Thread View: news.admin.technical
1 messages
1 total messages
Started by Jerry Aguirre
Thu, 10 Sep 1992 17:34
Re: NFS vs NNTP for news reading
Author: Jerry Aguirre
Date: Thu, 10 Sep 1992 17:34
Date: Thu, 10 Sep 1992 17:34
31 lines
2350 bytes
2350 bytes
In article <BuBsJp.IHn@ux1.isu.edu> ntmtv!harthc@ames.arc.nasa.gov (Howard Hart) writes:
>Don't forget that wonderful feature of NFS when partitions are mounted
>read/write (such as the case where you have to mount the news batch
>directory read/write for users to post articles). Don't know about
>other machines, but on Sun's, if you loose the server, the client
>hangs indefinitely (I was told at one time that NFS writes have
I suggest that you investigate the NFS mount options of "hard", "soft",
and interuptable ("intr"). It is true that a hard NFS mount will hang
the processes attempting to access a down server but by mounting them
soft they will eventually time out. Mounting via "intr" is probably
more appropriate as it allows the user to decide whether to wait for
the server to come back or interupt and try again later.
Man puts gasoline in tank and then uses match to check level causing
explosion. Advises people to avoid gasoline powered cars.
Most people who use NFS for reading news export it read-only and still
use NNTP for posting. It is only recent versions of C news that have
the potential for putting postings in a directory to be processed later.
(And that was not for NFS but to simplify some portability/permissions
issues.)
Speaking of security, a while back the issue of NFS vs. NNTP came up and
one site described their setup using NFS and how they could never
support the same load using NNTP. I followed their directions and, sure
enough, was able to NFS mount their news partition, via the internet!
I wonder how many sites out there have news and other partitions
mountable from outside their institution. I suggest sites configure
their routers to block RPC on external lines. (And rlogin, rsh, etc.)
Thread Navigation
This is a paginated view of messages in the thread with full content displayed inline.
Messages are displayed in chronological order, with the original post highlighted in green.
Use pagination controls to navigate through all messages in large threads.
Back to All Threads