Article View: sci.space
Article #7281Man rating again (was: Stupid Shut Cost arguements)
From: Allen W. Sherzer
Date: Thu, 07 Jan 1993 02:57
Date: Thu, 07 Jan 1993 02:57
29 lines
1896 bytes
1896 bytes
In article <1993Jan06.165148.9581@eng.umd.edu> sysmgr@king.eng.umd.edu writes: >YOU say there's no need to man-rate. The astronaut community and anyone who >goes up on it IS going to disagree with you. Well after a successful test flight I would go up on it. I think lots of others would as well. Anybody with brains enough to read a test report and analyze risk wouldn't have any problem. I think most astronauts would be included in this list. The ones who don't want to go can quit. >I realize you'd like to treat people as another type of expendable, but it just >ain't so in the Western World. Wake up guy! The value of a human life simply isn't infinite. Look at the cost model for any large project. Part of it will include the costs associated with the people killed on the project. In fact, I'll bet that at least one person was killed building each of the 5 shuttle orbiters. People aren't expendable but nither do they have infinite value. If what you said where actually true then nobody woluld be flying Shuttles anyway. So if you want perfect safety, then stay home and leave the next frontier to the rest of us. Allen -- +---------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Allen W. Sherzer | "A great man is one who does nothing but leaves | | aws@iti.org | nothing undone" | +----------------------108 DAYS TO FIRST FLIGHT OF DCX----------------------+
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<1993Jan7.025746.2456@iti.org>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!sparky!uunet!hela.iti.org!awsReferences:
<72958@cup.portal.com> <1993Jan6.025846.15440@iti.org> <1993Jan06.165148.9581@eng.umd.edu>Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
Newsgroups: sci.space Path: arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!sparky!uunet!hela.iti.org!aws From: aws@iti.org (Allen W. Sherzer) Subject: Man rating again (was: Stupid Shut Cost arguements) Message-ID: <1993Jan7.025746.2456@iti.org> Organization: Evil Geniuses for a Better Tomorrow References: <72958@cup.portal.com> <1993Jan6.025846.15440@iti.org> <1993Jan06.165148.9581@eng.umd.edu> Date: Thu, 7 Jan 1993 02:57:46 GMT Lines: 29