🚀 go-pugleaf

RetroBBS NetNews Server

Inspired by RockSolid Light RIP Retro Guy

Article View: qc.general
Article #240

Re: The Quebec Letter: Galganov

#240
From: HAL9000
Date: Wed, 18 Sep 1996 00:00
59 lines
4055 bytes
In article <323976c1.870173@news.mbnet.mb.ca>,
software_answers@cyberspc.mb.ca (S.Pickell) wrote:

> I, as well most of Canadians I would think don't really have a problem
> with Quebec being distinct in it's culture.
> But what exactually distinct means is yet another matter to discuss.

So you are agreeing on an idea, but you can't decide what it means? Promising.

> And your interpretaion of Quebec's vision would seem to be to wrench
> Canada into pieces.
> Is that what Quebec Sovereignists want?
> I do not, nor cannot beleive it is the same as the rest of the people
> in Quebec.

Is Canada that weak? If it is, then perhaps all Canadians should
reconsider Confederation. It certainly seems that they deserve better.

> But who would it be benifical for, big business, the people of Quebec?
> It would certainly mean political and economical suicide for both
> parties. 

It seems that back during the referendum, big business was solidly backing
the federalist side... 'guess that means that an independent Quebec would
not be beneficial to the state and, by the phrasing of your question,
would be beneficial to the people of Quebec.

> It does not matter what ethnic background you have, I thought we were
> all Canadians first and foremost , just with different cultural
> backgrounds.  

That is the vision we do not share! has this eluded you during this whole
debate? Sovereignist see themselves as Quebecois first, Canadian second. 

> > I know that separation does not mean an ideal society.
> How can you say that? It will be an ugly mess...lets be honest.  

Expound please. Many of us who are in Montreal think it can't really get
any worse. Mayors from the rest of Canada are openly coming here on
missions to take our jobs away from us. That's Canadian unity for you. At
the same time it's obvious that the feds don't want to do anything about
complaints from anglophones. Is that the Canada you wish so dearly to
preserve? 

Zellers is the truly canadian store -- back when they started using this
logo they decided to pack up from Montreal and move to TO. That slogan has
biting irony in it, don't you think?

> >But there can be separation without hate!
> Your living in a dreamworld.

Well, the good feeling can't always be mutual. 

> And you Sir know exactually what the rest of Canada wants correct?

You're providing us with the answer to that.

TAE
Technical Details
Message-ID: <taemond-1809962328250001@nntp.generation.net>
Path: arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!unknown!not-for-mail
References: <322C2046.6072@odyssee.net> <50i67g$qkr@nntp.igs.net> <50n2t8$pdr@wpg-01.escape.ca> <511beg$8cg@ns.RezoNet.NET> <512hcm$8om@myth.vianet.on.ca> <32374FE1.734E@mlink.net><322C2046.6072@odyssee.net> <50i67g$qkr@nntp.igs.net> <50n2t8$pdr@wpg-01.escape.ca> <511beg$8cg@ns.RezoNet.NET> <512hcm$8om@myth.vianet.on.ca> <32374FE1.734E@mlink.net> <517qsn$j8p@wpg-01.escape.ca> <51a5df$2fh@chinook.Generation.NET> <323902BC.B76@mlink.net> <323976c1.870173@news.mbnet.mb.ca>

Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit
X-Google-Thread: f504b,e5bd2480bb1f8b
X-Google-Attributes: gidf504b,public
X-Google-Thread: fb374,e5bd2480bb1f8b
X-Google-Attributes: gidfb374,public
X-Google-Thread: ff20b,e5bd2480bb1f8b
X-Google-Attributes: gidff20b,public
X-Google-Thread: fe894,e5bd2480bb1f8b
X-Google-Attributes: gidfe894,public
X-Google-Thread: 100c8e,bb5e338e8a6a4c70
X-Google-Attributes: gid100c8e,public
X-Google-Thread: 114af9,e5bd2480bb1f8b
X-Google-Attributes: gid114af9,public
X-Google-Thread: 1031e2,e2ccf550990c77fd
X-Google-Attributes: gid1031e2,public
X-Google-Thread: 10643c,2c314f884e9baac7
X-Google-Attributes: gid10643c,public
From: taemond@generation.net (HAL9000)
Subject: Re: The Quebec Letter: Galganov
Date: 1996/09/18
Message-ID: <taemond-1809962328250001@nntp.generation.net>
X-Deja-AN: 181512994
references: <322C2046.6072@odyssee.net> <50i67g$qkr@nntp.igs.net> <50n2t8$pdr@wpg-01.escape.ca> <511beg$8cg@ns.RezoNet.NET> <512hcm$8om@myth.vianet.on.ca> <32374FE1.734E@mlink.net><322C2046.6072@odyssee.net> <50i67g$qkr@nntp.igs.net> <50n2t8$pdr@wpg-01.escape.ca> <511beg$8cg@ns.RezoNet.NET> <512hcm$8om@myth.vianet.on.ca> <32374FE1.734E@mlink.net> <517qsn$j8p@wpg-01.escape.ca> <51a5df$2fh@chinook.Generation.NET> <323902BC.B76@mlink.net> <323976c1.870173@news.mbnet.mb.ca>
content-type: text/plain; charset=Macintosh
organization: Generation.NET
mime-version: 1.0
newsgroups: qc.general,mtl.general,can.general,can.english,can.francais,can.politics,niagara.general,tor.general,wpg.general,can.atlantic.general,ott.general,bc.general,soc.culture.quebec