🚀 go-pugleaf

In article <1992Apr15.132710.1008@ennews.eas.asu.edu> makowsky@enuxha.eas.asu.edu (David Makowsky) writes:
>   In article <JIME.92Apr14173310@bullwinkle.atc.ll.mit.edu> jime@bullwinkle.atc.ll.mit.edu (Jim Eggert x6127 g41) writes:
>   # Certainly a deportation of all Palestinians is racist.
>   # How do you
>   # choose whom to deport?  Not based on previous crimes, for not all
>   # Palestinians have committed crimes.
>
>	   Previous crimes would certainly be a factor.
>
>   # Not based on actual threat, for a
>   # peace-loving Palestinian (and such do exist) is no threat.
>
>	   As long as they agree to remain so, they can stay.
>
>   # The only
>   # criterion is that the person is a Palestinian, and this criterion is
>   # by itself racist.
>
>	   Again, you seem not to be able to read (or at least remember after
>   you read it).  That is not the only criteria.  In fact, it is not a
>   criteria at all.

Then why did you say that you want to deport all the Palestinians?
Would you deport Jews in your plan to solve the Palestinian problem?

>   # Would you include in the deportation order any Jew
>   # who advocates the establishment of a Palestinian state?  Such Jews
>   # exist in Israel.   Such advocacy would be considered by the likes of
>   # yourself to be a threat (please correct me if I'm wrong).  And yet
>   # they would not be deported.  This demonstrates the ultimate racism
>   # inherent in your deportation idea.
>
>	   Your nuts.  Anyone could advocate whatever they wanted.  THey
>   could advocate a "palestinian?" State.  They just would have to agree
>   not to do anything to bring it about, and they would have to agree to
>   remain peaceful

So you use a loyalty oath to the state of Israel as the deportation
criterion?  Anyone promising not to do anything to establish a
Palestinian state could stay, and everyone else gets deported?  This
would then be a political action that would result in the deportation
of many Israeli Jews as well.  It is also essentially a fascist
position, where political opposition to your line of thinking would be
forcibly eliminated.
--
=Jim  jime%atc.ll.mit.edu (Jim Eggert)