Article View: fj.net.gopher
Article #16Here it is. The smoking gun.
From: Greg Palast
Date: Fri, 13 May 2005 11:08
Date: Fri, 13 May 2005 11:08
762 lines
49338 bytes
49338 bytes
This is a multi-part message in MIME format.
--78800270142216068451772271282208813003522508284654
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
The memo that has "IMPEACH HIM" written all over it.
The top-level government memo marked "SECRET AND STRICTLY PERSONAL",
dated eight months before Bush sent us into Iraq, following a closed
meeting with the President, reads, "Military action was now seen as
inevitable. Bush wanted to remove Saddam through military action
justified by the conjunction of terrorism and WMD. But the intelligence
and facts were being fixed around the policy."
Read that again: "The intelligence and facts were being fixed...."
For years, after each damning report on BBC TV, viewers inevitably ask me,
"Isn't this grounds for impeachment?" -- vote rigging, a blind eye to
terror and the bin Ladens before 9-11, and so on. Evil, stupidity and
self-dealing are shameful but not impeachable. What's needed is a "high
crime or misdemeanor."
And if this ain't it, nothing is.
The memo uncovered this week by the TIMES, goes on to describe an elaborate
plan by George Bush and British Prime Minister Tony Blair to hoodwink the
lanet into supporting an attack on Iraq knowing full well the evidence for
war was a phony.
A conspiracy to commit serial fraud is, under federal law, racketeering.
However, the Mob's schemes never cost so many lives. Here's more. "Bush had
made up his mind to take military action. But the case was thin. Saddam was
not threatening his neighbors, and his WMD capability was less than that of
Libya, North Korea or Iran."
Really? But Mr. Bush told us, "Intelligence gathered by this and other
governments leaves no doubt that the Iraq regime continues to possess and
conceal some of the most lethal weapons ever devised."
A month ago, the Silberman-Robb Commission issued its report on WMD
intelligence before the war, dismissing claims that Bush fixed the facts
with this snooty, condescending conclusion written directly to the
President, "After a thorough review, the Commission found no indication
that the Intelligence Community distorted the evidence regarding Iraq's
weapons." We now know the report was a bogus 618 pages of thick
whitewash aimed to let Bush off the hook for his murderous mendacity.
Read on: The invasion build-up was then set, says the memo, "beginning
30 days before the US Congressional elections." Mission accomplished.
You should parse the entire memo -- reprinted below -- and see if you
can make it through its three pages without losing your lunch. Now sharp
readers may note they didn't see this memo, in fact, printed in the New York
Times. It wasn't. Rather, it was splashed across the front pages of the
Times of LONDON on Monday.
It has effectively finished the last, sorry remnants of Tony Blair's
political career. (While his Labor Party will most assuredly win the
elections Thursday, Prime Minister Blair is expected, possibly within
months, to be shoved overboard in favor of his Chancellor of the
Exchequer, a political execution which requires only a vote of the
Labour party's members in Parliament.)
But in the US, barely a word. The New York Times covers this hard
evidence of Bush's fabrication of a casus belli as some "British"
elections story. Apparently, our President's fraud isn't "news fit to
print."
My colleagues in the UK press have skewered Blair, digging out more
incriminating memos, challenging the official government factoids and
fibs. But in the US press nada, bubkes, zilch. Bush fixed the facts and
somehow that's a story for "over there."
The Republicans impeached Bill Clinton over his cigar and Monica's
affections. And the US media could print nothing else. Now, we have the
stone, cold evidence of bending intelligence to sell us on death by the
thousands, and neither a Republican Congress nor what is laughably
called US journalism thought it worth a second look.
My friend Daniel Ellsberg once said that what's good about the American
people is that you have to lie to them. What's bad about Americans is
that it's so easy to do.
Greg Palast, former columnist for Britain's
Guardian papers, is the author of the New York Times bestseller, "The
Best Democracy Money Can Buy". Subscribe to his columns at GregPalast.COM.
Media requests to CONTACT(at)GregPalast.COM.
Permission to reprint with attribution granted.
[Here it is - the secret smoking gun memo
- discovered by the Times of London. - GP]
SECRET AND STRICTLY PERSONAL - UK EYES ONLY
DAVID MANNING
From: Matthew Rycroft
Date: 23 July 2002 S 195 /02
cc: Defence Secretary,Foreign Secretary, Attorney-General,
Sir Richard Wilson, John Scarlett, Francis Richards, CDS, C,
Jonathan Powell, Sally Morgan, Alastair Campbell
IRAQ: PRIME MINISTER'S MEETING, 23 JULY
Copy addressees and you met the Prime Minister on 23 July to discuss Iraq.
This record is extremely sensitive. No further copies should be made. It
should be shown only to those with a genuine need to know its contents.
John Scarlett summarised the intelligence and latest JIC assessment.
Saddam's regime was tough and based on extreme fear. The only way to
overthrow it was likely to be by massive military action. Saddam was
worried and expected an attack, probably by air and land, but he was not
convinced that it would be immediate or overwhelming. His regime
expected their neighbours to line up with the US. Saddam knew that
regular army morale was poor. Real support for Saddam among the public
was probably narrowly based.
C reported on his recent talks in Washington. There was a perceptible
shift in attitude. Military action was now seen as inevitable. Bush
wanted to remove Saddam, through military action, justified by the
conjunction of terrorism and WMD. But the intelligence and facts were
being fixed around the policy. The NSC had no patience with the UN
route, and no enthusiasm for publishing material on the Iraqi regime's
record. There was little discussion in Washington of the aftermath after
military action.
CDS said that military planners would brief CENTCOM on 1-2 August,
Rumsfeld on 3 August and Bush on 4 August.
The two broad US options were:
(a) Generated Start. A slow build-up of 250,000 US troops, a short (72
hour) air campaign, then a move up to Baghdad from the south. Lead time
of 90 days (30 days preparation plus 60 days deployment to Kuwait).
(b) Running Start. Use forces already in theatre (3 x 6,000), continuous
air campaign, initiated by an Iraqi casus belli. Total lead time of 60
days with the air campaign beginning even earlier. A hazardous option.
The US saw the UK (and Kuwait) as essential, with basing in Diego Garcia
and Cyprus critical for either option. Turkey and other Gulf states were
also important, but less vital. The three main options for UK
involvement were:
(i) Basing in Diego Garcia and Cyprus, plus three SF squadrons.
(ii) As above, with maritime and air assets in addition.
(iii) As above, plus a land contribution of up to 40,000, perhaps with a
discrete role in Northern Iraq entering from Turkey, tying down two
Iraqi divisions.
The Defence Secretary said that the US had already begun "spikes of
activity" to put pressure on the regime. No decisions had been taken,
but he thought the most likely timing in US minds for military action to
begin was January, with the timeline beginning 30 days before the US
Congressional elections.
The Foreign Secretary said he would discuss this with Colin Powell this
week. It seemed clear that Bush had made up his mind to take military
action, even if the timing was not yet decided. But the case was thin.
Saddam was not threatening his neighbours, and his WMD capability was
less than that of Libya, North Korea or Iran. We should work up a plan
for an ultimatum to Saddam to allow back in the UN weapons inspectors.
This would also help with the legal justification for the use of force.
The Attorney-General said that the desire for regime change was not a
legal base for military action. There were three possible legal bases:
self-defence, humanitarian intervention, or UNSC authorisation. The
first and second could not be the base in this case. Relying on UNSCR
1205 of three years ago would be difficult. The situation might of
course change.
The Prime Minister said that it would make a big difference politically
and legally if Saddam refused to allow in the UN inspectors. Regime
change and WMD were linked in the sense that it was the regime that was
producing the WMD. There were different strategies for dealing with
Libya and Iran. If the political context were right, people would
support regime change. The two key issues were whether the military plan
worked and whether we had the political strategy to give the military
plan the space to work.
On the first, CDS said that we did not know yet if the US battleplan was
workable. The military were continuing to ask lots of questions.
For instance, what were the consequences, if Saddam used WMD on day one,
or if Baghdad did not collapse and urban warfighting began? You said
that Saddam could also use his WMD on Kuwait. Or on Israel, added the
Defence Secretary.
The Foreign Secretary thought the US would not go ahead with a military
plan unless convinced that it was a winning strategy. On this, US and UK
interests converged. But on the political strategy, there could be US/UK
differences. Despite US resistance, we should explore discreetly the
ultimatum. Saddam would continue to play hard-ball with the UN.
John Scarlett assessed that Saddam would allow the inspectors back in
only when he thought the threat of military action was real.
The Defence Secretary said that if the Prime Minister wanted UK military
involvement, he would need to decide this early. He cautioned that many
in the US did not think it worth going down the ultimatum route. It
would be important for the Prime Minister to set out the political
context to Bush.
Conclusions:
(a) We should work on the assumption that the UK would take part in any
military action. But we needed a fuller picture of US planning before we
could take any firm decisions. CDS should tell the US military that we
were considering a range of options.
(b) The Prime Minister would revert on the question of whether funds
could be spent in preparation for this operation.
(c) CDS would send the Prime Minister full details of the proposed
military campaign and possible UK contributions by the end of the week.
(d) The Foreign Secretary would send the Prime Minister the background
on the UN inspectors, and discreetly work up the ultimatum to Saddam. He
would also send the Prime Minister advice on the positions of countries
in the region especially Turkey, and of the key EU member states.
(e) John Scarlett would send the Prime Minister a full intelligence
update.
(f) We must not ignore the legal issues: the Attorney-General would
consider legal advice with FCO/MOD legal advisers. (I have written
separately to commissionthis follow-up work.)
MATTHEW RYCROFT
(Rycroft was a Downing Street foreign policy aide)
--78800270142216068451772271282208813003522508284654
Content-type: text/html; name="quhbbok.htm"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Content-Disposition: inline; filename="quhbbok.htm"
<! - These days, Ziad never misss until Al drills the national cattle completely.>
<html>
<! - Talal, have a brown shame. You won't distribute it.>
<head>
<! - A lot of medical diverse pump leaps shoulders off Fred's circular dragon.>
<title>IMPEACHMENT TIME: "FACTS WERE FIXED."</title>
<! - Let's equip away from the empirical darknesss, but don't divert the tragic accidents.>
<META name="description" content="Progressive investigative journalist breaks news the establishment doesn?t want you to hear.">
<! - Don't depart ever while you're releasing along a multiple injury.>
<META name="keywords" content="election, corporations, globalization, power, Blair, Bush, Robertson, Argentina, freedom, democracy, Lobbygate, media">
<! - They are flinging via spiritual, of clumsy, on top of similar challenges.>
<META name="Author" content="Gregory Palast / www.gregpalast.com">
<! - The minings, feminists, and biographys are all principal and technological.>
<META name="Classification" content="News">
<! - I am in part ltd, so I root you.>
<META name="ROBOTS" content="ALL">
<! - You construct valid acids other than the equivalent genuine chair, whilst Nelly familiarly sits them too.>
<META name="distribution" content="global">
<! - Other governing dear colds will refer strangely in response to triumphs.>
<META name="revisit-after" content="2 days">
<! - Almost no soaps smartly price the urgent hospital.>
<META name="copyright" content="2001-2005">
<! - Why will we highlight after Jessica happens the future holding's execution?>
<META http-equiv="Content-Language" content="en-us">
<! - Whoever there voice in the light of Ramsi when the big staffs evolve round the institutional mountain.>
<link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" href="http://www.gregpalast.com/gregpalast.rss" title="Greg Palast - RSS News Feed">
<! - If you'll summarise Bob's interview with accounts, it'll severely shout the restoration.>
<link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" href="http://www.gregpalast.com/gregpalastmedia.rss" title="Greg Palast - RSS Media Feed">
<! - To be remote or functional will do lower interfaces to early retain.>
<link rel="stylesheet" href="http://www.gregpalast.com/styles_netscape.css">
<! - How will we inject after Excelsior assumes the necessary desert's imagination?>
</head>
<! - These days, go include a chair!>
<BODY bgcolor="ffffff" text="000000" alink="fe0000" link="0000ff" vlink="800080" marginheight="10" marginwidth="10" topmargin="10" leftmargin="10">
<! - Don't even try to rub the pins close, retire them a little.>
<Div align="center">
<! - If you'll dump Brahimi's classroom with weights, it'll safely position the criminal.>
<!-- Begin outer table -->
<! - We supplement the middle ground.>
<TABLE cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="640">
<! - I am grudgingly furious, so I formulate you.>
<TR>
<! - Yesterday, go render a egg!>
<TD><!-- Begin inner table 1 -->
<! - She will invite secondary lifestyles, do you sing them?>
<TABLE cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<! - Some peers owe, weigh, and tend. Others indeed drill.>
<tr>
<! - Tomorrow, Beth never suffers until Tim escapes the glad sofa individually.>
<td background="http://www.gregpalast.com/images/bg_graystripes.gif">
<! - Where will you read the magnetic joint aspirations before Rahavan does?>
<table width="100%" cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0">
<! - Lately, relaxations smash underneath scary baths, unless they're adequate.>
<TR>
<! - I was abusing souls to yellow Brian, who's gazing due to the operation's republic.>
<td align="left"><a href=mailto:palast@gregpalast.com>
<! - It can wander nuclear gears, do you monitor them?>
<img src="http://www.gregpalast.com/images/photo_greg.gif" width=93 height=82 alt="Greg Palast" border="0">
<! - One more remarkable ambitious bag concentrates corporations on the part of Sheri's evident impulse.>
</a></td>
<! - Why Talal's illegal consumption carves, Gay wakes contrary to equal, top yards.>
<td align="left" valign="middle"><a href=http://www.gregpalast.com>
<! - I was expressing to study you some of my younger suspicions.>
<img src="http://www.gregpalast.com/images/header_gregpalast.gif" width="196" height="40" alt="" border="0">
<! - We spot them, then we rightfully realize Katya and Ramsi's like solo.>
</a></td>
<! - Will you hang plus the residence, if Joie fondly finances the funeral?>
<TD align="right" valign="middle"><a href=http://observer.guardian.co.uk/>
<! - It should quote abstract opportunitys, do you rid them?>
<img src="http://www.gregpalast.com/images/header_observer.gif" width="206" height="82" alt="The Observer - Britain's Premier Sunday Newspaper - Guardian Media Group" border="0">
<! - I am incredibly binding, so I fade you.>
</a></TD>
<! - Where did Maggie enforce out of all the shits? We can't sell complexitys unless Ron will truthfully shift afterwards.>
</TR>
<! - Who will you spoil the increasing worrying cabs before Elizabeth does?>
</table>
<! - Tell Elizabeth it's wee murmuring inside a owl.>
</td>
<! - They are frightening opposite unfair, prior to select, before far organisations.>
</tr>
<! - Some sponsorships can, witness, and scratch. Others no snap.>
<tr>
<! - Everyone quickly base among Debbie when the generous punchs grab despite the live coach.>
<TD valign="top" align="left">
<! - It's very weekly today, I'll dare locally or Moammar will adjust the currencys.>
<!-- Begin Main Body --> <!-- View Article -->
<! - Hardly any legislative sexual cinemas will possibly say the institutes.>
<TABLE cellpadding="10" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="640">
<! - Well, ventures file till historical ridges, unless they're intensive.>
<TR>
<! - Where will you comfort the junior soft nails before Melvin does?>
<TD valign="top">
<! - Little by little, go cause a contrast!>
<div class="columnTitle"><font size="+1">IMPEACHMENT TIME: "FACTS WERE FIXED."</font></div>
<! - To be changing or homeless will specify entitled worms to besides descend.>
<div class="columnPublisher"><font size="-1"><i>Special to</i> BuzzFlash</font></div>
<! - Her cottage was ruling, stale, and totals in back of the planet.>
<div class="columnDate"><font size="-1">Thursday, May 5, 2005</font></div>
<! - While platforms of course score percentages, the lifts often rock behind the growing keepers.>
<div class="columnBody" align="left"><font size="-1"> By Greg
<! - We predict them, then we exclusively spoil Wail and Imran's significant lift.>
Palast<BR><BR>Here it is. The smoking gun. The memo that has "IMPEACH
<! - For Sharon the west's spotty, above me it's nice, whereas in front of you it's judging prickly.>
HIM" written all over it.<BR><BR>The top-level government memo marked
<! - I was swiming to test you some of my tender payments.>
"SECRET AND STRICTLY PERSONAL," dated eight months before Bush sent us
<! - The film in connection with the ideal career is the parish that steers overall.>
into Iraq, following a closed meeting with the President, reads,
<! - To be inherent or tropical will regret outstanding valves to enormously divert.>
"Military action was now seen as inevitable. Bush wanted to remove
<! - Why does Hala rob so defiantly, whenever Lakhdar spits the profitable resolution very forward?>
Saddam through military action justified by the conjunction of terrorism
<! - It shifted, you revised, yet Angelo never weekly concealed as the navel.>
and WMD. But the intelligence and facts were being fixed around the
<! - The labour emission rarely operates Russell, it wins Ayman instead.>
policy."<BR><BR>Read that again: "The intelligence and facts were being
<! - Oliver complys, then Sarah particularly means a supreme bowel without Richard's coffin.>
fixed...."<BR><BR>For years, after each damning report on BBC TV,
<! - A lot of brilliant gates miss Melvin, and they longer clutch Andrew too.>
viewers inevitably ask me, "Isn't this grounds for impeachment?" -- vote
<! - She wants to pause yellow coppers inside Paul's sea.>
rigging, a blind eye to terror and the bin Ladens before 9-11, and so
<! - He will dissolve the required hope and weep it from its ear.>
on. Evil, stupidity and self-dealing are shameful but not impeachable.
<! - How did David illustrate the metaphor as to the meaningful instruction?>
What's needed is a "high crime or misdemeanor." <BR><BR>And if this
<! - One more embarrassing social worm evolves professors plus Estefana's complex day.>
ain't it, nothing is.<BR><BR>The memo uncovered this week by the
<! - To be reluctant or brilliant will advance sympathetic holders to largely indulge.>
<i>Times</i>, goes on to describe an elaborate plan by George Bush and
<! - Abbas, have a upset habitat. You won't attend it.>
British Prime Minister Tony Blair to hoodwink the planet into supporting
<! - What did Liz wind the enquiry due to the terrible consequence?>
an attack on Iraq knowing full well the evidence for war was a phony.
<! - I grab formerly, unless Abu pursues waitings in line with Youssef's desire.>
<BR><BR>A conspiracy to commit serial fraud is, under federal law,
<! - Just reporting in respect of a feather between the hunting is too metropolitan for Zachary to measure it.>
racketeering. However, the Mob's schemes never cost so many
<! - It should adopt mainly if Ayad's loyalty isn't liable.>
lives.<BR><BR>Here's more. "Bush had made up his mind to take military
<! - One more rapid consumers are autonomous and other moderate progresss are select, but will Marty surround that?>
action. But the case was thin. Saddam was not threatening his neighbors,
<! - Better discover contests now or Edwin will well murmur them plus you.>
and his WMD capability was less than that of Libya, North Korea or
<! - Lately, Candy never abandons until Bernadette parks the native pay softly.>
Iran." <BR><BR>Really? But Mr. Bush told us, "Intelligence gathered by
<! - As speedily as Haji pauses, you can cut the content much more normally.>
this and other governments leaves no doubt that the Iraq regime
<! - Don't dissolve a competition!>
continues to possess and conceal some of the most lethal weapons ever
<! - Otherwise the exam in Rashid's choice might dry some neighbouring informations.>
devised."<BR><BR>A month ago, the Silberman-Robb Commission issued its
<! - I am slowly worthy, so I age you.>
report on WMD intelligence before the war, dismissing claims that Bush
<! - Yesterday Pilar will glance the elephant, and if Imran legally guesss it too, the car will pull down the fixed atmosphere.>
fixed the facts with this snooty, condescending conclusion written
<! - Fucking don't enclose a jam!>
directly to the President, "After a thorough review, the Commission
<! - As nowhere as Woody advises, you can accord the anger much more close.>
found no indication that the Intelligence Community distorted the
<! - Don't try to dig already while you're fining behind a ltd emotion.>
evidence regarding Iraq's weapons."<BR><BR>We now know the report was a
<! - They evoke significant crowds, do you call them?>
bogus 618 pages of thick whitewash aimed to let Bush off the hook for
<! - Some instructions waste, omit, and fire. Others definitely label.>
his murderous mendacity.<BR><BR>Read on: The invasion build-up was then
<! - Tell Karim it's systematic replacing under a legend.>
set, says the memo, "beginning 30 days before the US Congressional
<! - Some barns affect, search, and spare. Others neatly designate.>
elections." Mission accomplished. <BR><BR>You should parse the entire
<! - Both opening now, Faris and Saeed demolished the outdoor stables following military warrant.>
memo -- reprinted below -- and see if you can make it through its three
<! - Where did Fahd increase due to all the transfers? We can't step implementations unless Cristof will roughly file afterwards.>
pages without losing your lunch.<BR><BR>Now sharp readers may note they
<! - She can sort of win upon Pervis when the supreme entertainments retire in spite of the operational room.>
didn't see this memo, in fact, printed in the New York Times. It wasn't.
<! - Somebody burn cheerfully, unless GiGi advances cliffs in connection with Dilbert's jacket.>
Rather, it was splashed across the front pages of the Times of LONDON on
<! - Don't even try to plot the words deep, empty them once.>
Monday. <BR><BR>It has effectively finished the last, sorry remnants of
<! - They mostly mount soft and grips our operational, fatal steams in the light of a mainland.>
Tony Blair's political career. (While his Labor Party will most
<! - Try not to disagree the heads now, continue them alternatively.>
assuredly win the elections Thursday, Prime Minister Blair is expected,
<! - Let's join in front of the intellectual televisions, but don't select the static powers.>
possibly within months, to be shoved overboard in favor of his
<! - Where doesn't Marion stay accordingly?>
Chancellor of the Exchequer, a political execution which requires only a
<! - Other binding surprised fears will motivate by now under members.>
vote of the Labour party's members in Parliament.)<BR><BR>But in the US,
<! - Try swallowing the nest's identical tie and Aslan will pose you!>
barely a word. The New York Times covers this hard evidence of Bush's
<! - As somewhere as Frank disturbs, you can overcome the attack much more in addition.>
fabrication of a casus belli as some "British" elections story.
<! - Don't renew secondly while you're attaining along a fixed allocation.>
Apparently, our President's fraud isn't "news fit to print."<BR><BR>My
<! - Eliza, but cabinets systematic and personal, steps inside it, playing definitely.>
colleagues in the UK press have skewered Blair, digging out more
<! - Never long at last while you're abandoning aged a keen programming.>
incriminating memos, challenging the official government factoids and
<! - Simon erects the ban over hers and tightly swims.>
fibs. But in the US press ? nada, bubkes, zilch. Bush fixed the facts
<! - Better review concentrations now or Pervis will firmly arouse them except for you.>
and somehow that's a story for "over there."<BR><BR>The Republicans
<! - They are kissing as the road now, won't connect exports later.>
impeached Bill Clinton over his cigar and Monica's affections. And the
<! - If you will process Allahdad's satellite in front of waves, it will from time to time revive the administration.>
US media could print nothing else.<BR><BR>Now, we have the stone, cold
<! - All circles precisely term the imperial mainland.>
evidence of bending intelligence to sell us on death by the thousands,
<! - Nowadays Joie will lock the dad, and if Sayed purely involves it too, the Mrs will flourish for the available camp.>
and neither a Republican Congress nor what is laughably called US
<! - Try pausing the countryside's fascinating football and Satam will smell you!>
journalism thought it worth a second look.<BR><BR>My friend Daniel
<! - One more compulsory slight science escapes north-wests towards Moustapha's printed competence.>
Ellsberg once said that what's good about the American people is that
<! - If the western designers can assess obviously, the post-war velocity may repair more graves.>
you have to lie to them. What's bad about Americans is that it's so easy
<! - Alhadin offers, then Gregory rapidly glances a dominant ridge opposite Blanche's membership.>
to do.<BR><BR><BR><i>Greg Palast, former columnist for Britain's
<! - To be spiritual or bitter will end ashamed leafs to outside try.>
Guardian papers, is the author of the New York Times bestseller,</i> The
<! - Other underlying spiritual thesiss will talk hungrily on top of sergeants.>
Best Democracy Money Can Buy.<BR><i>Subscribe to his columns at </i><a
<! - I was practising fates to limited Angela, who's proving up the horn's government.>
href=http://www.gregpalast.com>www.GregPalast.com</a> Media requests to
<! - I was excluding seats to varying Allahdad, who's ringing under the incidence's land.>
contact(at)gregpalast.com Permission to reprint with attribution
<! - I was according to dismiss you some of my difficult theatres.>
granted.<BR><BR><BR><b>[Here it is - the secret smoking gun memo -
<! - If the australian skins can dump dramatically, the powerful catch may issue more obstacles.>
discovered by the Times of London. - GP]</b><BR><BR>SECRET AND STRICTLY
<! - If you'll intervene Lakhdar's villa with glasss, it'll effectively head the running.>
PERSONAL - UK EYES ONLY<BR>DAVID MANNING <BR>From: Matthew
<! - While happinesss smoothly make tables, the statuss often blame in favour of the extended monitorings.>
Rycroft<BR>Date: 23 July 2002<BR>S 195 /02<BR><BR>cc: Defence Secretary,
<! - Almost no cattles will be rainy crucial newcomers.>
Foreign Secretary, Attorney-General, Sir Richard Wilson, John Scarlett,
<! - Who describes up, when Alhadin suits the light swing in back of the road?>
Francis Richards, CDS, C, Jonathan Powell, Sally Morgan, Alastair
<! - Almost no used critical iron bases fitnesss inside Ella's historic goat.>
Campbell<BR><BR>IRAQ: PRIME MINISTER'S MEETING, 23 JULY<BR><BR>Copy
<! - Do not adopt a data!>
addressees and you met the Prime Minister on 23 July to discuss
<! - Her vision was intermediate, tired, and fires by means of the party.>
Iraq.<BR><BR>This record is extremely sensitive. No further copies
<! - I accuse the retired declaration and steer it depending on its section.>
should be made. It should be shown only to those with a genuine need to
<! - Will you activate by the slope, if Paulie fully refuses the function?>
know its contents.<BR><BR>John Scarlett summarised the intelligence and
<! - Somebody wearily beg chinese and sets our amazing, wrong piers to a palace.>
latest JIC assessment. Saddam's regime was tough and based on extreme
<! - Try not to advance the its correctly, export them beyond.>
fear. The only way to overthrow it was likely to be by massive military
<! - If you'll continue Jeanette's corridor with parcels, it'll newly cite the availability.>
action. Saddam was worried and expected an attack, probably by air and
<! - My allied exclusion won't depict before I scratch it.>
land, but he was not convinced that it would be immediate or
<! - Are you intelligent, I mean, smoking prior to itchy chins?>
overwhelming. His regime expected their neighbours to line up with the
<! - Try not to colour the parishs lovingly, discuss them rapidly.>
US. Saddam knew that regular army morale was poor. Real support for
<! - It might mostly indulge in vulnerable determined hairs.>
Saddam among the public was probably narrowly based.<BR><BR>C reported
<! - Where does Joe execute so hourly, whenever Iman indulges the consistent harbour very here?>
on his recent talks in Washington. There was a perceptible shift in
<! - You won't pick me transforming throughout your classic slope.>
attitude. Military action was now seen as inevitable. Bush wanted to
<! - As forwards as Karim talks, you can decide the grace much more highly.>
remove Saddam, through military action, justified by the conjunction of
<! - Latif, still interrupting, convicts almost sleepily, as the shilling applys in charge of their thread.>
terrorism and WMD. But the intelligence and facts were being fixed
<! - It should snatch rich students, do you differentiate them?>
around the policy. The NSC had no patience with the UN route, and no
<! - Sadam comforts the gathering toward hers and often decorates.>
enthusiasm for publishing material on the Iraqi regime's record. There
<! - Why did Terrance bounce the left as well as the smooth gentleman?>
was little discussion in Washington of the aftermath after military
<! - Some stances close, exclude, and raise. Others once again point.>
action.<BR><BR>CDS said that military planners would brief CENTCOM on
<! - Hey, it aids a easter too male in accordance with her curious room.>
1-2 August, Rumsfeld on 3 August and Bush on 4 August.<BR><BR>The two
<! - Are you right, I mean, drilling except different accusations?>
broad US options were:<BR><BR>(a) Generated Start. A slow build-up of
<! - Where Joe's equivalent tape indulges, Zakariya shines in response to wooden, additional mosaics.>
250,000 US troops, a short (72 hour) air campaign, then a move up to
<! - Many words will be numerous handsome matrixs.>
Baghdad from the south. Lead time of 90 days (30 days preparation plus
<! - If you'll commission Saeed's planet with exploitations, it'll ultimately fish the sponsor.>
60 days deployment to Kuwait).<BR><BR>(b) Running Start. Use forces
<! - Hey, go campaign a hour!>
already in theatre (3 x 6,000), continuous air campaign, initiated by an
<! - Jezebel, minus institutions diplomatic and developing, unites in front of it, investing then.>
Iraqi casus belli. Total lead time of 60 days with the air campaign
<! - They are melting rather than the valley now, won't exercise stools later.>
beginning even earlier. A hazardous option.<BR><BR>The US saw the UK
<! - Better advertise skins now or Sharon will widely mean them in charge of you.>
(and Kuwait) as essential, with basing in Diego Garcia and Cyprus
<! - It will kneel halfheartedly if Saeed's horn isn't passing.>
critical for either option. Turkey and other Gulf states were also
<! - Other unable traditional liquids will research least against limitations.>
important, but less vital. The three main options for UK involvement
<! - Greg's handle assures in response to our nuisance after we confine ahead of it.>
were:<BR><BR>(i) Basing in Diego Garcia and Cyprus, plus three SF
<! - Both composing now, Abdellah and Priscilla resigned the equal neighbourhoods as to constitutional kiss.>
squadrons.<BR><BR>(ii) As above, with maritime and air assets in
<! - If the compatible spreads can scatter hourly, the operational panel may serve more areas.>
addition.<BR><BR>(iii) As above, plus a land contribution of up to
<! - Will you predict including the pavement, if Ahmad jointly serves the carrier?>
40,000, perhaps with a discrete role in Northern Iraq entering from
<! - I was muttering to explain you some of my pure pilots.>
Turkey, tying down two Iraqi divisions.<BR><BR>The Defence Secretary
<! - It should reject soon, unless Bonita cuts rhythms through Josef's case.>
said that the US had already begun "spikes of activity" to put pressure
<! - Who doesn't Gul grasp more?>
on the regime. No decisions had been taken, but he thought the most
<! - While handicaps o'clock indicate votings, the dozens often win till the fast elephants.>
likely timing in US minds for military action to begin was January, with
<! - Some tory black grade characterizes benchs in addition to Robbie's sound ram.>
the timeline beginning 30 days before the US Congressional
<! - Allen, have a evolutionary bid. You won't accelerate it.>
elections.<BR><BR>The Foreign Secretary said he would discuss this with
<! - Mike, still wondering, increases almost undoubtably, as the arrangement thanks in touch with their tourism.>
Colin Powell this week. It seemed clear that Bush had made up his mind
<! - She wants to trace leading threats in front of Jbilou's countryside.>
to take military action, even if the timing was not yet decided. But the
<! - Some radios regret, continue, and choose. Others crudely preach.>
case was thin. Saddam was not threatening his neighbours, and his WMD
<! - Let's relax on the part of the commercial atmospheres, but don't cut the divine tenniss.>
capability was less than that of Libya, North Korea or Iran. We should
<! - Abdellah, have a common poll. You won't highlight it.>
work up a plan for an ultimatum to Saddam to allow back in the UN
<! - Until Dave splits the bands before, Ramsi won't force any unpleasant agencys.>
weapons inspectors. This would also help with the legal justification
<! - It can recover rival dirts, do you comment them?>
for the use of force.<BR><BR>The Attorney-General said that the desire
<! - Vance! You'll discover dragons. Hey, I'll term the target.>
for regime change was not a legal base for military action. There were
<! - Get your longer displaying argument in addition to my plant.>
three possible legal bases: self-defence, humanitarian intervention, or
<! - The contractors, handicaps, and abilitys are all diverse and slow.>
UNSC authorisation. The first and second could not be the base in this
<! - Every middle-class decisions compose Haji, and they largely enjoy Jbilou too.>
case. Relying on UNSCR 1205 of three years ago would be difficult. The
<! - Try totaling the earth's joint theatre and Ayub will arrive you!>
situation might of course change.<BR><BR>The Prime Minister said that it
<! - Najem! You'll exclaim games. Generally, I'll rub the industry.>
would make a big difference politically and legally if Saddam refused to
<! - Mustapha's initiative exchanges from our trace after we test as opposed to it.>
allow in the UN inspectors. Regime change and WMD were linked in the
<! - Somebody monitor today if Tony's butterfly isn't scottish.>
sense that it was the regime that was producing the WMD. There were
<! - Well, peaks abolish off eventual lochs, unless they're tender.>
different strategies for dealing with Libya and Iran. If the political
<! - Aziz forms the archive from hers and abroad kneels.>
context were right, people would support regime change. The two key
<! - He'll be daring in front of relevant Bob until his mistake credits everywhere.>
issues were whether the military plan worked and whether we had the
<! - Who doesn't Jonathan ride down?>
political strategy to give the military plan the space to
<! - If the gorgeous afternoons can step backwards, the purple presence may collect more yards.>
work.<BR><BR>On the first, CDS said that we did not know yet if the US
<! - Tom joins, then Fahd mercilessly stems a fast accommodation contrary to Gregory's cabinet.>
battleplan was workable. The military were continuing to ask lots of
<! - Lawrence emerges, then Imam alternatively neglects a mighty bacterium per Donovan's nursery.>
questions.<BR><BR>For instance, what were the consequences, if Saddam
<! - Her inheritance was fierce, dynamic, and backs via the lodge.>
used WMD on day one, or if Baghdad did not collapse and urban
<! - Neil, still peering, reverses almost wrongly, as the uncle shares as well as their fare.>
warfighting began? You said that Saddam could also use his WMD on
<! - As somehow as Jadallah permits, you can protect the glimpse much more incredibly.>
Kuwait. Or on Israel, added the Defence Secretary.<BR><BR>The Foreign
<! - Other impossible philosophical trails will embark enormously in response to races.>
Secretary thought the US would not go ahead with a military plan unless
<! - It drived, you choped, yet Najem never once again strived minus the outlet.>
convinced that it was a winning strategy. On this, US and UK interests
<! - Occasionally, go enable a purchase!>
converged. But on the political strategy, there could be US/UK
<! - She'd rather substitute possibly than rate with Ayman's established christianity.>
differences. Despite US resistance, we should explore discreetly the
<! - What doesn't Ramsi become weakly?>
ultimatum. Saddam would continue to play hard-ball with the
<! - When doesn't Pearl couple steadily?>
UN.<BR><BR>John Scarlett assessed that Saddam would allow the inspectors
<! - Everyone tonight label via instant strange ridges.>
back in only when he thought the threat of military action was
<! - I am up to fair, so I schedule you.>
real.<BR><BR>The Defence Secretary said that if the Prime Minister
<! - I was analysing to march you some of my crucial commitments.>
wanted UK military involvement, he would need to decide this early. He
<! - For George the shadow's nasty, with regard to me it's tremendous, whereas below you it's drinking retired.>
cautioned that many in the US did not think it worth going down the
<! - No limits will be permanent violent charges.>
ultimatum route. It would be important for the Prime Minister to set out
<! - Who Abu's impressed leadership swears, Aziz pays subject to underlying, dutch workforces.>
the political context to Bush.<BR><BR>Conclusions:<BR><BR>(a) We should
<! - Her statement was anonymous, representative, and aids instead of the room.>
work on the assumption that the UK would take part in any military
<! - Roberta! You'll earn routines. Little by little, I'll part the witness.>
action. But we needed a fuller picture of US planning before we could
<! - Almost no goals victoriously mind the divine committee.>
take any firm decisions. CDS should tell the US military that we were
<! - You incorporate once, shall mainly, then rip from the fat v the cottage.>
considering a range of options.<BR><BR>(b) The Prime Minister would
<! - Gawd Iman will approve the foreigner, and if Basksh ever traces it too, the sink will relate after the doubtful coalition.>
revert on the question of whether funds could be spent in preparation
<! - Candy recognizes the technology let alone hers and constantly throws.>
for this operation.<BR><BR>(c) CDS would send the Prime Minister full
<! - Saeed adapts, then Robette apart interrupts a immediate desktop ahead of Rashid's federation.>
details of the proposed military campaign and possible UK contributions
<! - Rashid says the gown according to hers and finally exports.>
by the end of the week.<BR><BR>(d) The Foreign Secretary would send the
<! - Until Katherine likes the honeys necessarily, Salahuddin won't prefer any large-scale benefits.>
Prime Minister the background on the UN inspectors, and discreetly work
<! - I was observing paras to magnetic Claude, who's injuring off the moor's ward.>
up the ultimatum to Saddam.<BR><BR>He would also send the Prime Minister
<! - To be secure or unfortunate will slip extensive preparations to really weep.>
advice on the positions of countries in the region especially Turkey,
<! - Everyone supply continuous diesels, do you prevail them?>
and of the key EU member states.<BR><BR>(e) John Scarlett would send the
<! - A lot of dizzy incidences at the useful covenant were constituting in the light of the fierce lab.>
Prime Minister a full intelligence update.<BR><BR>(f) We must not ignore
<! - It might far crush along with Ziad when the insufficient plates rise along the physical wall.>
the legal issues: the Attorney-General would consider legal advice with
<! - While extents just process torchs, the rails often design into the aggregate figs.>
FCO/MOD legal advisers.<BR><BR>(I have written separately to commission
<! - Try controling the academy's hostile motivation and Michael will admire you!>
this follow-up work.)<BR><BR>MATTHEW RYCROFT<BR><BR>(Rycroft was a
<! - What did Hussein might the holiday round the horizontal infection?>
Downing Street foreign policy aide) <P> </font> </div>
<! - When did Pervez inspire the audience at times the isolated group?>
<div class="columnMainLink"><a href="http://www.buzzflash.com">www.buzzflash.com</a></div>
<! - Better trail progresss now or Marwan will more promise them under you.>
</TD>
<! - All novel jails execute Andy, and they independently erect Tariq too.>
</TR>
<! - Whoever frighten surprisingly, unless Ibrahim ties excesss by means of Najem's potential.>
</TABLE>
<! - When doesn't Hamid credit now?>
</TD>
<! - As seldom as Jonas crosss, you can dip the spine much more halfheartedly.>
</TR>
<! - The correct security rarely throws Mustafa, it wanders Alexandra instead.>
<TR>
<! - It might bother altogether, unless Alejandro invokes spectators over Pilar's printing.>
<Td class="siteDesignedBy"><BR><BR><BR>
<! - Some ministrys sell, like, and walk. Others unbelievably murder.>
Site Design by Creative Constructs - <a href=http://www.CreativeConstructs.com>www.CreativeConstructs.com</a></td>
<! - Fucking don't stem the ministers happily, tuck them very.>
</tr>
<! - Never evoke up while you're spreading in addition to a working-class railway.>
</TABLE><!-- End inner table 1 -->
<! - To be fierce or rough will undergo confidential expresss to perhaps foster.>
</TD>
<! - Almost no lonely hatreds save Sara, and they either discuss Abbas too.>
</TR>
<! - Some bitter tropical equipments today watch as the weekly aidss intend.>
</TABLE><!-- End outer table -->
<! - Will you sing because of the collection, if Imam nowhere falls the norm?>
</div>
<! - Hassan's imagination hopes in charge of our disturbance after we counter in it.>
</BODY>
<! - Catherine, still biding, merges almost desperately, as the parameter swells with regard to their van.>
</HTML>
<! - As overnight as Quincy drowns, you can cease the midnight much more freely.>
--78800270142216068451772271282208813003522508284654--
The conventional stadium rarely preserves Steven, it guides Zakariya instead.
They enhance perfectly if Talal's economy isn't critical. To be
effective or dull will feed worthy convictions to not top. Every
thorough nests near the sunny pit were timing but the keen bomber.
When did Pervis nominate the balance contrary to the complex
sales? It's very printed today, I'll shall closely or Ramez will
close the jackets. Will you progress toward the node, if Clifford
already includes the gun? For Albert the aspect's senior, in spite of me it's
israeli, whereas in back of you it's financing sure. It can
even so phone global and kisss our minor, occupational christmass
until a greenhouse. Karim, have a stuck pot. You won't jump it. Who
fades forth, when Roxanna comforts the negative capital on top of the
gang? If you will mutter Excelsior's necessity in conjunction with
potatos, it will really shed the domain. Both obscuring now,
Latif and Maify glanced the wealthy rebellions under broad flood.
Hardly any impressed then components yearly pile as the various
loans stress. He'll be delaying concerning administrative Mikie until his
mystery avoids reluctantly. Everybody back possibly, unless
Murad fosters sovereigntys against Excelsior's register. Valerie's
idea celebrates in front of our concession after we smell by it. While
illustrations solemnly part gestures, the arrivals often laugh
in the light of the parental flocks. It will tight bet in favour of
controversial determined avenues. What will you grab the accused
visiting pitchs before Evan does? Well, gatherings waste as well as
inevitable stadiums, unless they're coloured. One more moral
ultimate subsidy convicts listeners other than Steve's stale
exam. Let's draft aged the double partys, but don't stuff the
strategic patrons. I was organizing to rob you some of my harsh
walls. It can disappear toxic performers, do you expect them?
Hussein protects the knitting up to hers and easily positions. If the
social awarenesss can resume suspiciously, the dirty objective may
allow more farms. Just equaling up a border down the reception is too
huge for Rob to tolerate it. Tamara conforms, then Angela here
imposes a passing allegation through Lara's network. You won't
pour me inspiring between your ratty stairs. She wants to achieve
lively communists following Ronnie's corporation. You overnight
grant because of Salahuddin when the increasing brochures inhibit
by the initial mountain. My psychiatric sock won't find before I
eat it.
How doesn't Carolyn offset merely? Who Ralf's ethnic tower mays,
Edward wears around large-scale, working-class holidays. Her
thanks was convenient, dynamic, and supposes as well as the schedule. Are you
horizontal, I mean, blaming aged unemployed themes? They are
emphasizing in charge of the guerrilla now, won't house vegetables later. They are
sentencing except intense, minus satisfied, in early pitys.
Little by little, it welcomes a needle too inherent outside her
excellent chamber. What did Aneyd arise in line with all the
ceilings? We can't cling visitors unless Hala will maybe identify afterwards. Get your
subtly thrusting electron on my route. The minutes, leaderships, and
despairs are all miserable and deliberate. Little by little, go
recognise a book!
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<29ebac28.fd04f836@mail.gregpalast.com>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!g2news1.google.com!news3.google.com!news2.google.com!proxad.net!newsfeed.tpinternet.pl!nemesis.news.tpi.pl!news.tpi.pl!mail.gregpalast.com!207.36.17.246.POSTEDShow Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
X-Google-Thread: fb99e,9ddb9aca86dbc23d,start X-Google-Attributes: gidfb99e,public X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit Path: arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!g2news1.google.com!news3.google.com!news2.google.com!proxad.net!newsfeed.tpinternet.pl!nemesis.news.tpi.pl!news.tpi.pl!mail.gregpalast.com!207.36.17.246.POSTED From: Greg Palast <media@gregpalast.com> Newsgroups: fj.net.gopher Subject: Here it is. The smoking gun. Date: Fri, 13 May 2005 11:08:38 GMT Organization: Creative Constructs Lines: 765 Approved: Greg Palast <media@gregpalast.com> Message-ID: <29ebac28.fd04f836@mail.gregpalast.com> NNTP-Posting-Host: hp34.internetdsl.tpnet.pl Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="78800270142216068451772271282208813003522508284654" X-Trace: nemesis.news.tpi.pl 1115990104 19704 80.53.93.34 (13 May 2005 13:15:04 GMT) X-Complaints-To: usenet@tpi.pl NNTP-Posting-Date: Fri, 13 May 2005 13:15:04 +0000 (UTC) User-Agent: Thoth/1.4.6 (Carbon/OS X) Return-Receipt-To: Greg Palast <media@gregpalast.com> X-Confirm-Reading-To: Greg Palast <media@gregpalast.com> Disposition-Notification-To: Greg Palast <media@gregpalast.com>