The New University: A State Within the State?

Thread View: ubc.general

3 messages

[T] Back to Threads [V] Tree View [G] Group Articles

3 total messages Started by Nancy Horsman Tue, 23 Nov 1993 02:02

#258

Author: Nancy Horsman
Date: Tue, 23 Nov 1993 02:02

44 lines
3448 bytes


                   A State Within the State:
                         How UBC Works


The University of British Columbia, like its brother institutions
throughout  America  and  Europe, is a legacy of the middle ages,
dated, perhaps, by the charter in 1200 which formally  recognized
the  University of Paris. The charter ensured that the University
should have a tax-free existence and a legal  and  political  in-
dependence.   These   two   guarantees   have  been  the  western
university's by right until the present:  they  support  the  in-
dependence  of thought and integrity of research ("academic free-
dom") which western men of learning have felt to be basic  to  an
institution of advanced education.

The university still enjoys these economic and political freedoms
even  though  its goals and its management practises have changed
drastically.  Now, much  more  a  business  corporation  than  an
academic  institution,  the  university  still  defends "academic
freedom"  against  all  critics,  even  those  who  question  its
privileged business status.

The University of B.C. is a model of corporate design. Under pro-
visions  of  the  B.C. Universities Act, it has tax-free lands to
dispose of as it wishes, and it has full  profit  from  all  real
estate sales within the lands.  It has an internal police system,
a protective legal structure, and a  hierarchical  administrative
organization.

In short, U.B.C. is a state within the larger  state  of  British
Columbia,  and it is ruled by corporation president David Strang-
way. With the sanctions of business and  government,  U.B.C.  has
moved  rapidly  away  from  gentlemanly  agreements  between  the
President and the Deans of Faculty, toward a dictatorial  organi-
zation, powerful, privileged, but not benign.



Nancy Horsman
Formerly Assistant Director
Office for Women Students
U.B.C.

Re: The New University: A State Within the State?

#259

Author: Derek K. Miller
Date: Wed, 24 Nov 1993 19:33

22 lines
2428 bytes

In article <2crr0c$jv8@nntp.ucs.ubc.ca>, leon@chem.ubc.ca (Nancy Horsman)
wrote:
> In short, U.B.C. is a state within the larger  state  of  British
> Columbia,  and it is ruled by corporation president David Strang-
> way. With the sanctions of business and  government,  U.B.C.  has
> moved  rapidly  away  from  gentlemanly  agreements  between  the
> President and the Deans of Faculty, toward a dictatorial  organi-
> zation, powerful, privileged, but not benign.

Very well.

And?

Are you suggesting that removing the tax-free status and so on would
provide us with a better educational institution, or simply that a new
organizational model must be put into place once Strangway retires in 1997?

      :=:=> Derek K. Miller                 dkmiller@unixg.ubc.ca    
      Researcher, Alma Mater Society        thegrodd@tz.ucs.sfu.ca
      Room 230B - 6138 SUB Blvd., Vancouver, B.C. V6T 1Z1
      Campus Mail Zone 1  phone (604) 822-6868  fax (604) 822-9019
      University of British Columbia, Canada

Re: The New University: A State Within the State?

#260

Author: Chris Lewis
Date: Thu, 25 Nov 1993 03:22

32 lines
2722 bytes

In article <dkmiller-241193113316@port55.annex2.net.ubc.ca> dkmiller@unixg.ubc.ca (Derek K. Miller) writes:
|In article <2crr0c$jv8@nntp.ucs.ubc.ca>, leon@chem.ubc.ca (Nancy Horsman)
|wrote:
|> In short, U.B.C. is a state within the larger  state  of  British
|> Columbia,  and it is ruled by corporation president David Strang-
|> way. With the sanctions of business and  government,  U.B.C.  has
|> moved  rapidly  away  from  gentlemanly  agreements  between  the
|> President and the Deans of Faculty, toward a dictatorial  organi-
|> zation, powerful, privileged, but not benign.

|Are you suggesting that removing the tax-free status and so on would
|provide us with a better educational institution, ...

Bizarre how someone figures tax-free status is something unusual about
a non-profit public educational institution mostly funded by the
taxpayers.  Then the leaps of logic to "not benign".

Perhaps not quite so surprising when you notice the amount of cross-posting
this got and Ms. Horsman's signature:

|>Nancy Horsman
|>Formerly Assistant Director
  ^^^^^^^^
|>Office for Women Students
|>U.B.C.

Note followup-to.
-- 
Look on the bright side - at least the PC's reached gender parity!

Chris Lewis; clewis@ferret.ocunix.on.ca; Phone: Canada 613 832-0541
Ferret list: ferret-request@ferret.ocunix.on.ca

Thread Navigation

This is a paginated view of messages in the thread with full content displayed inline.

Messages are displayed in chronological order, with the original post highlighted in green.

Use pagination controls to navigate through all messages in large threads.

Back to All Threads