Thread View: comp.windows.misc
2 messages
2 total messages
Started by Frank Wang
Tue, 11 Jun 1991 01:23
Is win3 a oper. sys?
Author: Frank Wang
Date: Tue, 11 Jun 1991 01:23
Date: Tue, 11 Jun 1991 01:23
9 lines
861 bytes
861 bytes
Is Window 3 a operation system? If yes, why it cannot boot a pc? If not, why ms-dos can be run under it? I am totally confused after one of my friend told me "Window 3 is oper. sys, since it rearrange the ram." While another friend told me "It's not a oper. sys. It's just a application program. Thanks in advance to those replyer.
Re: Is win3 a oper. sys?
Author: Charles Hedrick
Date: Tue, 11 Jun 1991 02:50
Date: Tue, 11 Jun 1991 02:50
38 lines
2547 bytes
2547 bytes
>Is Window 3 a operation system? > If yes, why it cannot boot a pc? > If not, why ms-dos can be run under it? There's probably no good answer to that question. The term "operating system" was invented to describe software that comes from a rather different tradition. An operating system fits into an architecture that involves a fairly clear layering between hardware, device drivers, operating system, application software, etc. For reasons having to do with limited hardware resources, as well as historical reasons that are harder to justify, typical PC systems do not have the sort of layered architecture into which an operating system fits. E.g. an application program like Kermit will directly manipulate the serial interface and screen, which normally only a device driver is allowed to do, and will do interrupt handling functions that a operating system would normally do. Windows, at least when running on a 386 processor, performs a number of functions that an operating system would normally do. But not all of them. It sort of "fills in the holes" in MS-DOS's operating system functionality (though not all of them). It is designed to work with MS-DOS, not on the bare machine, which is why you can't boot it. Note by the way that MS-DOS doesn't exactly run "under" Windows. Windows can run the MS-DOS command processor in a window, but that's basically an applications program. Windows does depend upon some of the more operating system-like portions of MS-DOS (though it replaces others). Things get even more interesting when you run Windows with QEMM. Then normal operating systems functionality is split among MS-DOS, QEMM, Windows and (to some extent) applications programs. So I'm not convinced that it's useful to try to figure out which piece of software is the "operating system" on a PC running Windows. OS/2 and Unix, both of which will run on the same software, are a different question. Both of them look a lot more like a traditional operating system.
Thread Navigation
This is a paginated view of messages in the thread with full content displayed inline.
Messages are displayed in chronological order, with the original post highlighted in green.
Use pagination controls to navigate through all messages in large threads.
Back to All Threads