Article View: misc.headlines
Article #401Re: More responses from Ralph Winston forthcoming in a few days
From: David L Paktor
Date: Fri, 10 Apr 1992 08:51
Date: Fri, 10 Apr 1992 08:51
79 lines
4096 bytes
4096 bytes
In Message <gate.Du7eiB1w164w@b-cpu.UUCP>
ralphw@b-cpu.UUCP (Ralph Winston) writes:
> Those of you who are eager to read my amazingly stupid, inaccurate
> and malicious responses will probably get just what you deserve...
>
> Ralph Winston
Oh, Happy Happy, Joy Joy! Breathless anticipation! Eager delight! Drool!
Slurp! Dribble! Yummmmm.... And -- what's that smell?
Oh, right. Sarcasm, of course.
Those of you who have been following the net for the past year or so
may remember Winston as the 'Talmudic Scholar' who posted a bunch
of trash purporting to be "excerpts from the Talmud", and which was
supposed to "prove" something-or-other. After a few refutations
from persons who were genuinely knowledgeable about such matters,
verifying the fraudulent nature of these purported quotes, someone
recognized and identified the whole collection as a reprint of early-
-part-of-the-century Polish anti-Semitic libels.
One of the clear indications that it was Polish, (besides actually
recognizing it historically) is the nature of the transliterations,
which follow the rules of Polish orthography -- in particular, 'sz'
for 'shin' and 'w' for 'vav'.
The fact that he let it slip by, combined with the fact that he had
access to such stuff at all, makes me wonder if Ralph Winston is
for real -- that is to say, if he is really who he purports to be.
I suspect that he is posting under a pseudonym, and is, in fact an
older person of Polish origin, probably one who emigrated late
in life, at an age where linguistic patterns are well-settled in
and hard to change.
For all we know, 'he' may even be a woman, posting under a cross-gender
as well as cross-cultural pseudonym.
Of course, his frequent excursions into denying the murderous intent
of the German state towards the Jewish People during World War II,
and his protestations against their burden of guilt, suggest that
he may actually be a German, instead.
But in either case, he would not be the young WASP-y individual who
tastes-good-like-a-cigarette-should that the name conjures to mind.
Granted, these are narrow clues from which to try to move on to such
a grand conclusion, so this is nothing more than sheer speculation
on my part.
Does anyone "out there" have any more solid information to go on?
Does anyone know whether this 'Ralph Winston' is character really
who 'he' purports to be? Or who 'he' is really?
Can we take a clue from spelling his name backwards? I get something
like: "Notsni wh plar" which I make out to be: "Notsi" (=Nazi)
"wh" (abbreviation for "with his") "plar" (loose anagram for "pals").
Nazi With His Pals === Ralph Winston. Now, that tastes like a cigarette...
David
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~|~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~|~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
=== Mister Systems === | David L Paktor | Paktor@cup.Portal.com
| |
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
A recent survey showed that 80% of Americans think Dan Quayle is
not qualified to be President. What is disturbing about this,
is that it implies that 20% think he is.
However, we can take some reassurance in the notion that these
are probably the same 20% that think Elvis is still alive...
(Actually, the number is closer to 17%;
Dan Quayle thinks that's more than half.)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<57201@cup.portal.com>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!sparky!uunet!cs.utexas.edu!asuvax!mcdphx!udc!motcsd!apple!portal!cup.portal.com!PaktorReferences:
<gate.Du7eiB1w164w@b-cpu.UUCP>Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
Path: arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!sparky!uunet!cs.utexas.edu!asuvax!mcdphx!udc!motcsd!apple!portal!cup.portal.com!Paktor From: Paktor@cup.portal.com (David L Paktor) Newsgroups: misc.headlines,talk.politics.misc,talk.politics.mideast,soc.misc Subject: Re: More responses from Ralph Winston forthcoming in a few days Message-ID: <57201@cup.portal.com> Date: 10 Apr 92 08:51:00 GMT References: <gate.Du7eiB1w164w@b-cpu.UUCP> Organization: The Portal System (TM) Lines: 79