Article View: la.eats
Article #42Re: MSG
From: Yokichi Tanaka
Date: Mon, 03 Aug 1992 21:11
Date: Mon, 03 Aug 1992 21:11
51 lines
2996 bytes
2996 bytes
I'm not an expert on chemicals, but here is my limited un-scientific understanding of MSG. MSG = monosodium glutamate It has a distinct flavor. It's the main ingredient in Dash and Aji-no-moto (Japanese). In fact I think aji-no-moto is all MSG. Chicken and beef bouillon (such as Knorr's) contain a lot of MSG. Japanese used to take shaved fish (dried bonita) and dried little fish (jyako) and perhaps some seaweed and boil them together to obtain a "dashi" flavoring. When MSG was discovered (or invented) it made attaining this flavor much easier. Use of MSG quickly became widespread in Japan, China and Korea. Soon, however, it was learned that MSG was carcinogenic (I think). Also, many people would get a buzz if they consumed too much MSG. The health craze of the '80s led many restaurants to advertise "no MSG". What most stores mean by "no MSG" is that they don't add any MSG in its pure form to its food. It's very difficult to prepare some Chinese dishes completely free of MSG, because, I believe, oyster sauce contains some MSG. I have also heard that some soy sauces contain MSG. Most Chinese and Japanese dishes taste better with that MSG-like taste added to it. If you go to a regular restaurant (non-no-MSG, or yes-MSG) and ask that dishes be prepared without MSG, the food may taste somewhat bland. It depends if the restaurant compensates the lack of MSG with some kind of fish flavoring (or "dashi" in the case of Japanese restaurants.) Places that advertise that they don't use MSG on any of their dishes, probably do a better job of compensating for the lack of MSG. MSG doesn't bother me too much, but my wife gets light-headed and sometimes nauseous by it. Before MSG, Japanese ramen shops (noodles) would pride on making the best soup by experimenting with different "dashi"s. (For more, check out a Japanese film called "Tampopo". It's not that good a movie, but you will get a better understanding of Japaneses' fickleness/obsession with the ultimate ramen.) Today, most ramen shops use MSG for convenience. It's hard to describe the taste of MSG in words. When I was a child, before its ill effects were known, I used to pour some on the table and lick it using my finger. I haven't developed cancer yet though. I can not always tell whether a particular flavoring in a dish was obtained via MSG or via "dashi". -- Yokichi (Yoke) Tanaka Togai InfraLogic, Inc. "fuzzy" tanaka@til.com Irvine, California, USA uunet!til!tanaka 714-975-8522 "The more you drive, the less intelligent you are."
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<1992Aug3.211112.7565@til.til.com>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!sparky!uunet!til!til!tanakaReferences:
<1992Aug2.002106.23712@cco.caltech.edu>Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
Newsgroups: la.eats Path: arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!sparky!uunet!til!til!tanaka From: tanaka@til.til.com (Yokichi Tanaka) Subject: Re: MSG Message-ID: <1992Aug3.211112.7565@til.til.com> Sender: tanaka@til (Yokichi Tanaka) Nntp-Posting-Host: til Organization: Togai InfraLogic, Inc. References: <1992Aug2.002106.23712@cco.caltech.edu> Date: Mon, 3 Aug 1992 21:11:12 GMT Lines: 51