Article View: misc.rural
Article #1624Re: Generators
From: John A. Stanley
Date: Thu, 08 Sep 1994 00:50
Date: Thu, 08 Sep 1994 00:50
106 lines
6680 bytes
6680 bytes
In article <CvqJ41.Lr@cdthq.uucp>, Gary Heston (gary@cdthq.uucp) writes: >In article <498@solar.win.net> jstanley@solar.win.net (John A. Stanley) writes: > >>My electrical power comes from 2000 peak watts of photovoltaic >>panels and a 1000 watt wind generator on an 84' tilt-up tower. I >>also get most of my domestic hot water and heating energy from five >>solar thermal panels that heat the water in a 350 gallon insulated >>tank in the basement. Propane provides supplemental heat, cooking >>fuel, and backup electrical power. > >Would you mind describing this a little further, and possibly giving >some numbers on typical performance and costs, your typical gain from >the photovoltaic panels, typical consumption, hours of runtime on >the Onan generator, and such? Seeing as how I just today moved into the house for the first time, I don't have any numbers to throw at you. We've also had problems with the instrumentation (Cruising Equipment meters have proven to be total garbage; they keep going catatonic.) The reconditioned industrial NiCd batteries have also proven to have much less than stellar performance. So... once I switch over to lead-acids (which will require a heating system in the battery box) and change over to a computer-automated logging system for the instrumentation, I can come up with some real numbers... like in 6 months or so. The entire construction of the house was primarily powered by the sun (diesel fuel powered the rammed earth block machine, and the Onan powered the compressor for the nail gun so that the Trace could power all the saws.) Last winter they got the Whisper 1000 (wind generator) up and running. It is located about a quarter mile from the house out in the back 40, where it is on high ground and wide open to the N, NE, and NW; perfect for those howling winter winds. The unit puts out 240v three phase AC. That means all that power flows through a cheap piece of 10ga wire with only 2% line loss. It is stepped down and rectified at the power panel in the garage. The Onan is meant as a back-up only. The system should have sufficient sun and/or wind energy to meet all my needs. So why did I sink so much money into a generator that won't see much use? Because when I *do* need it, it will work; ya get what ya pay for. Also, cheap engines don't take too kindly to being converted to propane: gasoline provides top-end lubrication, propane doesn't. The Onan was designed to be run on propane, and therefore runs cleaner and more reliably (no old gas fouling up the carb.) Heat is in Wirsbo tubing embedded in the slab. This system simply heats up the floor. There are different zones with separate thermostats. This works marvelously with solar heat because the water in the system need not be any hotter that 110 deg. F. There is at the moment no heat in the small upstairs (~400 sq. ft.), but it is open to the downstairs in the center of the house, so the heat should rise up there. Warm air from the attached greenhouse can also be brought into the house for additional warmth. While the foundation has an R value of about 35, the slab is completely uninsulated. That means that the slab has a tendency to remain at ground temp when there is no heat on. This is a primary source of cooling in the summer. And actually, last winter when there was only plastic on the windows and no heating system, the house remained at 35-40 degrees in sub-zero weather. The wood burning fireplace insert would raise the temp about 15 degrees in several hours. Keep in mind that this is a 3000 sq. ft. house. Fresh air can be brought into the house through a huge concrete air plenum buried 10' underground. This system cools air in summer and warms it in winter. Costs? Obscenely expensive and twice what I had originally planned on. I have nothing more to say about this. >Did you look into, or whoever designed your system, using a DC >generator that could directly charge your batteries, instead of >making AC and feeding it into a charger? That would be far more >efficient, and is the way one UPS manufacturer does it. You'd then have a generator that can do nothing but charge the batteries. Can you say expensive boat anchor? There's a very good reason that my system is common: flexibility. I can disconnect my generator from the 4kw Trace inverter, switch it on, and presto! I have an additional 4kw of power at my disposal. Some folks downsize their system and use the generator to do laundry and other energy intensive tasks while charging up a smaller battery bank for powering lights, electronics, and refrigeration. Another problem: when my Onan is charging the batteries it's also powering the whole house. Try *that* with a low voltage dc generator; do you realize what kind of current you'd have to generate to do both tasks? Do you realize how humongous the windings would have to be? You'd have a bloody fortune in copper in such a generator. If you're willing to shut down your entire electrical system so that you can charge your batteries, then go for it. Me? My generator will come on automatically when the bank drops to a particular voltage, and I'll never even know it. The switch between inverter power and generator power is completely seamless. Homebrew types will sometimes rig up an old lawnmower engine to an old car alternator for battery charging, but my system is rather large with a 24v battery bank, not 12v. Your idea may be more efficient, but it sure is impractical, if not downright unworkable in a large system. -- John A. Stanley jstanley@solar.win.net
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<532@solar.win.net>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!nntp.gmd.de!Germany.EU.net!EU.net!howland.reston.ans.net!swiss.ans.net!malgudi.oar.net!witch!solar!jstanleyReferences:
<486@solar.win.net> <34drks$h0q@juniper.almaden.ibm.com> <498@solar.win.net><CvqJ41.Lr@cdthq.uucp>Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit X-Google-Thread: f88da,d8976f5412549006 X-Google-Attributes: gidf88da,public X-Google-Thread: 10db0a,27ef007800f67f48 X-Google-Attributes: gid10db0a,public X-Google-Thread: f5cce,d8976f5412549006 X-Google-Attributes: gidf5cce,public X-Google-Thread: 1012ff,27ef007800f67f48 X-Google-Attributes: gid1012ff,public X-Google-Thread: f514b,27ef007800f67f48 X-Google-Attributes: gidf514b,public X-Google-ArrivalTime: 1994-09-07 17:50:19 PST Path: arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!nntp.gmd.de!Germany.EU.net!EU.net!howland.reston.ans.net!swiss.ans.net!malgudi.oar.net!witch!solar!jstanley Newsgroups: misc.rural,misc.consumers.house,ba.mountain-folk Message-ID: <532@solar.win.net> References: <486@solar.win.net> <34drks$h0q@juniper.almaden.ibm.com> <498@solar.win.net><CvqJ41.Lr@cdthq.uucp> Reply-To: jstanley@solar.win.net (John A. Stanley) From: jstanley@solar.win.net (John A. Stanley) Date: Thu, 08 Sep 1994 00:50:19 GMT Subject: Re: Generators Lines: 103