Article View: milw.general
Article #446Re: Unruly Black children upset over discipline
From: johnwesley55
Date: Sun, 26 Jun 2005 12:31
Date: Sun, 26 Jun 2005 12:31
212 lines
10726 bytes
10726 bytes
- wrote: > http://www.nationalvanguard.org > > Residents Scream 'Racism' Over School Suspension Rates > Report; Posted on: 2005-06-24 > [ Printer friendly / Instant flyer ] > > > Unruly Black children upset over discipline. > > > For parents such as John Jackson Jr., the discipline gap between white > and black students in the Milwaukee area is so wide, you couldn't jump > over it with rockets in your shoes. > > In 1999, black students constituted about 6.5% of enrollment in > suburban schools but received nearly 22% of all suspensions. In 2004, > they accounted for slightly more of the enrollment - 7% - but, at > almost 25%, for an even greater share of suspensions. > > In Milwaukee Public Schools, where black students make up about 60% of > the student body, they still accounted for 75% of the suspensions in > 1999 and about 77% in 2004 - a similar disparity to the suburbs. > > "The knee-jerk fear of race is one of the core problems," said Tammy > Johnson, director of the Race and Public Policy Program at the Applied > Research Center, a think tank in California. "It's no use to say we > see no color and that we treat each child equally." > > > ------------------------------------------------------ > http://www.jsonline.com/news/metro/jun05/335047.asp > > > E-MAIL > PRINT THIS STORY > > Metro area schools show racial gap in suspensions > By CHASE DAVIS > Posted: June 19, 2005 > > > For parents such as John Jackson Jr., the discipline gap between white > and black students in the Milwaukee area is so wide, you couldn't jump > over it with rockets in your shoes. > > > The question needs to be asked: Is there > something about the way we're operating? > - Howard Fuller, > Marquette University professor and > former superintendent of > Milwaukee Public Schools > > > > > His two children, Janay and Jarred, just finished their sixth- and > ninth-grade years in the Shorewood School District. Neither has been > disciplined, but Jackson said that every day, chances are good that > someone just like them - young, black and possibly innocent - is. > > "I think it's very unfair," he said. "It doesn't seem like it's changing." > > In schools in the five-county Milwaukee area, black students > consistently have been suspended disproportionately more than their > enrollment while white students have been suspended less, according to > a Journal Sentinel analysis of state discipline data from the 1998-'99 > school year to the 2003-'04 school year, the most recent year > available. > > In 1999, black students constituted about 6.5% of enrollment in > suburban schools but received nearly 22% of all suspensions. In 2004, > they accounted for slightly more of the enrollment - 7% - but, at > almost 25%, for an even greater share of suspensions. > > White students, by comparison, made up about 87% of enrollment in the > suburbs in 1999 and accounted for relatively fewer suspensions - about > 67%. That gap grew slightly in 2004, when white enrollment dropped to > about 84% and white suspensions fell even further to almost 62%. > > In Milwaukee Public Schools, where black students make up about 60% of > the student body, they still accounted for 75% of the suspensions in > 1999 and about 77% in 2004 - a similar disparity to the suburbs. > > The Journal Sentinel used the same state data to measure MPS but > examined it separately from the suburbs because of the size of the > district. > > > Reason for gap unclear > > The gap is hardly news to Milwaukee-area educators, who, like their > peers across the country, have struggled to make sense of it. What's > more difficult to understand, they said, is why the gap exists and how > to cinch it up. > > "This isn't just a problem here; it's a problem everywhere," said > Howard Fuller, a former MPS superintendent who is a professor at > Marquette University. "The question needs to be asked: Is there > something about the way we're operating?" > > Milwaukee is not alone in struggling with racially lopsided > suspensions. A similar gap appears on the state level and in school > districts across the United States. It has been documented meticulously > for decades, with no single reason prevailing as the cause. > > Educators have suggested potential causes for the disparity: white > teachers misunderstanding black students; poverty; different > expectations and cultures at home and school; and even pure coincidence. > > In Brown Deer, which in 2004 had a black enrollment of 35% and a black > suspension rate of 63%, district leaders have found that the longer > students spend in the district, regardless of race or socioeconomic > status, the less often they get into trouble. > > "It's not so much the color of your skin," Superintendent Bruce Connolly > said. "Once kids get with the program, their discipline rates drop off." > > Others said the reason is cultural. Often, teachers are leery of the > louder, more active styles of communication that characterize some > black teens, experts and officials said. Teachers might interpret > play-fighting as real fighting or yelling as disrespect. "Sometimes, a > group of students making a lot of noise is just being noisy," said > Whitefish Bay Superintendent James Rickabaugh. "Sometimes, we > overreact to that." > > Statistically, there seems to be some link between several of the > issues raised by administrators and the increasing gap in area school > districts, the Journal Sentinel found. > > Enrollment in the Chapter 220 integration program, for instance, > correlates with the size of the disparity gap. The more a district's > enrollment includes Chapter 220 students, the more disproportionately > black students tend to be suspended there. The same is true with a > district's overall black enrollment: the more black students, the more > disparity. > > That doesn't mean Chapter 220 or a large black enrollment causes > disproportionate discipline. Rather, the numbers show that the gap > exists, and often grows, even in some of the metro area's most diverse > school districts. > > Other common explanations, such as poverty, seem to have little or > nothing to do with the magnitude of the discipline gap. State data > show a district could have a large or small disparity no matter how > many students qualify for free and reduced-price lunches there. > > > Parents say race is a factor > > Some parents have a more simple explanation: Black students are being > suspended more often simply because they are black. > > "If there's a white kid, he'd just go to the principal's office," said > Lionell Perry Jr., a Milwaukee parent who has sent four children to > suburban schools through the Chapter 220 program. "If an > African-American student does the same identical thing, he'd be sent > home." > > Parents such as Perry describe the suburban school system as > predominantly white and inflexible, unwilling to adapt to an > increasingly diverse student body. Some said that the districts have > been slow to deal with the issue and that their children sometimes > feel isolated. > > "There's a certain sense of camaraderie at some of these schools, and > African-American kids are sometimes outside that camaraderie," said > Jackson, the Milwaukee parent whose two children attend Shorewood > schools. > > Administrators said the challenge lies in striking a difficult balance > between making students adjust to a system some call too rigid and > adapting the system to a more diverse generation of students. > > But whereas many officials of the districts with the largest > disparities said they recognize the problem, few have put any > district-level policies in place to address it. > > Superintendents said they have made colorblind policy decisions > designed to curtail suspensions for all students, but others said an > unwillingness to consider race a factor stymies efforts to fix the gap. > > "The knee-jerk fear of race is one of the core problems," said Tammy > Johnson, director of the Race and Public Policy Program at the Applied > Research Center, a think tank in California. "It's no use to say we > see no color and that we treat each child equally." > > One school cited as a model by the center was James Lick Middle School > in San Francisco. In 1999, administrators there said that race skewed > child discipline, Johnson said, then rigorously studied how and why. > The result: The disparity began to diminish. > > Johnson said she advocates a race-based approach to leveling out > minority disparities. Parents such as Jackson agree. > > "Usually, the first solution to a problem," he said, "is recognizing > there is a problem." > Does anyone expect differant behavior from children with an average IQ of 85? These little negroes pollute the educational evironment for other kids. John > > > > > > 2005, Journal Sentinel Inc.
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<1119789064.493098.313630@f14g2000cwb.googlegroups.com>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!g2news1.google.com!postnews.google.com!f14g2000cwb.googlegroups.com!not-for-mailReferences:
<42bc2fea.496403270@news.isomedia.com>Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
X-Google-Thread: fcd36,7552780e0eaa30e4,start X-Google-Thread: fa03c,7552780e0eaa30e4,start X-Google-Thread: 10e835,7552780e0eaa30e4,start X-Google-Thread: 1037c2,7552780e0eaa30e4,start X-Google-Thread: f9e27,7552780e0eaa30e4,start X-Google-Attributes: gidfcd36,gidfa03c,gid10e835,gid1037c2,gidf9e27,public X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit Path: arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!g2news1.google.com!postnews.google.com!f14g2000cwb.googlegroups.com!not-for-mail From: johnwesley55@lycos.com Newsgroups: milw.general,wi.general,chi.general,neworleans.general,misc.education Subject: Re: Unruly Black children upset over discipline Date: 26 Jun 2005 05:31:04 -0700 Organization: http://groups.google.com Lines: 213 Message-ID: <1119789064.493098.313630@f14g2000cwb.googlegroups.com> References: <42bc2fea.496403270@news.isomedia.com> NNTP-Posting-Host: 162.42.85.22 Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1" X-Trace: posting.google.com 1119789069 18146 127.0.0.1 (26 Jun 2005 12:31:09 GMT) X-Complaints-To: groups-abuse@google.com NNTP-Posting-Date: Sun, 26 Jun 2005 12:31:09 +0000 (UTC) In-Reply-To: <42bc2fea.496403270@news.isomedia.com> User-Agent: G2/0.2 Complaints-To: groups-abuse@google.com Injection-Info: f14g2000cwb.googlegroups.com; posting-host=162.42.85.22; posting-account=4mykOw0AAAAdW7jCx-TkwPfDRu97TUm0