Article View: rec.running
Article #1305Re: mysterious runners death in Sweden
From: Luis P Caamano
Date: Mon, 16 Nov 1992 15:37
Date: Mon, 16 Nov 1992 15:37
157 lines
8217 bytes
8217 bytes
In article <1992Nov16.101150.3779@kth.se> TordM@VanA.PhySto.SE writes:
>
> I seem to recall they all had an infection in their heart, cos of some
>reason when they were training with a cold the infection "travelled" to
>the heart... The bacteria TWAR seem to be some track they think is
>doing the hard work by contaminating others
>
>
This is a message I got from the O-List:
From: Tapio Leino <uunet!marten!vtt.fi!Tapio.Leino>
Message-Id: <9211160800.AA07937@rat.vtt.fi>
To: Orienteering@Graphics.Cornell.EDU
Subject: About the TWAR in us.
Cc: Tapio.Leino@vtt.fi
Status: RO
Because they had found out in Sweden that most of the seven died orienteers
were either born at the central Sweden (Bergslagen) or had lived there
they tested orienteers and some common people who were donoring their blood
to find out about the number of people with the counter agent of TWAR.
153 male and 94 female orienteers were tested. And 224 blood donators were
tested. The results showed that among the orienteers 63% had the counter
agent of TWAR which means that they sometimes have had the TWAR. Among the
other group a total of 69% (the blood donators) had the counter agent in
their blood. It looks like the TWAR is more common amongst the other people
than the orienteers.
Tapio Leino
Technical Research Centre of Finland / Laboratory of Structural Engineering
mail: VTT/Rakennetekniikan laboratorio, P.O. Box 26, SF-02151 ESPOO, Finland
tel: -358-0-456 6683, telefax: -358-0-456 7003 e-mail: Tapio.Leino@vtt.fi
I guess that removes TWAR from the possibilities. In this other
message they show that it happens not only to orienteers:
From: James E Baker <uunet!marten!CompuServe.COM!76070.630>
To: o <orienteering@graphics.cornell.edu>
Subject: Lex on death/a physician's comments
Message-Id: <921115210725_76070.630_CHL35-2@CompuServe.COM>
Status: RO
Lex Bundschuh (a U.S. doctor and orienteer) wrote up some nice notes
about the Swedish deaths. Although much is similar to what has been
said, I thought they were worth posting, as Lex has put some research
into this (and is a doctor), and they are less alarmist than I'm
afraid that IOF letter seemed (I was reading much of it as I typed, as
I wanted to get some solid, official info out quickly. On reflection,
it was less calm and measured than I'd expected based on the earlier
Swedish Federation fax, which my flaky software accidentally deleted
in front of my and JJ's eyes. I summarized it earlier). Lex hopes to
get more information later when tests are complete.
OBSERVATIONS ON DEATHS AMONGST SWEDISH ORIENTEERS
Last week in USA Today [ed - a nationwide US newspaper, general interest
but a bit lighter and fluffier than the New York Times] there was an
article claiming that a mysterious illness had killed 7 elite Swedish
orienteers [ed - apparently more prominent than the article on the North
American Championships]. As a physician and orienteer, I would like to
clarify this. According to the Swedish Orienteering Federation, 7 elite
orienteers have died shortly after training over the past 3 years. All
7 had "flu-like" illnesses and continued to train. There is nothing
unique to orinteering that puts one at risk for sudden death. Viral
("flu-like") illnesses are usually quite benign and there are no
serious consequences. However, on rare occasions, the heart can become
involved; so the heart muscle is weakened. When this happens, any
increased demand on the heart can lead to sudden cardiac death. An
initial theory that a single infectious agent caused these deaths has not
been proven. A group of medical experts in Sweden is investigating
elite orienters to determine if there is any infectious source present.
Although the figure of 7 deaths among elite orienteers seems alarming,
similar things have occurred in other sports. During the 1986-88
seasons, 4 young male Georgia basketball players collapsed from
sudden cardiac death.
The bottom line for the average orienteer is: 1) orienteers are not
uniquely susceptable to exercise related heart problems, 2) if you
have a "flu-like illness" with aches and fevers, don't train hard.
Lex Bundschuh
[ed- our national sponsor's marketers came upon the article while
looking for coverage of the recent North American Champs, which they
sponsored. They were quite distressed.]
And this other message suggest that this is not the first time it
happens and that all the media coverage comes from the fact that
the whole swedish orienteering team has been banned from
training until further notice.
Date: Mon, 16 Nov 1992 09:54:00 -0230
From: uunet!marten!kean.ucs.mun.ca!mulligan
Reply-To: uunet!marten!kean.ucs.mun.ca!mulligan
To: orienteering@graphics.cornell.edu
Cc: mulligan@kean.ucs.mun.ca
Message-Id: <00963B1D.807C0460.17166@Leif.ucs.mun.ca>
Subject: orienteering deaths
Status: RO
The recent postings on the subject of TWAR and the deaths of several
orienteers after training while recovering from flu like symptoms
sounded familiar to me. Sure enough, in checking back over some old
issues of "The Orienteer", the magazine of the British Orienteering
Federation I found the following in the April 1976 issue:
"It was with profound shock amounting almost to disbelief that
we learned of the untimely death of Mike Wells-Cole on
March 7.
Mike had been ill with food poisoning and then a dose of 'flu
but he seemed to be fully recovered and back in the swing of
his normal busy life. On Saturday March 6, he worked till
10pm at Willesden Sports Centre to help a colleague who wanted
the night off. Then on Sunday March 7, after a training run,
he suddenly succumbed to a rare virus infection of the lung."
The article goes on to describe Mike's achievements in orienteering.
He was one of, if not, the best British orienteer at the time, with
the best British placing in a World Championships up till then (18th
in 1970).
The August issue has a brief comment on ths risks of training after
'flu and promises a follow-up in a the October issue. Its not in that
issue and I do not have the December or any later issues to follow up
on the cause of his death. These two articles do suggest that he may
have had a viral infection rather than the bacterial infection that is
being associated with the current deaths. However, it might be
interesting to know if the exact cause of his infection was
established at that time. It does seem, however, that we are in many
ways reliving an old experience.
The August issue also contains an item that might be of interest. As
a memorial to Mike Wells-Cole, a trophy was to be awarded biennially
to the Briton achieving the best performance in teh World
Championships. Can any of the British readers of this list verify
that this is still so?
Martin Mulligan Dept. of Biochemistry
mulligan@kean.ucs.mun.ca Memorial University of Newfoundland
My conclusion is BE CAREFUL WHEN YOU'RE SICK.
--
Luis P. Caamano | lpc@dickens.com
Dickens Data Systems, Inc. Atlanta, GA | uunet!dickens.com!lpc
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
If I think I know it all, I'll stop learning. -myself
The more I learn, the more I know I know nothing. -somebody else
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<1992Nov16.153725.17596@dickens.com>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!sparky!uunet!ddssuprs!lpcReferences:
<perel.1.721904917@dhhalden.no> <1992Nov16.101150.3779@kth.se>Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
Newsgroups: rec.running Path: arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!sparky!uunet!ddssuprs!lpc From: lpc@dickens.com (Luis P Caamano) Subject: Re: mysterious runners death in Sweden Message-ID: <1992Nov16.153725.17596@dickens.com> Date: Mon, 16 Nov 1992 15:37:25 GMT References: <perel.1.721904917@dhhalden.no> <1992Nov16.101150.3779@kth.se> Organization: Dickens Data Systems, Inc. Lines: 157