Article View: sci.physics
Article #1381Aristotle and the Modern Physicist
From: Mcinnes B T (Dr)
Date: Thu, 23 Jul 1992 05:52
Date: Thu, 23 Jul 1992 05:52
35 lines
2439 bytes
2439 bytes
[The scene: Aristotle is accidentally translated in time to the late 20th century, while working on the Physics. He asks a Modern Physicist to help him to catch up with things.] MP: I hear that you believe that a free particle will eventually come to rest, even if subject to no force. A: Well, I'm open to correction. MP: Take a look in the library. [Later]: A: I have updated my views with the aid of this text on quantum field theory. It seems that,eg, spacecraft are able to continue moving without the use of their propulsion systems. I reconcile my views with this as follows: clearly there is some interaction here [let us call it "inertia"] mediated by some hitherto undetected particle which I hereby dub the "inerton", with a spin that may readily be calculated.... MP: No! No! You have it all wrong! A free particle moves in a straight line at constant speed. It does this not because of some "interaction", but rather because it is subject to NO interactions! Back to the library! [Later] A: I have been reading newton. What a beautiful conception, this First Law! But what really convinces me is the magnificent use to which this fellow Einstein has put it. MP: How do you mean? A: Well, Einstein has explained gravity by transferring it from the domain of the Second Law to that of the First. A free particle moves along a "straight line", where this expression is taken to mean a geodesic in the appropriate spacetime. Thus we can say, eg, that the Earth moves around the Sun, not, as Newton mistakenly thought, because the Sun and the Earth interact, but rather because they DO NOT interact! If they interacted, the motion would not be geodesic. Magnificent! MP: No! No! You have it all wrong! The Earth moves around the Sun because there is some interaction [let us call it "gravity"] mediated by some hitherto undetected particle which I hereby dub the "graviton", with a spin that may readily be calculated........ Moral: It takes more than an Einstein to abolish the fantasy of the "gravitational interaction".
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<1992Jul23.055247.12293@nuscc.nus.sg>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!sparky!uunet!zaphod.mps.ohio-state.edu!sdd.hp.com!nigel.msen.com!yale.edu!jvnc.net!nuscc!matmcinnShow Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
Newsgroups: sci.physics Path: arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!sparky!uunet!zaphod.mps.ohio-state.edu!sdd.hp.com!nigel.msen.com!yale.edu!jvnc.net!nuscc!matmcinn From: matmcinn@nuscc.nus.sg (Mcinnes B T (Dr)) Subject: Aristotle and the Modern Physicist Message-ID: <1992Jul23.055247.12293@nuscc.nus.sg> Organization: National University of Singapore Date: Thu, 23 Jul 1992 05:52:47 GMT Lines: 35