Thread View: sci.aeronautics
2 messages
2 total messages
Started by joseph.f.baugher
Sun, 20 Dec 1992 02:34
Re: Speed of sound (was MACH 1)
Author: joseph.f.baugher
Date: Sun, 20 Dec 1992 02:34
Date: Sun, 20 Dec 1992 02:34
75 lines
3326 bytes
3326 bytes
Most of the formulae I have seen posted here for the speed of sound in air are wrong. In fact, some of them are not even dimensionally correct. Here's what Resnick and Halliday (a well-known freshman physics text) have to say. The formula for the speed of sound in an elastic medium (either liquid or gas) is c = sqrt (B/rho) where B is the bulk modulus of the material (the ratio of the change in pressure to the resulting fractional change in volume) with units of newtons/m^2 or, equivalently, kg/(m.sec^2), and rho is the density with units of kg/m^3. If the material is a solid, the formula is quite similar, but the bulk modulus is replaced by Young's modulus Y. Therefore, the more dense the material, the slower the speed of sound. Also, the higher the bulk modulus the more difficult it is to compress the material and the higher the speed of sound. So the people who have said that the speed of sound depends on the density of the air are correct, but that is not all there is to it. The bulk modulus of air also varies and must also be considered. For an ideal gas, the formula for the speed of sound is given by c = sqrt(gamma*P/rho) where it is assumed that the passage of a sound wave through a gas is an adiabatic process. Here, gamma is the ratio of specific heats (Cp/Cv), P is the pressure, and rho is the density. Except of course for the factor gamma, this formula could have been derived by using a simple dimensional analysis. Let us now look at the well-known ideal gas formula: PV = nRT where n is the number of moles enclosed in a volume V, T is the absolute temperature in Kelvin (K), and R is the universal gas constant, units of joules/(mole*K). Solving for P gives P = (n/V)RT The factor n/V is the number of moles per cubic meter. Substituting this into the formula for the speed of sound in a gas, we get c = sqrt( gamma*(n/(V*rho))RT ) The factor n/(V*rho) is simply the inverse of the molecular weight of the gas (MW), so the formula for the speed of sound in a gas is c = sqrt( gamma*R*T/(MW) ) The ratio of specific heats is for all practical purposes a constant. R is a universal constant of nature, so the speed of sound depends only on the absolute temperature and on the molecular weight of the gas. Since the temperature of the air decreases with altitude in the troposphere, the speed of sound decreases with altitude. Hope this helps. Joe Baugher ************************************** AT&T Bell Laboratories * "You see, something's going to * 2000 North Naperville Road * happen. Something wonderful!" * P. O. Box 3033 ************************************** Naperville, Illinois 60566-7033 (708) 713 4548 ihlpl!jfb Who, me? Speak for AT&T? Surely you jest! jfb200@cbnewsd.att.com
Re: Speed of sound (was MACH 1)
Author: Brad Whitehurst
Date: Mon, 21 Dec 1992 14:53
Date: Mon, 21 Dec 1992 14:53
51 lines
2292 bytes
2292 bytes
In article <1992Dec20.023400.6822@cbnewsd.cb.att.com> jfb200@cbnewsd.cb.att.com (joseph.f.baugher) writes: >Most of the formulae I have seen posted here for the speed of sound in >air are wrong. In fact, some of them are not even dimensionally >correct. > >Here's what Resnick and Halliday (a well-known freshman physics text) >have to say. > >The formula for the speed of sound in an elastic medium (either liquid >or gas) is > > c = sqrt (B/rho) > [some deletions...] >Let us now look at the well-known ideal gas formula: > > PV = nRT > ... >The factor n/(V*rho) is simply the inverse of the molecular weight of >the gas (MW), so the formula for the speed of sound in a gas is > > c = sqrt( gamma*R*T/(MW) ) > >The ratio of specific heats is for all practical purposes a constant. >R is a universal constant of nature, so the speed of sound depends >only on the absolute temperature and on the molecular weight of the >gas. Yup, but the previous posters were using the convention (though they may not have said it) of using a gas-specific gas constant rather than the universal gas constant, like so: R=Ru/MW. That is the the source of your confusion, not a real error in their formula. Most gas dynamics books have got the specific R's tabulated, so we just use them, rather than Ru/MW, since you have to look up MW anyway. >Since the temperature of the air decreases with altitude in the >troposphere, the speed of sound decreases with altitude. > >Hope this helps. > >Joe Baugher ************************************** >AT&T Bell Laboratories * "You see, something's going to * -- Brad Whitehurst | Aerospace Research Lab rbw3q@Virginia.EDU | We like it hot...and fast.
Thread Navigation
This is a paginated view of messages in the thread with full content displayed inline.
Messages are displayed in chronological order, with the original post highlighted in green.
Use pagination controls to navigate through all messages in large threads.
Back to All Threads