Article View: tn.general
Article #259Re: This man drives while using pot .. legally!
From: Richard Garrity
Date: Tue, 30 Nov 2004 02:13
Date: Tue, 30 Nov 2004 02:13
160 lines
9224 bytes
9224 bytes
Anonymouse wrote: > > FOR A VERY FEW PATIENTS, U.S. PROVIDES FREE MARIJUANA > > WASHINGTON - Every weekday morning around 11 o'clock, a middle-aged > stockbroker named Irvin Rosenfeld gets up from his desk and walks to a > breezeway outside his office in Boca Raton, Fla. There, alongside the > potted palms and smokers taking their breaks, he lights up a cigarette > of his own -- not tobacco, but marijuana, sent to him by the Federal > Government. > > The arrangement is 16 years old and perfectly legal. Rosenfeld, who > suffers from a rare bone disorder and smokes to relieve his pain, is > part of an exclusive club of Americans who receive a free can of > marijuana cigarettes each month under a "compassionate use" program > sanctioned by the Food and Drug Administration and the National > Institute on Drug Abuse. > > There are only eight participants in the program. "I'm one of the > fortunate people," Rosenfeld said. > > Or at least, blessed with good timing. Since 1992 the door has been > shut on the little-known program, which began in 1978 and at its height > had no more than about 20 patients. Now, however, the question of > whether the Government should be providing an illegal drug to a chosen > few has been thrust into the spotlight by a new study showing that > marijuana is beneficial for certain conditions, including pain, nausea > and the severe weight loss associated with AIDS. > > The study, the most comprehensive review of the literature about medical > marijuana to date, was commissioned by the White House and conducted by > a committee of 11 scientists appointed by the Institute of Medicine, a > branch of the National Academy of Sciences. A report on the study > concluded that the benefits of smoking marijuana were limited by the > toxic effects of the smoke, but nonetheless recommended that the drug be > given under close supervision to patients who do not respond to other > therapies. > > Yet, it does not appear likely that the list of Government-approved > marijuana smokers will grow any time soon. Indeed, that the program > continues to exist at all is testimony to the Government's schizophrenic > approach to one of the thorniest questions in law and medicine: whether > doctors should be able to write prescriptions for marijuana. > > On the one hand, the Institute on Drug Abuse pays the University of > Mississippi to grow what a spokeswoman called a "consistent, reliable > source of research-grade cannabis" for Rosenfeld and the others. > > A North Carolina manufacturer receives $62,000 a year from the > Government to roll the cigarettes and ship them Federal Express, in > sealed tins of 300 each, to the patients' doctors and pharmacists. > > Rosenfeld, who is 46, carries a folded letter in his wallet, dated March > 17, 1983, from the Food and Drug Administration, authorizing him to use > a substance that might otherwise bring a Federal prison term of up to > five years. Most days, he smokes in his car while driving to work; "I > get no euphoric effect," he said. > > The F.D.A. letter, he added, has been helpful on those rare occasions > that the police have pulled him over. > > On the other hand, Congress has prevented the District of Columbia from > releasing the results of a recent ballot question that asked voters to > decide if marijuana should be made legal for medical purposes. And the > Clinton Administration has moved to shut down marijuana buyers' clubs in > California and has threatened to prosecute doctors who write > prescriptions for the drug. > > "Why allow eight patients to have legal access to marijuana but > criminalize thousands of other patients in very similar circumstances > who have the same conditions, virtually identical medical histories?" > asked Chuck Thomas, spokesman for the Marijuana Policy Project, a > nonprofit group in Washington that lobbies to make the drug legal for > medical use. "Why deny them legal access?" > > That question is now before a Federal judge in Philadelphia, where 165 > patients have filed a lawsuit seeking to force the F.D.A. to grant > wider access to the drug. The the case is scheduled for trial in June. > > "The compassionate access program is an acknowledgment by the Government > of the United States that marijuana has medicinal value," said Lawrence > Hirsch, the lawyer for the patients. "It is fundamentally unfair for > the Government to supply marijuana for medical necessity to eight people > in the United States, when the rest of the potential candidates for > therapeutic cannabis are excluded." > > In response, a spokesman for the Department of Justice argues that > Congress has made the possession and distribution of marijuana illegal > and that the F.D.A. has no obligation to make further exceptions. > > The Government hopes the program will eventually become extinct through > attrition; some of the patients who were enrolled have died. > > Those who remain owe their precious exceptions to a 51-year-old glaucoma > patient, Robert Randall of Sarasota, Fla. While the Institute of > Medicine has found marijuana is not particularly useful for glaucoma, > Randall begs to differ. In 1973, when he was a college student in > Washington, Randall said, he found that smoking marijuana helped ease > the pressure on his eyes. > > "So I grew four little marijuana plants on my sun deck on Capitol Hill, > to make up for those times that I couldn't afford to buy it," he said. > "Then I got arrested." > > As his case worked its way through the legal system, Randall sued the > Federal Government, contending that his smoking was a "medical > necessity." In 1976 a judge agreed, he said, and he began receiving > marijuana under the supervision of a doctor at Howard University. > > But that arrangement unraveled in 1978, and he sued again. The > Government settled the case through the compassionate use program, under > which the F.D.A. gives patients access to unapproved drugs if no other > therapies will help them. > > "The marijuana is mediocre," said Randall, who was the first enrollee. > "It's what you would expect from a Government-controlled monopoly. But > it works." > > Randall later helped others apply, among them Rosenfeld and two Iowa > patients, Barbara Douglass and Ladd Huffman. > > Both have multiple sclerosis, a condition for which the Institute of > Medicine found marijuana beneficial. They met in 1990 after a local > newspaper published an article about Huffman, who had been arrested for > growing the drug in a shed behind his home. In 1991 they applied for > Federal marijuana together. > > Both received F.D.A. approval. Ms. Douglass began receiving the drug > shortly therafter. > > "It relaxes the muscle spasms," she said. > > But the program was shut down before the final paperwork was finished > for Huffman. > > A spokesman for the Department of Health and Human Services said today > that the department determined that the marijuana was no longer > necessary because of the advent of the drug Marinol, a capsule > containing marijuana's active ingredient that was approved by the F.D.A. > in 1985. > > Huffman says Marinol does not work. "With these capsules, you take them > and about an hour later you get so stoned you can hardly function," he > said. But, having been sentenced to two years' probation for his > marijuana offense, he is afraid to smoke the drug again. > > As for Rosenfeld, he has pangs of conscience, knowing that people like > Huffman have been prosecuted for buying a drug he gets courtesy of the > taxpayers. And he worries that his supply could be cut off at any time, > particularly if the Government loses the lawsuit in Philadelphia. > > "I'm not against the Government," he said. "I appreciate what they do > for me." > -- I am sure he does appreciate it! But why is this man allowed to drive his car under the influence of a drug? Isn't that a dangerous game to play? Richard
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<41ABD756.5D76D2E1@bohemianassoc.net>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!g2news1.google.com!news1.google.com!newsread.com!newsprint.newsread.com!logbridge.uoregon.edu!tethys.csu.net!pln-w!spln!dex!extra.newsguy.com!newsp.newsguy.com!news3References:
<41ab8eca$1_4@news.utk.edu>Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
X-Google-Thread: 1111b5,3c383f27c1286def X-Google-Thread: 101049,c6a2f38db01adb75,start X-Google-Thread: 10e16d,c6a2f38db01adb75,start X-Google-Thread: 10fa57,c6a2f38db01adb75,start X-Google-Thread: 103916,3c383f27c1286def X-Google-Attributes: gid1111b5,gid101049,gid10e16d,gid10fa57,gid103916,public X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit Path: arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!g2news1.google.com!news1.google.com!newsread.com!newsprint.newsread.com!logbridge.uoregon.edu!tethys.csu.net!pln-w!spln!dex!extra.newsguy.com!newsp.newsguy.com!news3 From: Richard Garrity <rgarrity@bohemianassoc.net> Newsgroups: tn.general,dc.general,rec.autos.driving,ok.general,tx.general Subject: Re: This man drives while using pot .. legally! Date: Mon, 29 Nov 2004 21:13:42 -0500 Organization: Bohemian Associates Lines: 160 Message-ID: <41ABD756.5D76D2E1@bohemianassoc.net> References: <41ab8eca$1_4@news.utk.edu> NNTP-Posting-Host: p-792.newsdawg.com Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit X-Mailer: Mozilla 4.7 [en] (Win95; I) X-Accept-Language: en