Thread View: net.internat
5 messages
5 total messages
Started by Mike Banahan
Thu, 17 Oct 1985 14:00
Bureaucracy - delete this group!
Author: Mike Banahan
Date: Thu, 17 Oct 1985 14:00
Date: Thu, 17 Oct 1985 14:00
50 lines
3044 bytes
3044 bytes
Sigh!....
It looks as if in naievety and led on by excessive enthusiasm,
I overstepped the rules and regulations involved in setting up newsgroups.
The guardians of the news system rightly require that a number of steps
should be observed before unilaterally creating a newsgroup such as this one.
In my ignorance I underestimated what needed to be done.
Gene Spafford ( ..seismo!gatech!spaf) has pointed out my misdoings
and requests that the newsgroup should be renamed or removed. I would
like to say that the correspondence between us has been on a cordial
basis, and that I am quite ready to admit that the misunderstandings on
how to create this newsgroup have all been on my side.
If may be permitted to abstract from his last mail to me (a dangerous thing to
do, for quoting out of context can easily lead to misinterpretation),
he makes the following suggestions:
1) Form a moderated group.
2) Since the bulk of the postings come from Europe, restrict the
distribution to eunet.internat (or a similar group).
3) Do the work by mailing list.
I have no time to moderate such a group, and feel that the widespread discussion
that the topic should have would not be well served by a mailing list.
Accordingly, we should consider this group closed. The EUUG mandate
in Copenhagen was that a newsgroup should be created, so that is what I will do.European readers of this group should expect to see this one disappear in
a couple of days time (I will not issue the removegroup command - my interest
is not in how these things are done and I don't understand them well),
and I will find someone to set up a newsgroup called, tentatively
eunet.internat
unless somebody from an eunet backbone suggests a better name.
If somebody out there is better skilled at these negotiations than I,
and believes that there is a real need for a newsgroup like this, they
are welcome to take up the cudgels with net.news.group.
For the time being, us Europeans will talk to each other (as best we can:
it isn't easy talking Danish from a VT100 keyboard!). But I can't help
feeling that it's a shame that the US should be excluded.
My apologies to all concerned for the mess. My fault.
Bye bye, au revoir, arrividerci, auf wiedersehen, pa\o gjensyn, siyonara
etc......
Mike Banahan.
--
Mike Banahan, Technical Director, The Instruction Set Ltd.
mcvax!ukc!inset!mikeb
Re: Bureaucracy - delete this group!
Author: crs
Date: Fri, 18 Oct 1985 17:02
Date: Fri, 18 Oct 1985 17:02
11 lines
887 bytes
887 bytes
> For the time being, us Europeans will talk to each other (as best we can:
> it isn't easy talking Danish from a VT100 keyboard!). But I can't help
> feeling that it's a shame that the US should be excluded.
How true! Can nothing be done?
--
All opinions are mine alone...
Charlie Sorsby
...!{cmcl2,ihnp4,...}!lanl!crs
crs@lanl.arpa
Re: Bureaucracy - DON'T delete net.internat!
Author: John Gilmore
Date: Tue, 22 Oct 1985 19:52
Date: Tue, 22 Oct 1985 19:52
47 lines
3245 bytes
3245 bytes
In net.internat, mikeb@inset.UUCP (Mike Banahan) wrote (seriously edited by me): > I overstepped the rules and regulations involved in setting up newsgroups. > Gene Spafford ( ..seismo!gatech!spaf) has pointed out my misdoings > and requests that the newsgroup should be renamed or removed. > (he suggests one of:) > 1) Form a moderated group. > 2) restrict to eunet.internat (or a similar group). > 3) Do the work by mailing list. > Accordingly, we should consider this group closed. > and I will find someone to set up a eunet.internat > If somebody believes that there is a real need for a newsgroup like this, they > are welcome to take up the cudgels with net.news.group. > For the time being, us Europeans will talk to each other. I don't see a lot of point in excluding the world "net" distribution from one of the few Usenet topics that actually involves people around the globe. Since most Unix systems are designed and built outside Europe, restricting the newsgroup to Europe seems silly (not to mention insulting to Asians who have the same or worse problems.) Net.internat seems to have readers and writers and a topic that seriously needs research, investigation, discussion, and coordination. If somehow somebody forgot to tap-dance when the music came on, so what? In this self-organized anarchistic network have we gotten so bureaucratic that because a rule didn't get followed, we'd wipe out a productive technical newsgroup? (You can tell I've just finished reading Ursula LeGuin's "The Disposessed" again...) I know there are people at Sun following this newsgroup, working toward making better products for the world market. I'm sure this is true at most or all of the other Unix manufactories. And people, like me, rewriting public domain Unix certainly could do a better job this time if we could see what problems the current software faces in non-English markets. I don't quite remember when "the net" decided that new groups should all be mod groups or mailing lists or local groups. None of those has quite the same effect as a "real" newsgroup, and I think a real newsgroup is appropriate for this topic. If you agree, send mail to Gene Spafford (..!mcvax!seismo!gatech!spaf) and Mike Banahan (mcvax!ukc!inset!mikeb) and tell them what you think. Just send mail -- don't post "me too" articles to the net -- unless you have something more than that to say. PS: I'm looking for an "eunet" news feed from some local San Francisco site. Our feed (ptsfa) doesn't seem to carry those groups...
Re: Bureaucracy - delete this group!
Author: donn
Date: Wed, 23 Oct 1985 06:19
Date: Wed, 23 Oct 1985 06:19
10 lines
913 bytes
913 bytes
I don't know if this will make it in time, but I'm also sorry to
see it go, as HP does have some real interest in internationalization.
We were planning in participating in the future.
Donn Terry
HP Ft. Collins, Co.
{ihnp4|hplabs|hpbbn}!hpfcla!donn
^
|________ use from Europe.
Re: Bureaucracy - delete this group!
Author: Jim Henry
Date: Sat, 26 Oct 1985 03:19
Date: Sat, 26 Oct 1985 03:19
18 lines
1529 bytes
1529 bytes
I think it would be a real tragedy if this discussion was not kept up in the U.S. Americans have to be the most blind when it comes to recognizing inter-cultural differences and the problems they raise. There is probably no good solution to the problem under discussion but that does not make it esoteric or worthless. I am new to the net and so I am in no position to fully appreciate the "netiquette" of a newsgroups existence. Could someone summarize what is required if we want to keep this group up as an unmoderated group? I assume hijacking a computer and holding it hostage would be frowned upon even if this is a more international type of thing. If this group does become restricted to the European networks, is there a way I can continue to receive information? DISCLAIMER: Nothing, especially this, represents the opinions of my employer and I'd like to keep it that way.
Thread Navigation
This is a paginated view of messages in the thread with full content displayed inline.
Messages are displayed in chronological order, with the original post highlighted in green.
Use pagination controls to navigate through all messages in large threads.
Back to All Threads