Article View: torfree.general
Article #613Re: Vanishing minutes?
From: Nabil M. El-Khodari (FITS)
Date: Sun, 19 Jan 1997 00:00
Date: Sun, 19 Jan 1997 00:00
238 lines
11241 bytes
11241 bytes
------------37D815E928832 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Richard van Abbe wrote: > > On Sat, 18 Jan 1997 16:52:10 GMT, ab756@torfree.net (Graham Bullers) > wrote: > > =>It is true that at the last board meeting the board voted to give each > =>board member $3000 towards a new computer,is this why the minutes of the > =>last meeting are not posted? > > No, that is NOT true. And if there IS such a rumor going around, it is > absurd in the extreme. I do agree with Richard here. I think Graham has just succeeded in getting a response. > No Board member has been given or promised ANY money, for ANY reason, > by this or previous Boards of Directors. Agree completely, not any direct payments were ever promised or given to current board members (It would appear that I am very cautious here, due to lack of information, but I am almost certain that this also applies to all previous board members. The trick Graham is that you are putting current and previous board members on the defensive, i.e. asking them to provide proof of innocence, an old dirty trick in my opinion. The proof of guilt is the onus of the accuser. Every body is innocent until proven otherwise. > The draft minutes of the last meeting contained several errors that > are being corrected. When they are, the minutes will be posted as > usual. I do feel a contradiction here. As usual implies that they will not be published :-) May be it is time to tell the membership what were the things that needed correction. It is also time to post the previous board minutes prior to January 9th as approved by the board, unless they are being 'corrected' too. > This Board has certainly been beset by some daunting difficulties, > as everyone who has been following the saga of the Toronto Free-Net > knows. But I can assure you that despite the normal differences of > opinion and vision, everyone connected with this Board is selflessly > committed to saving and improving this institution for its current and > future members. Well, if that includes me too, I would certainly agree with caution, taking decisions and votes as a sign of difference in 'opinion'. > Speaking for myself, if I thought for a minute that anyone was > profiting financially by his/her leadership position in TFN I would > quit instantly, and air that dirty laundry for all to see. What if not a board member? Would the same apply? > Besides, if this rumor were, in fact, true, TFN would at this moment > be bankrupt and out of business. And although it's no secret that we > are not in good shape, we are not yet bankrupt, either. Depends on your definition of bankruptcy. If you follow the traditional definition that only restricts 'bankruptcy' to declaring bankruptcy in response to overwhelming request of paying bills that could not be processed in time and the 'debtor' had to resort to courts to get its money, I would agree completely. However, if you imply that the current board is not in debt or does have concrete resources to pail TFN out, then I would challenge you to prove it. Sometimes, the truth is your way out. > So let's try to quell the wild rumors and paranoia, shall we? Nothing > can possibly be more effective in bringing about our demise. The wild rumors was brought about by your summary excution, your lack of adherance to the by-laws, etc. These are the most effective weapons to bring about the TFN demise. As for paranoia, you mean like that practiced by the board itself? Unless of course the board is not practicing paranoia but ....... The facts will come out Richard, whether you do it yourself as the Excutive Director, or is brought about by other ways. You are well advised to study in detail the Allisat affair, where the previous board tried to keep its dealings with the matter a 'secret'. It may not be a bad idea that the board meetings should be 'on camera sessions' to determine what exactly took place and by whom. The ommission of mentioning the names of board members with, against and abstaining leaves a lot to be desired. Again may be the practices of the previous board - particularly in minutes and sessions - be an excellent guide. -- Nabil M. El-Khodari HTML Writers Guild mailto:fits@4u.net Web designer Software Contractors' Guild Tel.: (416) 762-5135 http://www.geocities.com/RainForest/3285/ Fax.: (416) 762-3490 President, FITS (Falcon International Teleco./Translation Services) ------------37D815E928832 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Content-Type: text/html; charset=us-ascii <HTML><BODY> <DT>Richard van Abbe wrote:<BR> > <BR> > On Sat, 18 Jan 1997 16:52:10 GMT, ab756@torfree.net (Graham Bullers)<BR> > wrote:<BR> > <BR> > =>It is true that at the last board meeting the board voted to give each<BR> > =>board member $3000 towards a new computer,is this why the minutes of the<BR> > =>last meeting are not posted?<BR> > <BR> > No, that is NOT true. And if there IS such a rumor going around, it is<BR> > absurd in the extreme.</DT> <DT> </DT> <DT>I do agree with Richard here. I think Graham has just succeeded in getting a response.</DT> <DT><BR> > No Board member has been given or promised ANY money, for ANY reason,<BR> > by this or previous Boards of Directors.<BR> <BR></DT> <DT>Agree completely, not any direct payments were ever promised or given to current board members (It would appear that I am very cautious here, due to lack of information, but I am almost certain that this also applies to all previous board members. The trick Graham is that you are putting current and previous board members on the defensive, i.e. asking them to provide proof of innocence, an old dirty trick in my opinion. The proof of guilt is the onus of the accuser. Every body is innocent until proven otherwise.</DT> <DT> </DT> <DT>> The draft minutes of the last meeting contained several errors that<BR> > are being corrected. When they are, the minutes will be posted as<BR> > usual.<BR> <BR></DT> <DT>I do feel a contradiction here. As usual implies that they will not be published :-) May be it is time to tell the membership what were the things that needed correction. It is also time to post the previous board minutes prior to January 9th as approved by the board, unless they are being 'corrected' too.</DT> <DT><BR> > This Board has certainly been beset by some daunting difficulties,<BR> > as everyone who has been following the saga of the Toronto Free-Net<BR> > knows. But I can assure you that despite the normal differences of<BR> > opinion and vision, everyone connected with this Board is selflessly<BR> > committed to saving and improving this institution for its current and<BR> > future members.<BR> <BR></DT> <DT>Well, if that includes me too, I would certainly agree with caution, taking decisions and votes as a sign of difference in 'opinion'. </DT> <DT><BR> > Speaking for myself, if I thought for a minute that anyone was<BR> > profiting financially by his/her leadership position in TFN I would<BR> > quit instantly, and air that dirty laundry for all to see.<BR> <BR></DT> <DT>What if not a board member? Would the same apply?</DT> <DT><BR> > Besides, if this rumor were, in fact, true, TFN would at this moment<BR> > be bankrupt and out of business. And although it's no secret that we<BR> > are not in good shape, we are not yet bankrupt, either.<BR> <BR></DT> <DT>Depends on your definition of bankruptcy. If you follow the traditional definition that only restricts 'bankruptcy' to declaring bankruptcy in response to overwhelming request of paying bills that could not be processed in time and the 'debtor' had to resort to courts to get its money, I would agree completely.</DT> <DT> </DT> <DT>However, if you imply that the current board is not in debt or does have concrete resources to pail TFN out, then I would challenge you to prove it. Sometimes, the truth is your way out.</DT> <DT> </DT> <DT>> So let's try to quell the wild rumors and paranoia, shall we? Nothing<BR> > can possibly be more effective in bringing about our demise.<BR> <BR></DT> <DT>The wild rumors was brought about by your summary excution, your lack of adherance to the by-laws, etc. These are the most effective weapons to bring about the TFN demise. As for paranoia, you mean like that practiced by the board itself? Unless of course the board is not practicing paranoia but .......</DT> <DT> </DT> <DT>The facts will come out Richard, whether you do it yourself as the Excutive Director, or is brought about by other ways. You are well advised to study in detail the Allisat affair, where the previous board tried to keep its dealings with the matter a 'secret'. It may not be a bad idea that the board meetings should be 'on camera sessions' to determine what exactly took place and by whom. The ommission of mentioning the names of board members with, against and abstaining leaves a lot to be desired. Again may be the practices of the previous board - particularly in minutes and sessions - be an excellent guide. <BR> -- <BR> Nabil M. El-Khodari HTML Writers Guild mailto:fits@4u.net<BR> Web designer Software Contractors' Guild Tel.: (416) 762-5135<BR> http://www.geocities.com/RainForest/3285/ Fax.: (416) 762-3490<BR> President, FITS (Falcon International Teleco./Translation Services)<BR> </DT> </BODY> </HTML> ------------37D815E928832--
Technical Details
Message-ID:
<32E23642.6280@4u.net>Path:
arc1-ca.pugleaf.net!unknown!not-for-mailReferences:
<E47HH3.Hvo.0.queen@torfree.net> <E47qv0.CpL.0.bloor@torfree.net> <5bss5u$25m@nnrp1.toronto.ican.net>Show Full Headers
Complete Article Headers
X-Google-Language: ENGLISH,ASCII-7-bit X-Google-Thread: 10643c,ccac5bba4e3a7a29,start X-Google-Attributes: gid10643c,public X-Google-Thread: 10aaae,ccac5bba4e3a7a29,start X-Google-Attributes: gid10aaae,public X-Google-Thread: 1511e9,ccac5bba4e3a7a29,start X-Google-Attributes: gid1511e9,public X-Google-Thread: 103731,ccac5bba4e3a7a29,start X-Google-Attributes: gid103731,public From: "Nabil M. El-Khodari (FITS)" <fits@4u.net> Subject: Re: Vanishing minutes? Date: 1997/01/19 Message-ID: <32E23642.6280@4u.net> X-Deja-AN: 211012833 references: <E47HH3.Hvo.0.queen@torfree.net> <E47qv0.CpL.0.bloor@torfree.net> <5bss5u$25m@nnrp1.toronto.ican.net> to: scribe@ican.net x-sender: "Nabil M. El-Khodari (FITS)" <fits@4u.net> (Unverified) x-priority: Normal content-type: multipart/alternative; boundary="----------37D815E928832" organization: Falcon International Telecommunication/Translation Services mime-version: 1.0 reply-to: fits@4u.net newsgroups: torfree.general,torfree.policy,tor.general,can.infohighway x-mailer: Mozilla 4.0b1 (Win95; I)