Article View: sci.philosophy.tech
Article #754Re: FREE WILL 2: Neither a Determinist nor an Indeterminist be.
From: flockoff
Date: Wed, 16 Dec 1992 03:30
Date: Wed, 16 Dec 1992 03:30
28 lines
1657 bytes
1657 bytes
Hi, I just thought I'd put in my 2c worth on this topic. Firstly I am a hard and fast determanist, with the inherent belief that free-will is an illusion. I have however no problem equating this belief with the atribution of praise or blame on peoples actions. Reasoning follows : I think the crucial question is - Why do we wish to apportion blame or praise? The answer is surely (hopefully :-), because by praising or blaming we hope to make people behave in the future the way we want them to. So if someone, through no free-choice of their own blows someones head off, then it is perfectly reasonable to punish them severly because this will hopefully lead to premisses something like these entering into their brain machine If I'm bad -> I'll get punished If I'm punished -> I'll be unhappy. Axiom - try to make (happy)=T - (Initialized at boot up:-) so by MTTs they won't be bad, which is surely the only point of praise and blame. This is probably really stupid but I thought I'd find out what was wrong with it anyway. Bye ------------------------------------------------------------ Peter Grooby - Lincoln University - NZ Probably bet not to email me at above address as I probably won't get it. Thanx.
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<1992Dec16.163051.324@lincoln.ac.nz>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!sparky!uunet!comp.vuw.ac.nz!canterbury.ac.nz!lincoln.ac.nz!flockoffReferences:
<spurrett.75.723752038@superbowl.und.ac.za> <spurrett.96.724338679@superbowl.und.ac.za>Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
Path: arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!sparky!uunet!comp.vuw.ac.nz!canterbury.ac.nz!lincoln.ac.nz!flockoff From: flockoff@lincoln.ac.nz Newsgroups: sci.philosophy.tech Subject: Re: FREE WILL 2: Neither a Determinist nor an Indeterminist be. Message-ID: <1992Dec16.163051.324@lincoln.ac.nz> Date: 16 Dec 92 16:30:50 +1300 References: <spurrett.75.723752038@superbowl.und.ac.za> <spurrett.96.724338679@superbowl.und.ac.za> Lines: 28