Comparing hard disks

Thread View: net.micro.atari16

2 messages

[T] Back to Threads [V] Tree View [G] Group Articles

2 total messages Started by Wayne Vucenic Sun, 09 Mar 1986 19:13

#128

Author: Wayne Vucenic
Date: Sun, 09 Mar 1986 19:13

33 lines
2304 bytes

I'm interested in the 20Meg Atari hard disk.  I had heard rumors to
the effect that the developers hard disks have a faster data transfer rate
than the soon-to-be-available commercial 20Meg Atari hard disks.  I asked
about this at my local dealer, but the fellow there told me that the
only differences were cosmetic: metal case vs. plastic case.  I'm not sure
he's got the straight story on data transfer rates, as he was quoting
10Mbits/sec to me.  I realize that the DMA controller can transfer at that
speed, but I had heard that the hard disk controllers were actually
running at 7.5Mbits or 5Mbits.
   I was wondering if anyone had the straight story on the differences
between the developers and commercial hard disks.  The two topics of
particular interest to me are:

	1) Performance: data transfer rates, access times, etc.
	2) Fan noise.  I seem to be overly sensitive to noise.  (I REALLY
		like the fact that my ST doesn't have a fan, but the hum
		(60 cycle, it sounds like) from my monochrome monitor
		begins to bug me at times.  My color monitor is silent.
		Anyone else have a noisy mono monitor, or is it just mine?)
		Anyway, back to hard disks... the developers hard disk I
		looked at had a fan that seemed to be about average for
		fan noise.)

Other differences of more minor interest would include requirements for
parking the heads.  I understand that the developer's hard disk requires
this, but I can't imagine that a commercial version would.

Can anyone at Atari or elsewhere shed some light on this?  Thanks.
		
=============================================================================
Wayne Vucenic
...{ucbvax, ihnp4, allegra, decvax}!hplabs!well!wvucenic
=============================================================================

Re: Comparing hard disks

#201

Author: nigel
Date: Fri, 14 Mar 1986 10:53

35 lines
2384 bytes

In article <743@well.UUCP> wvucenic@well.UUCP writes:
>I'm interested in the 20Meg Atari hard disk.  I had heard rumors to
>the effect that the developers hard disks have a faster data transfer rate
>than the soon-to-be-available commercial 20Meg Atari hard disks.  I asked
>about this at my local dealer, but the fellow there told me that the
>only differences were cosmetic: metal case vs. plastic case.  I'm not sure
>he's got the straight story on data transfer rates, as he was quoting
>10Mbits/sec to me.  I realize that the DMA controller can transfer at that
>speed, but I had heard that the hard disk controllers were actually
>running at 7.5Mbits or 5Mbits.
...
The developers drives have two boards in - a standard hard drive controller,
and a bus convertor board. I was told around Christmas time that before
selling commercially, Atari wanted to get this onto one board, and into a
plastic case, so your dealer is on the right lines. 5MBits is the quoted
rate for the drive, but some timings I made using an analyser (very rough)
suggested the acknowledges were closer to 7MBits. If Atari wish to use a
single board, then the new board may be faster. The developer setup looks like
a standard SASI board, with a SASI to Atari convertor (one PAL, about 6 TTL).

>		Anyway, back to hard disks... the developers hard disk I
>		looked at had a fan that seemed to be about average for
>		fan noise.)

Yes - average, fine by me.

>
>Other differences of more minor interest would include requirements for
>parking the heads.  I understand that the developer's hard disk requires
>this, but I can't imagine that a commercial version would.

There is a utility to move the heads to a safe landing point (!) for
transport. The importance is not heavily stressed, just suggested.

Nigel Roles

Thread Navigation

This is a paginated view of messages in the thread with full content displayed inline.

Messages are displayed in chronological order, with the original post highlighted in green.

Use pagination controls to navigate through all messages in large threads.

Back to All Threads