Article View: qc.general
Article #112Re: The Quebec Letter: Galganov
From: Fawzi
Date: Sat, 19 Oct 1996 00:00
Date: Sat, 19 Oct 1996 00:00
55 lines
4079 bytes
4079 bytes
In article (Dans l�article) <548npe$rv6@Vir.com>, atp@vir.com (Michael Mell ) wrote (�crivait)�: > fawzi@vir.com (Fawzi) wrote: > > >> > >> 1. You call yourself a 'nation' but refuse to recognize any other > >> group with the exception of the Indians and possible the Acadians even > >> if this group has had ancestors here in the New World for as long as > >> you. > > >Je n'ai jamais dit �a. > > perhaps I didn't list enough groups......... the following clip was > taken from an earlier response by you. > > > So, the theory must be: If within a specific political unit there is a > > majority of the population which has been defined to constitute a > > nation then they must have the right to vote to secede from any > > political unit to which this political unit belongs. > > Exactement, �a s'appelle le droit des nations � l'autod�termination. > > > > Woo! We can see suburbs of Vancouver and Toronto going to the > > Chinese. We can see the Ukraine decendants taking over large > > territories in the midwest. The Acadians can have their chunk of New > > Brunswick > > Ces groupes ne constituent pas des nations, � part peut-�tre les > Acadiens. Mais �a il faudrait leur demander.. Since your understanding of french seems to be limited eventhough you live in Montreal, I'll answer in english... By answering that I think, -that the exemples that you give don't form nations-, you're saying that I've said, -that no other group forms a nation-. That is not true, I never said that. And I said that one should ask about the Acadiens because I'm in no position to answer about them, because I simply don't know enough about them. And that is all that I've said, I'm not questioning their ancestry. And I've never mentioned ancestry anywhere... And that's all you've answered to my post, just extracting what you want to believe to persue in your fabulation. Well, go ahead my friend, you can go on and live your little life with your fabulations and close your eyes in front of this culture that surrounds you. It's your loss, not mine. Fawzi
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<fawzi-1910962349060001@news1.vir.com>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!unknown!not-for-mailReferences:
<512hcm$8om@myth.vianet.on.ca> <32374FE1.734E@mlink.net><322C2046.6072@odyssee.net> <50i67g$qkr@nntp.igs.net> <50n2t8$pdr@wpg-01.escape.ca> <51 <3240c676.2049963@news.mbnet.mb.ca> <51s4h0$noq@hendrix.postino.com> <fawzi-2009961316340001@news1.vir.com> <pbennett-2409961221480001@47.208.9.182> <fawzi-2409962219260001@news1.vir.com> <pbennett-2609961319580001@47.208.9.182> <fawzi-2909960 <DytFK6.1v8@blaze.trentu.ca> <fawzi-0610961211430001@news1.vir.com> <325846ac.3796698@news.mbnet.mb.ca> <Pine.SOL.3.91.961006174854.5344E-100000@general3.asu.edu> <fawzi-0810961003290001@news1.vir.com> <325BAAED.550@bnr.ca> <fawzi-1110961212300001@news1.vir.com> <53unqp$4kv@Vir.com> <fawzi-1510961127440001@news1.vir.com> <54156i$6p@Vir.com> <542mk8$afi@Vir.com> <fawzi-1710961405360001@news1.vir.com> <548npe$rv6@Vir.com>Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII X-Google-Thread: f504b,e5bd2480bb1f8b X-Google-Attributes: gidf504b,public X-Google-Thread: 100c8e,bb5e338e8a6a4c70 X-Google-Attributes: gid100c8e,public X-Google-Thread: ff20b,e5bd2480bb1f8b X-Google-Attributes: gidff20b,public X-Google-Thread: fb374,e5bd2480bb1f8b X-Google-Attributes: gidfb374,public X-Google-Thread: 10643c,2c314f884e9baac7 X-Google-Attributes: gid10643c,public X-Google-Thread: fe894,e5bd2480bb1f8b X-Google-Attributes: gidfe894,public X-Google-Thread: 114af9,e5bd2480bb1f8b X-Google-Attributes: gid114af9,public X-Google-Thread: 1031e2,e2ccf550990c77fd X-Google-Attributes: gid1031e2,public From: fawzi@vir.com (Fawzi) Subject: Re: The Quebec Letter: Galganov Date: 1996/10/19 Message-ID: <fawzi-1910962349060001@news1.vir.com> X-Deja-AN: 190725989 references: <512hcm$8om@myth.vianet.on.ca> <32374FE1.734E@mlink.net><322C2046.6072@odyssee.net> <50i67g$qkr@nntp.igs.net> <50n2t8$pdr@wpg-01.escape.ca> <51 <3240c676.2049963@news.mbnet.mb.ca> <51s4h0$noq@hendrix.postino.com> <fawzi-2009961316340001@news1.vir.com> <pbennett-2409961221480001@47.208.9.182> <fawzi-2409962219260001@news1.vir.com> <pbennett-2609961319580001@47.208.9.182> <fawzi-2909960 <DytFK6.1v8@blaze.trentu.ca> <fawzi-0610961211430001@news1.vir.com> <325846ac.3796698@news.mbnet.mb.ca> <Pine.SOL.3.91.961006174854.5344E-100000@general3.asu.edu> <fawzi-0810961003290001@news1.vir.com> <325BAAED.550@bnr.ca> <fawzi-1110961212300001@news1.vir.com> <53unqp$4kv@Vir.com> <fawzi-1510961127440001@news1.vir.com> <54156i$6p@Vir.com> <542mk8$afi@Vir.com> <fawzi-1710961405360001@news1.vir.com> <548npe$rv6@Vir.com> content-type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1 organization: Non mime-version: 1.0 newsgroups: qc.general,mtl.general,can.general,can.english,can.francais,can.politics,niagara.general,tor.general,wpg.general,can.atlantic.general,ott.general,bc.general,soc.culture.quebec