🚀 go-pugleaf

RetroBBS NetNews Server

Inspired by RockSolid Light RIP Retro Guy

5 total messages Started by Christopher_C_Lapp Sat, 08 Aug 1992 17:51
NSA and the ATA
#452
Author: Christopher_C_Lapp
Date: Sat, 08 Aug 1992 17:51
10 lines
792 bytes
I noticed a full page advertisement recruiting for the National
security agency in the American Translators Association bulletin.
Why would the NSA want language types?  I thought they did alot
number-crunching and your average translator has had little or
no math background.  Also, don't they have a whole much of
Defense Language School types who have been drilled in every 
language imaginable?  Is the NSA just fishing?  Are they desparate
for talent or what?
Any comments?
Chris Lapp
Re: NSA and the ATA
#456
Author: Paul Rubin
Date: Sat, 08 Aug 1992 16:51
21 lines
1614 bytes
    (Of course, the *ideal* person might have a lot of linguistics *and*
    a lot of group theory and other relevant math *and* a hefty dose of
    high-performance computer expertise.  Such people are probably rather
    hard to find, though...)

*And* be willing to work for a secret spook agency.  Those are
even harder to find...

Here's a semi-counterexample though: I used to know a hippie type
who was a grad student in Turkish Literature, but who came from the US.
He did various odd jobs to get by until one day the DoD asked
if he would like them to pay all his school expenses---with almost no
obligations.  Seems they decided Turkish was a "strategic" language
and they were willing to spring some $$$ just to make sure that
at least a few US nationals understood it.  After he accepted,
he basically never heard from them except they paid his bills
and every now and then would send him documents in Turkish and
ask for translations.  He said the documents were always innocuous
news reports etc. and he suspected that their only purpose was
to make sure he was still around and studying.
Re: NSA and the ATA
#454
Author: Jonathan Thornburg
Date: Sat, 08 Aug 1992 23:21
40 lines
2476 bytes
In article <63663@cup.portal.com> Christopher_C_Lapp@cup.portal.com writes:
>I noticed a full page advertisement recruiting for the National
>security agency in the American Translators Association bulletin.
>Why would the NSA want language types?  I thought they did alot
>number-crunching and your average translator has had little or
>no math background.  Also, don't they have a whole much of
>Defense Language School types who have been drilled in every 
>language imaginable?

I suspect that messages sent between (say) the Saudi Arabian Oil
Ministry and it's London office, might well be in languages other
than US Standard English...

More seriously, James Bamford "The Puzzle Palace" (Houghton Mifflin,
1982 / Penguin, 1983; ISBN 0-14-006748-5) quotes "A former [UK GCHQ]
A Group voice-processing specialist" as saying

	"You operate primarily on key words, because
	 there is no way that in a year [of Russian
	 language school] you are going to comprehend
	 the language well enough to understand what's
	 going on.  They've had second-generation
	 people who have had a hard time because some
	 people slur, and there is geographical variance,
	 so they expect a non-native to just operate
	 on the key words -- when you hear the word
	 missle, for example."

In other words, governmental crypto agancies need a lot of linguists,
and at least some of these have to be pretty good.  Thus the ATA ad.

(Of course, the *ideal* person might have a lot of linguistics *and*
a lot of group theory and other relevant math *and* a hefty dose of
high-performance computer expertise.  Such people are probably rather
hard to find, though...)

- Jonathan Thornburg
  <jonathan@einstein.ph.utexas.edu> or <jonathan@hermes.chpc.utexas.edu>
  University of Texas at Austin / Physics Dept / Center for Relativity
  and (for a few more months) U of British Columbia / {Astronomy,Physics}
Re: NSA and the ATA
#458
Author: Mr. Lyn R. Kennedy
Date: Sun, 09 Aug 1992 20:58
25 lines
1576 bytes
Christopher_C_Lapp@cup.portal.com writes:

> I noticed a full page advertisement recruiting for the National
> security agency in the American Translators Association bulletin.
> Why would the NSA want language types?  I thought they did alot
> number-crunching and your average translator has had little or
> no math background.  Also, don't they have a whole much of
> Defense Language School types who have been drilled in every 
> language imaginable?  Is the NSA just fishing?  Are they desparate
> for talent or what?

My guess is that since they relied on the military for many of those 
functions, they may need to build up their own staff due to cutbacks in 
the military. Much of the NSA's monitoring is supposed to be open 
sources that need to be translated before being passed on to the 
analysts.


-------------------------------------------------------------------------
                 
73,            internet     | lrk@k5qwb.lonestar.org
Lyn Kennedy    packet radio | K5QWB @ N5LDD.#NTX.TX.US.NA
               pony express | P.O. Box 5133, Ovilla, TX, USA 75154

-------------- "We have met the enemy and he is us."  Pogo --------------
Re: NSA and the ATA
#480
Author: Joseph F. Hull
Date: Tue, 11 Aug 1992 16:56
12 lines
1204 bytes
The translation sections are (almost) completely separate from the technical sections.  The
requirement for linguists who are also math (or computer science or ...) trained is to
translate technical documents from the source language into English (a noticeably different
skill than translating ordinary conversations).  In general, Americans are so "America-
centered" it is quite difficult for intelligence / military / commercial interests to find
enough adequately skilled people to satisfy the demand (for translators).

-- 
	   _   _
    /_    / ) / ) Jeff Hull          hull@den.mmc.com
   //_) -/- -/-   1544 S. Vaughn Cir
/_/ \_/ /   /	  Aurora, CO 80012   303-977-1061
Thread Navigation

This is a paginated view of messages in the thread with full content displayed inline.

Messages are displayed in chronological order, with the original post highlighted in green.

Use pagination controls to navigate through all messages in large threads.

Back to All Threads