🚀 go-pugleaf

RetroBBS NetNews Server

Inspired by RockSolid Light RIP Retro Guy

Article View: hfx.general
Article #430

Re: InfoInterActive (IIA-A)

#430
From: James H. Steiger
Date: Sat, 13 Dec 1997 00:00
120 lines
6076 bytes
ak955@chebucto.ns.ca (Barbara Amero) wrote:

>James H. Steiger (steiger@remove.this.to.reply.unixg.ubc.ca) wrote:
>: ak955@chebucto.ns.ca (Barbara Amero) wrote:
>
>: >That fella should qualify which males, as I did - misogynist men like
>: >Steiger, and I will now add John Jenkins Sr., aka daddio (gawdhepus).
>: >
>
>: Feminist dictionary:
>
>: mis-o-gyn-ist  1. A man whose arguments make a misandrist feel
>: uncomfortable.  
>
>I've never seen a "Feminist dictionary".

Funny, you seem to use one constantly. 

>
>Steiger's argument that 1/3 of rape accusations are false makes me
>feel right some uncomfortable. 

Of course they would. They counteract your very slanted presentation!

>Whose interests are served by flogging <snip>

those data?  Easy -- the interests of anyone who cares
about accuracy in social science! The data are fascinating!

>Certainly not women's interests. 

You're confusing "women's interests" with your interests.
Is it in "women's interests" to have huge amounts of resources
wasted hunting imaginary rapists?

You have little to do in life other than rant inaccurately
about your twisted view of the world, one in which women 
live in constant fear, and male perpetrators lurk around
every dark corner.

Hence, your interest is in trolling the internet with your
outdated quotes from Women's Studies classes, hoping to 
arouse hostility from outraged readers, so that you can
then claim you were offended, wounded, victimized, etc.,
and gain a fair measure of revenge against the intelligent,
accomplished, rational people of the world.

Rational people would ignore you, except that we have found
that, by ignoring the kind of misandrist nonsense you post, we are
giving it credence by default.

Women's interests are served by having honest, open access
to the world, and not by having a paranoid, incorrect view
of the world.

>To say that 1/3 of rape
>accusations are false is illogical, when you consider it is estimated
>that only about 10% of rapes/sexual assaults are reported because, for
>one, women do not want to be faced with such an ordeal.

Now that's a classic example of Amero Logic in action. 

First, the "estimate" of "only about 10%" has been widely discredited.
It is a complete myth. 

But even a 9th grader could tell you that both the above statistics
*could* be true simultaneously. Problem is, your 10% has been
discredited, while mine is supported by hard evidence, published
in reputable places.

But, perhaps more important, the whole notion that rape is a prevalent
crime, and that a substantial minority of women, as many as 25%, have
been raped or sexually assaulted in their lifetime is also false, an
artifactual finding resulting from bad research procedures.


>
>One rape myth is that "the woman was trying to get back at the man she was
>angry with". 
>Burt (1980) has shown that rape myth

Burt showed nothing, because this isn't a myth...it has been verified
in two independent studies... Burt, I suspect, simply did a study
showing a certain multivariate structure of attitudes. This has
nothing to do with showing that anything was a myth. Feminists
think that by labeling attitudes "myths," they can automatically
discredit them. Some feminists have said "women never lie about rape."
Now, *there* is a real rape myth.

The studies of fabricated rape allegations were ones in which women
themselves *admitted* in writing what they did, and why. They
volunteered the explanations. They made the original false
accusations. Ask anyone who works in law enforcement. There are high
profile cases of such fabrications all the time.

For example, just very recently, a woman whose claims of rape 
and abduction had prompted a very extensive [and expensive]
police manhunt admitted the whole thing was a fabrication.
Did the police put her in jail? No. Did they make her pay
anything? Not that I know of. Women get away
scot-free with this behavior most of the time. Until
we get strict legal penalties in place, this will continue,
and a fair number of innocent [completely innocent] men
will be rounded up and put in jail.

I leave with a quote from an article that appeared recently. 

Read and heed, Barbara.


"[Jill] Hightower, who is 60, and has been married for 42 years,
said feminists interested in reducing spousal abuse should be reaching
out to the majority of men who are not violent and toning down their
rhetoric. 'We have to work with the whole of society,' she said."

     -- Vancouver Province

[Jill Hightower is executive director of the B.C. Institute for Family
Violence]
Technical Details
Message-ID: <34931eb0.183597565@news.ucs.ubc.ca>
Path: arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!unknown!not-for-mail
References: <65vepi$8hj$1@News.Dal.Ca> <65vj3f$980$1@News.Dal.Ca> <34838272.5520@mail.required.org> <348400A7.6DC9@hotmail.com> <661p86$j8j$1@News.Dal.Ca> <34849205.47DD@mail.required.org> <663vd5$rjc$1@News.Dal.Ca> <3488dedd.5590573@news.thezone.net> <66tar6$8oe$1@News.Dal.Ca> <34923fc7.126524252@news.ucs.ubc.ca> <66ttin$9of$2@News.Dal.Ca>

Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit
X-Google-Thread: f7b9c,55c4bb8881e9d04e
X-Google-Attributes: gidf7b9c,public
X-Google-Thread: fc83c,55c4bb8881e9d04e
X-Google-Attributes: gidfc83c,public
X-Google-Thread: fbdd9,55c4bb8881e9d04e
X-Google-Attributes: gidfbdd9,public
X-Google-Thread: fed9c,55c4bb8881e9d04e
X-Google-Attributes: gidfed9c,public
X-Google-Thread: 10e4c3,55c4bb8881e9d04e
X-Google-Attributes: gid10e4c3,public
X-Google-Thread: 111b2d,55c4bb8881e9d04e
X-Google-Attributes: gid111b2d,public
X-Google-Thread: 112f74,55c4bb8881e9d04e
X-Google-Attributes: gid112f74,public
X-Google-Thread: 100ef4,55c4bb8881e9d04e
X-Google-Attributes: gid100ef4,public
From: steiger@remove.this.to.reply.unixg.ubc.ca (James H. Steiger)
Subject: Re: InfoInterActive (IIA-A)
Date: 1997/12/13
Message-ID: <34931eb0.183597565@news.ucs.ubc.ca>
X-Deja-AN: 297957570
References: <65vepi$8hj$1@News.Dal.Ca> <65vj3f$980$1@News.Dal.Ca> <34838272.5520@mail.required.org> <348400A7.6DC9@hotmail.com> <661p86$j8j$1@News.Dal.Ca> <34849205.47DD@mail.required.org> <663vd5$rjc$1@News.Dal.Ca> <3488dedd.5590573@news.thezone.net> <66tar6$8oe$1@News.Dal.Ca> <34923fc7.126524252@news.ucs.ubc.ca> <66ttin$9of$2@News.Dal.Ca>
Organization: The University of British Columbia
Newsgroups: hfx.general,ns.general,can.atlantic.biz,ns.online,nb.general,nb.access,nb.biz,ab.general,bc.general