov!userReferences:
<1992Dec11.183618.9800@netcom.com>Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
Newsgroups: comp.sys.mac.apps Path: arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!sparky!uunet!think.com!ames!elroy.jpl.nasa.gov!mac4.jpl.nasa.gov!user From: sgrenander@NASAMAIL.JPL.NASA.GOV (Sven U. Grenander) Subject: Re: TypeReader, OCR, Scanner Bundle Message-ID: <sgrenander-111292142403@mac4.jpl.nasa.gov> Followup-To: comp.sys.mac.apps Sender: news@elroy.jpl.nasa.gov (Usenet) Nntp-Posting-Host: mac4.jpl.nasa.gov Organization: Jet Propulsion Laboratory References: <1992Dec11.183618.9800@netcom.com> Date: Fri, 11 Dec 1992 22:30:48 GMT Lines: 105