🚀 go-pugleaf

RetroBBS NetNews Server

Inspired by RockSolid Light RIP Retro Guy

Thread View: net.mail.headers
1 messages
1 total messages Started by Jordan Hayes Wed, 18 Dec 1985 21:59
Re: Quiz - Parse this From line
#60
Author: Jordan Hayes
Date: Wed, 18 Dec 1985 21:59
37 lines
2056 bytes
	From: hpcnou!dat@hplabsd (Dave Taylor)

 >> From noscvax!@MIT-MC.ARPA:hpfcla!hpcnoe!veeger!hpcnou!dat@hplabsd

Simple.

If there's a leading '@', use source-routing. If not, look for
the right-most '@' ... so, send the return message to "hplabsd" ...

Ah, they say -- "but that's not the truth ..."

Humbug.

You can't parse it correctly unless you make some assumptions about
where that address showed up at. If it showed up at a dumb UUCP host
connected to noscvax, you may not have a problem returning it to
there and having noscvax send to mit-mc which would send to hplabsd
which would send to hpfcla!hpcnoe!veeger!hpcnou!dat ... *ugh* !!

However, if the site it came from recieved the message *via* uucp,
but is also an arpanet host (can you say "seismo" "ucbvax" "topaz"
"sdcsvax" "harvard" + a cast of thousands ...), you have a problem,
since it will try to do the "correct" thing I mentioned above about
sending it to hplabsd (BTW: how about your own return address, Dave?)

Such a silly question to ask ... the answer is clear: you can't parse
addresses with multiple (conflicting) syntaxes ... I thought we cleared
this question up a few years ago ... *sigh*

Now: how about the solution? As simple as the answer to Dave's
Question ... uucp needs to use 822 addresses if they expect to get
decent service when getting gatewayed into/out of the Arpanet.

They can do whatever they want between themselves, but when in Rome ...

/jordan
Thread Navigation

This is a paginated view of messages in the thread with full content displayed inline.

Messages are displayed in chronological order, with the original post highlighted in green.

Use pagination controls to navigate through all messages in large threads.

Back to All Threads