🚀 go-pugleaf

RetroBBS NetNews Server

Inspired by RockSolid Light RIP Retro Guy

Thread View: gnu.emacs.vm.bug
4 messages
4 total messages Started by Skip Montanaro Mon, 17 Aug 2009 11:28
iso-2022-jp in X-VM-v5-Data: header
#501
Author: Skip Montanaro
Date: Mon, 17 Aug 2009 11:28
77 lines
4475 bytes
I am using VM 8.0.12 more-or-less successfully with Aquamacs 2.0
preview 2 and 1.7.  I encounter repeated problems with errors like
this:

    Wrong type argument: listp, =\?iso-2022-jp\?Q\?

When I open the mbox file as a plain text file and search for
"iso-2022" I invariably find it tucked away in an X-VM-v5-Data: header
in a message near the end of the mbox in a message which most
decidedly does not have an iso-2022-jp encoding.  For example, I see
this right now:

    X-VM-v5-Data: ([nil nil nil nil nil nil nil nil nil]
	    ["15279" "Sunday" "16" "August" "2009" "12:10:44" "-0500" "Carl
M. Zapf\fe" "cmzapffe@comcast.net" nil "266" =?iso-2022-jp?Q?#
("Fra_lein?= Zuffie's Hom\ecoming Party" 0 33 (vm-coding iso-latin-1
vm-charset "ISO-8859-1" vm-string t \charset iso-8859-1) 33 34 (vm-
coding iso-latin-1 vm-charset "ISO-8859-1" vm-str\ing t)) "^From:" nil
nil "8" nil =?iso-2022-jp?Q?#("Fra_lein?= Zuffie's Homecom\ing Party"
0 8 (vm-coding iso-latin-1 vm-charset "ISO-8859-1" vm-string t chars
\et iso-8859-1) 9 17 (vm-coding iso-latin-1 vm-charset "ISO-8859-1" vm-
string t \charset iso-8859-1) 18 28 (vm-coding iso-latin-1 vm-charset
"ISO-8859-1" vm-str\ing t charset iso-8859-1) 29 33 (vm-coding iso-
latin-1 vm-charset "ISO-8859-1" \vm-string t charset iso-8859-1) 33 34
(vm-coding iso-latin-1 vm-charset "ISO-88\59-1" vm-string t)) (number
" " mark "     Carl M. Zapffe    Aug 16  266/15279 \" thread-indent
"\"=?ISO-8859-1?Q?Fra=FClein_Zuffie's_Homecoming_Party?=\"\n") \nil
nil nil nil nil nil nil]

while the subject is iso-8859-1-encoded:

    Subject: =?ISO-8859-1?Q?Fra=FClein_Zuffie's_Homecoming_Party?=

If I delete the offending X-VM-v5-Data: header and reopen the file in
VM it works fine.  For a bit.  It seems the next time I visit that
file though, the error is back.

Here's what I currently see in *Messages* which seems related to the
problem:

    Reading /Users/skip/Mail/mbox... done
    Parsing messages... done
    Reading attributes... done
    963 messages, 0 new, 2 unread, 0 deleted [2 times]
    Checking for new mail for /Users/skip/Mail/mbox...
    Added to /Users/skip/Mail/mbox
    Got mail from ~/incoming/mbox.
    964 messages, 1 new, 2 unread, 0 deleted [2 times]
    Generating summary... 952
    vm-do-summary: Wrong type argument: listp, =\?iso-2022-jp\?Q\?
    Warning: Bug in vm-summary-mode: it forgets to call `run-mode-
hooks'
    Wrong type argument: listp, =\?iso-2022-jp\?Q\?
    Quitting...
    Stuffing attributes...
    1 message to stuff
    Ordering updates...
    Stuffing 100% complete...
    Stuffing attributes... done
    Generating summary... 950
    vm-do-summary: Wrong type argument: listp, =\?iso-2022-jp\?Q\?
    Warning: Bug in vm-mode: it forgets to call `run-mode-hooks'
    Wrong type argument: listp, =\?iso-2022-jp\?Q\?
    Buffer mbox modified; kill anyway? (y or n)
    Warning: Bug in vm-presentation-mode: it forgets to call `run-mode-
hooks'
    Mark saved where search started
    Mark set
    Mark saved where search started
    Loading vm-revno...done
    VM version is: 8.0.12

Let me know if I can provide more details or do some further debugging
(enable various debug settings, etc).

Skip Montanaro
skip@pobox.com
Re: iso-2022-jp in X-VM-v5-Data: header
#197
Author: Uday S Reddy
Date: Thu, 19 Nov 2009 18:58
13 lines
1610 bytes
Skip Montanaro wrote:
> I am using VM 8.0.12 more-or-less successfully with Aquamacs 2.0
> preview 2 and 1.7.  I encounter repeated problems with errors like
> this:
> 
>     Wrong type argument: listp, =\?iso-2022-jp\?Q\?

Dear Skip, There were clear bugs mentioned in the *Messages* buffer.
Would you like to try out the version 8.1 I announced in the vm.info
newsgroup, and see if it solves the problems?

Thanks,
Uday
Re: iso-2022-jp in X-VM-v5-Data: header
#198
Author: Uday S Reddy
Date: Sat, 21 Nov 2009 16:47
49 lines
3307 bytes
The problem that has occurred is that VM wrote a badly-formed 
X-VM-v5-Data header.  Here is the header again, formatted a bit more 
clearly:

([nil nil nil nil nil nil nil nil nil]
  ["15279" "Sunday" "16" "August" "2009" "12:10:44" "-0500"
   "Carl M. Zapf\fe" "cmzapffe@comcast.net" nil "266"
   =?iso-2022-jp?Q?#("Fra_lein?= Zuffie's Hom\ecoming Party" 0 33
		    (vm-coding iso-latin-1 vm-charset "ISO-8859-1"
			       vm-string t \charset iso-8859-1)
		    33 34 (vm-coding iso-latin-1 vm-charset
				     "ISO-8859-1" vm-str\ing t))
   "^From:" nil nil "8" nil
   =?iso-2022-jp?Q?#("Fra_lein?= Zuffie's Homecom\ing Party"
		    0 8 (vm-coding iso-latin-1 vm-charset "ISO-8859-1"
				   vm-string t chars \et iso-8859-1)
		    9 17 (vm-coding iso-latin-1 vm-charset
				    "ISO-8859-1" vm-string t \charset
				    iso-8859-1)
		    18 28 (vm-coding iso-latin-1 vm-charset
				     "ISO-8859-1" vm-str\ing t charset
				     iso-8859-1)
		    29 33 (vm-coding iso-latin-1 vm-charset
				     "ISO-8859-1" \vm-string t charset
				     iso-8859-1)
		    33 34 (vm-coding iso-latin-1 vm-charset
				     "ISO-88\59-1" vm-string t))
   (number " " mark
	  "     Carl M. Zapffe    Aug 16  266/15279 "
	  thread-indent
	  "\"=?ISO-8859-1?Q?Fra=FClein_Zuffie's_Homecoming_Party?=\"\n")
   \nil nil nil nil nil nil nil]

There are three copies of the subject string here: "Fraulein Zuffie's 
Homecoming Party" (written in ASCII).  The last copy is good.  That is 
how the string is supposed to appear.  The first two copies are some 
badly corrupted versions of the string.  We have to figure out where 
they are coming from.  Some change that was incorporated between 
revisions 610 and 623 is causing this.  That is a guess.  I am guessing 
that revision 610 was all right because it was merged into the devo 
version, which I use, and I haven't noticed the problem.  Revision 623 
was released as v8.0.12.

Here is a pointer to the revisions:

   http://bazaar.launchpad.net/~hack-robf/viewmail/vm-8.0.x/changes

Cheers,
Uday
Re: iso-2022-jp in X-VM-v5-Data: header
#199
Author: Uday S Reddy
Date: Sat, 21 Nov 2009 17:07
26 lines
2204 bytes
Uday S Reddy wrote:

> Here is a pointer to the revisions:
> 
>   http://bazaar.launchpad.net/~hack-robf/viewmail/vm-8.0.x/changes

Oh, you would notice that the revision 624 claims to have fixed the 
problem and the revision 625 also has a clean up routine to 
automatically clean badly formed v5-Data headers.  It is possible that 
these fixes work.  But I can't be entirely sure because I didn't find a 
mapvector procedure (which was used in revision 624).

If you would like to try out the revision 625 and see if it works 
correctly, you can use this mapvector procedure:

(defun mapvector (proc vec)
   (let ((new-vec (make-vector (length vec) nil))
	(i 0)
	(n (length vec)))
     (while (< i n)
       (aset new-vec i (apply proc (aref vec i) nil))
       (setq i (1+ i)))
     new-vec))

Cheers,
Uday
Thread Navigation

This is a paginated view of messages in the thread with full content displayed inline.

Messages are displayed in chronological order, with the original post highlighted in green.

Use pagination controls to navigate through all messages in large threads.

Back to All Threads