🚀 go-pugleaf

"PMG" wrote:

> It's not a matter of proof.  First off, Chess is never played perfect. 
> What I posted was Crafty's annotations of the moves in the game, it
> indicated that White made 2 serious tactical errors, that's why Black
> won.

At the first point where your analysis shows a blunder by White,
Crafty reckoned White was 5 pawns down even after Crafty's
preferred move. The White blunders that actually lost the game
were earlier on. Nxe5 is a bad move. Nxf7 is a *terrible* move.

It's odd that your Crafty doesn't annotate Nxf7. Presumably it
has the move in its book (doubtless with a note that it's a
dreadful move) and therefore doesn't provide any analysis.

You are, of course, quite right that to annotate ...Nd4 with
an exclamation mark merely because in this game White committed
suicide is bizarre.

-- 
Gareth McCaughan  Gareth.McCaughan@pobox.com
sig under construction